What does ADSL really cost?
Telkom already has close on 100 000 ADSL subscribers threatened if Icasa succeeds in abolishing its access rentals.
Broadband is available from other operators such as Vodacom, Wireless Business Solutions and Sentech, Telkom is the only firm that can provide it using asymmetric digital subscriber line service (ADSL) technology. ADSL is deployed by using the existing copper infrastructure that supports “plain old telephone services”, or Pots. The monthly rental ADSL subscribers pay for this comes to R92.
Telkom incurs other costs. An ADSL-enabling port (a digital subscriber line access multiplexer, or D-Slam, port) needs to be installed on the copper telephone line for every ADSL connection. Telkom’s executive for product services, Steven White, says the ports are housed in air-conditioned kiosks (around 480 ports in a kiosk), which need to be maintained.
MyADSL, an online forum for SA’s ADSL and broadband users, estimates the cost of a D-Slam port to fall within $30 to $60. In addition the backbone network, which connects the customer management system, called the edge switched-service router (ESSR).
The monthly access charge paid by Telkom customers, which ranges from between R270 for a 192 kilobit per second (kbps) service to R477 for 512kbps, is used by Telkom to recoup the costs, maintain and expand the D-Slam, ATM and ESSR network and equipment, says White. This is the charge Icasa has targeted, and advocates replacing it with a once-off charge.
White told Moneyweb earlier this week that the company has already spent over R1-bn in rolling out services: “It is incomprehensible that Icasa would not allow us to recover this cost. A once-off charge would be out of financial reach for most South Africans,” he says.
Geoff Rehmet, Dimension Data subsidiary Internet Solutions’ (IS) new business development consultant, says according to prices based on rollout in other countries, IS estimates the monthly cost of the access portion is between R46 and R70
At the public hearings into Telkom’s service, MWEB’s Mervyn Goliath said the copper infrastructure, is already in place: “How can a perpetual monthly charge be justified when much of the infrastructure is already there? “ he asked.
Reacting to Telkom’s claim that it won’t be able to make its money back on its investment, Rehmet says: “For Telkom to suggest Icasa is not permitting it to recover cost is disingenuous. Telkom has only itself to blame if it is misunderstood, as it is the sole provider of ADSL. During the public hearing process, Telkom had ample time to adequately inform the regulator”
Rehmet does not think Icasa is advocating that consumers do not pay for the ADSL line on a monthly basis:
Currently, most Internet service providers (ISPs) – bar UUNet and IS – are reselling a South African Internet Exchange (Saix) service. Telkom controls Saix.
The virtual ISPs then provide add-on services like e-mail accounts and web space. ISPs buy three gigabytes worth of service for R157.
IS and UUNet are connected to the Internet pipe through Telkom’s IPConnect product.
“For all players,” he says, “it is incredibly difficult to compete with Telkom on the Internet bandwidth portion, where there is no real competition due to Telkom’s current tariff structures. There is a serious element of margin squeeze, and Telkom is abusing its dominant position in the upstream facilities market in order to exclude competitors.”
White says there are plans to sell bandwidth on a per-gigabyte basis to ISPs by the end of the year, as this will enable ISPs to build own packages, and create a cheaper product for customer who do not use 3GB of bandwidth each month.
“This does not solve the problem,” says Rehmet. “The underlying issue is that there is no competition.” He likened the situation to prescribing a headache tablet to someone suffering from malaria.
In its findings document, Icasa said the issue of allowing access would be addressed in the convergence bill and its facilities leasing regulations. The regulator also outlined its intention to reopen the investigations into the submarine cable that brings international bandwidth to SA.
Rehmet says one of two potential outcomes would be positive: “Either the cable may be declared an essential facility, enabling Vans providers to obtain wholesale access, or Icasa may terminate Telkom’s monopoly on landing stations. Telkom is now in a position to extract monopoly rents; if Icasa changes this, it could become like any other facilities leasing situation. Internationally, landing stations are usually subject to the provision that the operator of the landing station cannot exclude other players.”
Diane Ngoasheng, Icasa’s senior manager for consumer protection says the regulator is currently formulating regulations, “which should be concluded in a month’s time. After that, draft regulations will be published for public comment.
Source: http://www.moneyweb.co.za