Technology19.07.2005

Another flip-flop feared

The topic of self-provision has been a hot potato in the debate around competition and deregulation in the telecoms industry, particularly since the apparent flip-flop by Communications Minister Ivy Matsepe-Casaburri on the eve of her deregulation announcement on 1 February. VANS had believed they would be able to build their own networks, instead of being forced to buy the use of facilities from the incumbents, but Matsepe-Casaburri turned around and said they would not be allowed to do so.

Dominic Cull, ICT (information and communication technology) lawyer and associate at Nicci Ferguson Inc says the final licence terms and conditions, published last week by Icasa, allow self-provision, “thereby adding a further twist to the ongoing ‘can they or can’t they’ saga set in motion by the ministerial determination of 2 September 2004 (they can) and the following ministerial clarification (they can’t).”

The document says licensees may provide their services – which now also include voice – “by means of facilities obtained from any other person licensed to provide telecommunication services in terms of the act.” In terms of the Telecommunications Act, says Cull, this includes Private Telephone Networks (PTNs) as well as players like Sentech and Wireless Business Solutions. So in other words, just about anyone.

Cull says although the regulations are final, it is interesting that the big players in the industry are still adopting a wait-and-see approach, possibly fearing another flip-flop. This is particularly the case given that the Convergence Bill, which is anticipated will be promulgated towards the end of the year, effectively doesn’t seem to allow self-provision.

Cull says one the primary roles of a regulator is to ensure certainty in a sector, but Icasa has not been able to fulfil this mandate, largely due to uncertainty of the role of the Department of Communications (DoC) and its preferred policies. The uncertainty in this sector means “it is almost impossible for anyone in the arena to do any planning on the ground.”

The Internet Service Providers Association’s (ISPA) Ant Brooks says the terms and conditions leave the issue of self-provision open to interpretation. Which is why the industry is adopting a wait-and-see approach. But, even if players wanted to go ahead and self-provide, their hands are tied for the moment.

Self-provision would either require digging up roads for cables, which is expensive and thus an unlikely course of action by most players, but would also require municipality approval. The other route, of building wireless networks, would require access to the frequency spectrum, which is not yet being invited by Icasa. Many people are already building wireless networks, making use of a grey area, the unlicensed ISM band, but this is not considered legal.

Cull says that many people are already setting up wireless networks – even including some of the municipalities – is increasingly rendering the law less relevant.

Of concern is Icasa’s capacity to deliver, particularly after the Convergence Bill has been promulgated, says Cull. The bill introduces an entirely new system of licenses, which would require considerable legwork to implement.

Brooks said although the VANS licence terms and conditions were pretty simple (which is always good), it would have been nice to see the issue of frequency mentioned.

Encouragingly, the terms and conditions do facilitate other key elements that will enable the VANS to provide proper voice services. Such as giving them the right to interconnect with other licensed telecoms service providers, and to apply for numbering resources. Brooks said this had been expected.

Director for business development at telecommunications service provider Storm Dave Gale says although players like itself are now legally allowed to self-provide, the minister made it clear this was not her intention. As a result, it is unlikely they would be able to do so once the Convergence Bill has been promulgated.

The topic was hot one at the recent colloquium called by the DoC aimed at examining why telecoms costs are so high, with the VANS saying this was the key way to encourage competition and thus bring down prices. But, Gale says the DoC has effectively painted itself into a corner by not moving fast enough to get the second network operator (SNO) up and running. The business case of players like the SNO and multi-media licensee Sentech is based in part on being able to provide telecoms facilities, and the slow process has closed the window of opportunity that earlier licensing would have afforded. The danger of allowing the VANS to self-provide now could kill the fledgling SNO and Sentech.

The industry hardly needed a colloquium to identify that costs will come down if operators like the VANS are able to build their own networks. Sadly for consumers, however, it doesn’t seem this will be one cost barrier broken down any time soon.

Source:  http://www.moneyweb.co.za

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter