MTN’S DROPPED CALLS
Acquiring Celtel would have been a perfect fit for MTN and would have put the SA company in an unassailable position as the leading telecom operator on the continent. Celtel has 6m customers in 13 countries, with little overlap with the markets in which MTN operates.
The failed bid underscores the difficulties MTN faces as it tries to maintain its stellar earnings growth. The question is whether CEO Phuthuma Nhleko can pull off deals that will maintain MTN’s earnings and revenue momentum.
Some analysts say MTN may be running out of expansion opportunities. They say it’s doubtful it will find another market as large and lucrative as a Nigeria, its most successful outside SA. And, says one, opportunities such as the one offered by Celtel don’t come round often.
Without a good deal or two in the bag, MTN could become a takeover target of one of the big global players. But with a market value of more than R70bn, it would be a big swallow.
"MTN has to put a serious deal together soon," says an executive close to the telecom sector. "It’s bungled a few and hasn’t managed to pull off anything major since Nigeria," he says. He concurs that inaction by MTN could leave it open to a takeover.
But for the moment, it’s party time for MTN investors. The group reported another stellar set of financial results last week. In the year to March 2005, subscriber numbers leapt 50% and earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (Ebitda) surged 33% to R12bn. Ebitda margin grew from 38% to 41,5% and profit after tax jumped 47% to R7,3bn. The bulk of earnings came from Nigeria and SA .
But the competitive challenges and risks are growing, particularly in these two markets. The next few years will test the mettle of Nhleko and his management team.
Even as the group shoots the lights out with its earnings growth, there are problems ahead. Average revenue per user (Arpu) – a key financial measure for cellphone operators – is declining in all the markets in which it operates, but it has fallen particularly sharply in Nigeria in recent months. Competition is also becoming more intense, with growing pressure to reduce prices.
The group is actively seeking international expansion opportunities. It operates networks in SA, Nigeria, Cameroon, Uganda, Rwanda, Swaziland and Mauritius. In Nigeria, it is the leading operator with 4,4m subscribers in a market that is estimated to grow from today’s 9m to 27m by 2009.
MTN’s international expansion efforts have been stuck in first gear since the Nigeria deal was struck in 2001. Since then it has failed to secure licences in Saudi Arabia, Kenya, Oman, Iran and Algeria. These failures have led to concerns that MTN may be running out of expansion opportunities in Africa and the Middle East, the terrain it has set its sights on.
Nhleko is confident there are other potential acquisitions and new licence opportunities will present themselves soon. He says there are still "quite a few" potential targets, though they are smaller than Celtel.
Nhleko says the company is looking for opportunities "all the time". Last year he created a new division, headed by MTN stalwart Irene Charnley, whose sole purpose is identifying offshore opportunities. The largest prospects in Africa, outside Nigeria and SA, are Egypt, Algeria and Morocco, Nhleko says. There are also potential opportunities in mid-sized markets such as Côte d’Ivoire, Sudan and Angola. Third licences are soon to be issued in Egypt and Angola.
MTN has also set up an office in Iran, though Nhleko says the group is not currently pursuing a licensing opportunity there. "Too much is made of the Iranian office. It’s just one person trying to understand the sector there," he says. "Africa is our territory but we have also indicated that if an opportunity in the Middle East presents itself, we will explore it."
Even Asia is also not completely out of the question. "If something came up that would make a sensible regional play, we’d look at it, but we won’t go to a small country for 200 000 subscribers."
Nhleko says MTN has positioned itself financially to take advantage of acquisition opportunities. He says this was behind the company’s decision to retain its vast cash reserves of R5,8bn instead of paying a higher dividend.
Though MTN was generous in doling out 65c/share compared with last year’s 41c/share, the R1bn dividend payout compared unfavourably with Vodacom’s R3,4bn, one of the largest in SA corporate history.
Nhleko must use the money wisely. Nigeria could be coming off the boil. In the 2005 financial year, it contributed R4,9bn, or 41%, of group Ebitda earnings . At 52%, it has the highest Ebitda margin of any of MTN’s operations.
That might not last. MTN’s spectacular growth in Nigeria could come under significant pressure in the next few years as competition builds. SA rival Vodacom is likely to put up a robust fight if it is successful in its joint bid, with Richard Branson’s Virgin Group, for Vee Networks, the holding company of Nigeria’s second-largest operator, Vmobile. Vodacom says it will invest R6bn-R9bn in expanding Vmobile’s network and distribution channels in an effort to chip away at MTN’s commanding 47% share of the market.
MTN itself is spending big on its network expansion in Nigeria. Capital expenditure of R5,5bn in 2005 will be matched with a further R7bn in 2006. These are large sums compared with the R1,7bn MTN spent in SA in 2005.
MTN has dramatically accelerated its network roll-out programme, which has helped alleviate congestion problems that had led to complaints about service.
Nhleko plays down the potential threat Vodacom poses to MTN in Nigeria, though he concedes there could be problems if there is "irrational and destructive competition".
MTN faces other challenges in Nigeria. The exceptionally high margins it earned in the first phase are coming under pressure. The first sign of this is that its Arpu has fallen sharply. Arpu fell 22% between 2004 and 2005, to an average US$40/year. At the end of the reporting period, though, it had fallen sharply again, to just $27. Nhleko expects marginal Arpu to fall into the teens in the 2006 financial year.
He attributes the fall to an acceleration in subscriber numbers, which rose 123% last year, on the back of a much-reduced connection fee, as well as a new, more liberal interpretation of what constitutes a subscriber. Whereas early customers tended to be wealthier and spend more, subsequent subscribers are poorer.
Nhleko says the decline in Arpu has been "slightly faster" than expected but he says MTN will try to offset this by introducing new services, such as data access, to corporate and high-end users.
