Technology4.08.2005

Is there real competition?

These were presented on the second day of hearings held by regulator Icasa as part of its enquiry into the effect of handset subsidies on the market.

At hand is the issue of whether there is real competition between the three operators; if there isn’t, then the market has failed and might require regulatory intervention.

There are currently two types of users; pre-paid, which have a phone, purchase airtime upfront as required and pay a higher tariff per unit, and post-paid, which take out a 24-month contract and receive a package of airtime bundled together with a new phone. There are many permutations of contract, but essentially the network operators like the annuity income that contract customers represent and as such as willing to subsidise handsets to attract them. But, Icasa is concerned – based on consumer complaints – about the effect of handsets on competition in the market.

Icasa chairman Paris Mashile said the three network operators might be considered a “triopoly” to some extent. He questions whether there is real competition between the three, to that extent that the existence of the three operators has led to lower prices.

MTN, of course, disagrees. Presenting MTN’s case, Nkateko Nyoka (the former CEO of Icasa) said the take-up of cellular really took off when handset subsidies were introduced. One only had to compare the industry’s 23-m odd subscribers to Telkom’s 4-m to 5-m odd fixed line subscribers to know the impact it had had on penetration.

This is a similar view to that espoused by Vodacom CEO Alan Knott-Craig at a recent presentation.

Geoff Parr, chief economist at the Competition Commission said its view was that regulation was only necessary if the market had failed: “I don’t think its clear at this stage that the market has failed.” But, if it had, the regulation should only be in proportion to the size of the market failure, he said.

The Competition Commission suggested that there should be greater transparency for consumers in terms of what they were paying towards the handset in relation to the call costs. He likened the cellular industry to the banking industry, saying: “There’s not real transparency in terms of banking charges.” Not knowing what they might have to fork out at the end of each month ultimately made it difficult for consumers to compare their options, he said.

Parr said the unavailability of contracts excluding phones was “an excuse not to compete directly on call charges”. He says Icasa should recommend that operators offer a service subscription package where the consumer pays only for airtime, at a reduced monthly tariff.

At the moment, when a post-paid customer’s 24-month contract expires and they elect not to take up a new phone, they become month-to-month subscribers, but continue to pay the same tariff as before.

MTN did, however, commit to addressing this. Icasa councillor Nadia Bulbulia said this was already a breakthrough.

The Commission also recommended that operators should offer contracts of different lengths than merely the 24-months.

Phones are subsidised at three levels – by the networks, the service providers and the dealers, each to enable themselves to present competitive offerings. The more dominant networks and independent service providers (speaking at the previous day’s hearings) argued against reducing the contract period, as this is the time they need to recover the cost of subsidising the phones.

Both independents, Nashua Mobile and Autopage Cellular, were strongly in favour of handset subsidies, as was Vodacom. Key arguments in favour of subsidies included eliminating the barrier to entry for consumers and enabling them to keep up with new technologies to be able to utilise new services like high-speed wireless data. The market penetration is currently just above 50%, but Vodacom believes it can reach as high as 75% by 2008 – in other words there are still another more than 10-m potential customers to be reached.

Vodacom South Africa managing director Shameel Joosub said removing subsidies would lead to slower competitiveness, growth and penetration. Their removal would simply result in consumers financing handsets, which would not be as cost effective, as well as the operators introducing other incentives to compete.

MTN said it had been in favour of subsidisation and did not think Icasa should regulate their removal. But, with penetration levels at 53%, “we believe the market has reached a level of maturity where the phasing out of handsets may be appropriate”. Nyoka said this should be an industry-led process where Icasa merely lends its support. MTN wants the industry to agree on a code of conduct – something that worried the Competition Commission – whereby all the operators phase out handset subsidies in time.

Third operator Cell C believes the aim of introducing handset subsidies – to increase penetration – has already been achieved. Cell C head of regulatory affairs Karabo Motlana said in a mature market handset subsidies merely stimulated handset replacement, not subscriber growth. It believes the 24-month contracts will severely limit the uptake of number portability, which will soon be introduced and enable subscribers to switch between networks.

It proposes enforcing greater transparency as a short-term solution, with the operators being required to split out the cost of the phone, airtime and data costs to consumers. But, it says Icasa should regulate the removal of subsidies completely in a three-phased approach. Asked by Bulbulia for its view on MTN’s suggestion, Motlana said there was no industry consensus on the matter: “We do believe there is the need for regulatory intervention”.

Just last week, Icasa took the bold step towards regulating another area of the market; the pricing of high-speed internet access or ADSL provided by Telkom.

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter