Leave us alone!
Speaking at the Unisa School of Business Leadership (SBL) on Wednesday evening, Knott-Craig said unless cellular industry shareholders could be convinced of a healthy return on their investment, there would have been no incentive for them to invest in the first place. It is the lure of juicy returns that has so far seen R50-bn invested into the cellular industry infrastructure. And, the industry could require further investment of R100-bn or more in infrastructure over the next ten years in order to keep abreast of new technologies.
Knott-Craig’s assertions come in the midst of a growing backlash against the perceived high tariffs charged by the cellular industry. But, Knott-Craig says there has been little consideration of the industry’s complexity in making this judgement call. Investment, investment, investment There are currently more than 25-m cellular subscribers in South Africa, and Knott-Craig believes penetration levels – currently at 50% of the population – could easily rise to upwards of 75% in less than 5 years. But, the environment has to be right for continued investment. He attributes the remarkable success story of cellular in South Africa partly to competition and partly due to the practice of subsidising handsets, an industry policy that is currently being reviewed for its fairness by the regulator Icasa. Knott-Craig is adamant that subscriber growth will collapse if phone subsidisation is disallowed. Although only the upper-end spenders take out contracts and thus qualify for ‘free’ handsets, Knott-Craig says every subsidised phone ultimately finds its way into the pre-paid market. Knott-Craig believes it is far more important to reduce the barriers to entry for consumers than to lower tariffs. He argues that countries with low tariffs also have low penetration because investors have little incentive to invest in developing the network coverage and functionality. “Prices are much less relevant than you’d imagine. Countries with the cheapest prices have the lowest penetration,” he says. And besides, South Africa’s tariffs are not among the most expensive in the world; on a comparable basis, ours are roughly mid-range, says Knott-Craig. But, those that are the cheapest are Vodacom’s community service phones, where tariffs are roughly a quarter of the normal pre-paid rate here. So, it is common practice for people to have a phone for receiving calls, but to make their calls using the community service phones, which is another factor one must consider in the market structure before just lumping the whole country together as an expensive cellular market, says Knott-Craig. One must also consider the way the tariff environment is structured in order to make proper comparisons, he says. For example, here voice mail retrieval is free, whereas in other countries it is charged for. And the same for the connection cost of becoming a pre-paid subscriber; other countries charge for this. He warns that any attempts to tamper with the industry’s complex pricing model could be disasterous. Competitive forces in the market, he says, should set prices, as they currently do. “As soon as you tell investors how much money they can make, they go away,” warns Knott-Craig of regulating pricing. “Don’t stick your finger into the pie and think the whole thing won’t collapse.” If prices were too high, the market would not have grown as much as it has, he asserts. The role of the regulator Knott-Craig says the only job of the regulator in a competitive environment – which he believes South Africa most definitely is – is to do whatever required of it to increase penetration and to encourage further investment in the sector. Anything beyond that is superfluous and can even be destructive. “The most important thing for government and regulators is how to attract private investors.” And when a sector is operating effectively, then the importance of a good, strong (fair and effective) competition authority – like that which is in place in South Africa in the form of the Competition Commission – kicks in. But, the regulators must only step in when a dominant player is abusing that dominance, not just because they are dominant – discouraging dominance is encouraging people to lose, says Knott-Craig. “You can’t say you are a capitalist society and then punish people when they make a profit,” he says. Apart from having a go at the regulator, Knott-Craig also indirectly had a dig at Virgin ahead of its imminent tie-up with Cell C. He said it could not be classed as investment when someone bought wholesale minutes and on sold them. It was first thought that Virgin might undertake a MVNO (mobile virtual network operator) model, like in other countries, but given regulatory constraints, it seems more likely it will be more of an enhanced service provider to Cell C. But, either way, Virgin would not be building its own network. Knott-Craig is also sceptical about how successful the second network operator (SNO) will be and what kind of impact it will have on prices. “I wish the SNO good luck,” he said. He said people tended to think that just because Telkom didn’t have a fixed line competitor that it didn’t already have competition, when it was in fact competing fiercely with the mobile operators. But, where its losing out on subscriber growth, it is gaining in traffic on its network backbone, over which all traffic must still flow in stages. Although other operators can build their own networks following government’s February liberalisation announcements, Knott-Craig says there are not doing so because it is cheaper to rent such facilities from Telkom. One possible barrier to a healthy industry is the Convergence Bill. Knott-Craig says in its current form, the bill would be hugely problematic, but seems convinced that it will be changed to address some of the problems before promulgation. Crystal ball gazing In ten years time, says Knott-Craig, there will be no such thing as telephone numbers – people’s names will be used as their telecoms identity (number portability, which allows you to keep your number no matter the network, comes in later this year or early next, and is the first step). And all communication will be carried out via a single device and be technology neutral, i.e. the consumer won’t know or need to care what technology he or she is using to make the call, or send the email etc. Telecoms will be so ubiquitous, that it will be like water: “No one thinks about the price of a shower.” So where does this leave the telecoms companies – if they are to become faceless, nameless utilities?Knott-Craig uses the analogy of going to a restaurant, where one might go to the bathroom to wash his or her hands before dinner, not sparing a thought for the cost of the water, and then sitting down and paying for a bottle of mineral water. “That’s going to be the salvation of the cellular industry.”