There’s also political and regulatory risk associated with doing business in Nigeria where the government is notorious for changing regulations that govern business activity.
"There are definitely tensions in Nigeria," says an executive close to the African telecom market. "There are issues with the Nigerian government, which is being lobbied by people who say Nigerians are being sidelined for South Africans in the top jobs." He adds that "it requires a deft hand to manage the relationship with government".
But Nhleko is looking for growth beyond Nigeria. He is convinced there is still considerable growth lef
t in the markets in which MTN already operates. "We’ve been focusing on simply growing voice. We haven’t even begun to provide a broader suite of services in all the markets," he says.
In SA, a maturing market, MTN faces an altogether different set of challenges. The market, arguably more competitive than Nigeria’s, is expected to approach saturation in the next few years at just over 30m customers, from today’s 23m. Today, MTN says it has a market share of 39% (Vodacom claims 56% and Cell C 12% for an impossible total of 107%).
The challenges MTN faces in SA are multifaceted:
* Mobile operators will soon be required to implement number portability, which will lead to higher churn.
* Price competition is becoming more intense, particularly in data services Hoping to steal an early lead in mobile Internet access, Vodacom slashed its data rates by more than 90% last year, forcing MTN and Cell C to follow suit. But there is also price competition in voice services. Says Nhleko: "The competitive situation in SA is quite hot [and] resulted in the subscriber acquisition cost for post-paid [contract customers] being somewhat higher than we would have liked."
* Capital expenditure is rising as the company rolls out new, high-speed networks. It hopes these new networks will help it increase data’s contribution to revenues. Whereas only 6% of MTN SA’s revenues are generated by data (Internet access and text messages) this is as high as 20% in some developed markets. Nhleko wants data to contribute 8%-10% of revenues in the year to March 2006.
* There is a perception that Vodacom has taken a technological lead over MTN in recent months. Vodacom was the first to switch on a high-speed third-generation (3G) network. MTN is scheduled to launch its 3G network commercially at the end of this month.
Vodacom also made much of its launch of the BlackBerry e-mail device. Nhleko says the perception that Vodacom has a technological lead has no basis in reality. He says it’s important to balance speed-to-market and return on investment. "We could fairly rapidly roll out a massive 3G network but it must coincide with demand and availability of handsets." As for BlackBerry, Nhleko says MTN was first to introduce the device in SA. Vodacom, he says, created the false impression that it was first to introduce the BlackBerry because of an aggressive advertising campaign.
* At 34%, MTN SA’s Ebitda margin remains comparatively low next to its international peers. Nhleko hopes to raise this figure in the next few years by, among other things, restructuring its distribution channel. Similar sentiments have been expressed by Vodacom CEO Alan Knott-Craig. But it’s not clear how the two companies might do this, short of acquiring independent service providers Nashua Mobile and Altech subsidiary Autopage Cellular.
"In a market the size of SA, which is dominated by two players, why are Ebitda margins comparatively so poor?" Nhleko believes it’s because SA has "long and costly distribution chains" not found in markets such as the UK.
MTN SA MD Maanda Manyatshe, who joined the operator in November after a successful stint at the Post Office, says he wants to "own" his entire customer base, something that is not possible while there are still independent service providers in the market.
* The Convergence Bill, currently before parliament, will provide the legal framework under which mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) can be licensed. These operators will piggyback on existing cellular networks, though they will build their own brands and manage their clients directly. In markets where they have been introduced, MVNOs have helped drive down prices and reduced the profit margins of the incumbent operators. Richard Branson’s Virgin Group is expected to announce plans to enter the SA market as an MVNO piggybacking on Cell C, and Autopage has said it has similar plans.
MTN will not provide services to potential MVNOs, Nhleko says. "Before MTN’s brand was as strong as it is today, this is something we considered. But the pricing arrangements we’d have had to enter into were not attractive to us." He is not too concerned about the competitive impact they might have.
The competitive pressures might be growing but Nhleko says MTN still sees opportunities in SA, particularly as convergence gathers pace. MTN, he says, has always been keen to work closely with a fixed-line operator to offer data solutions. "We do not necessarily want to be a shareholder in a fixed-line operator but we would like to have a synergistic relationship with whoever eventually becomes the second network operator (SNO)," he says.
MTN is already indirectly involved in the fixed-line market through corporate-focused Internet service provider (ISP) MTN Network Solutions (MTNNS), in which it holds 60% (the other 40% is held by Johnnic Communications). MTNNS is licensed as a value-added network service (Vans) provider, which means it provides services on top of the networks provided by fixed-line operators (currently only Telkom).
Nhleko says the Convergence Bill, when it is enacted, could spur mergers between Vans operators. Though it’s still "early days", he says he "will not dismiss the possibility" of MTN buying another Vans operator to give it critical mass in data services. MTN is rumoured to have held talks last year with UUNet, the country’s second-largest corporate-focused ISP .. It’s also said to have expressed an interest in the planned sale by Nedcor and Old Mutual of their combined 40% stake in Dimension Data-controlled Internet Solutions, SA’s largest ISP.
"Looking at MTN’s future business model, it would make sense for it to have a closer relationship with [Vans operators]," says Manyatshe, adding that MTN is in discussions with Johncom to acquire the latter’s stake in MTNNS. "We’d like to bolster MTNNS and integrate it completely into MTN SA."
Manyatshe says MTN’s legal team is scrutinising the Convergence Bill to determine what the company will and won’t be able to do. One option, though unlikely, is that MTN will build its own fixed-line network to service corporate clients. The operator would prefer to form a partnership with either Telkom (unlikely given that Telkom owns 50% of Vodacom) or with the SNO.
Reproduced with the permission of the Financial Mail
Source: secure.financialmail.co.za/05/0617/cover/coverstory.htm