Technology13.09.2005

Sorry: not as expensive

But, it says the broader issues are still relevant and the industry review will proceed.

The document, put together as the start of an industry enquiry into the seemingly high cost of cellular telephony in the country in terms of section 27 of the telecommunications act, was released in mid-July. The enquiry comes in response to a complaint laid by telecoms industry body Cuasa (the Communications Users Association of South Africa). The closing date for interested parties to submit their responses was last Friday, and Icasa is currently considering whether to hold oral hearings.

In a statement published on its website, Icasa said it “regrets these unfortunate errors and any inconvenience caused to operators and interested parties.”

But, it doesn’t believe the mistakes negate the validity of the enquiry, nor the complaint lodged by Cuasa, reiterating the context of President Thabo Mbeki’s State of the Nation Address in February, in which he expressed concern about the high cost of telecommunications.

In its discussion document, Icasa said: “At present, it is the high cost of communications in SA that is also seen as the largest barrier to a boom market for foreign and domestic call centres and business process outsourcing, generally.”

Ray Webber from Cuasa said there seemed to be definate room for mobile pricing to improve, but it was difficult to tell how the whole thing would pan out. He says there are clearly two sides to the story – that of the users who feel they are being ripped off, and that of the network operators, who will no doubt argue to the contrary. He says it will be the inenviable task of Icasa to find a middle road.

Webber said Cuasa had not done the international comparisons, or taken into account the myriad of factors that need to be considered, it had simply planted the seed for the issues to be explored.

The mistakes, how much cause for concern?

The errors relate to giving incorrect comparable data on the monthly subscription rates for contract subscribers in six operators in three different countries; Czech Republic, Switzerland and Spain, because incorrect exchange rates were used for calculation purposes. For example, Icasa initially published the rate for Czech operator T-Mobile as being R68,90, when the correct figure was R575,13. In the case of Swiss operator Orange, the correct monthly subscription should have been R1722, not the R68,90 that Icasa originally quoted.

Comparable figures for the South African operators were; Vodacom (R785), MTN (R949) and Cell C (R640).

Vodacom’s response

Vodacom CEO Alan Knott-Craig is clearly incensed at the errors and the fact that it took Icasa so long to correct them. He says that the figures Icasa used were wrong by so much – in some cases a factor of five to ten – causes one to question their research: “If they get this information wrong, how much else is wrong”.

Icasa says it is examining other comparative data for any other errors that any other errors that may have crept in.

Vodacom said in its submission to Icasa that apart from the miscalculations, the countries used for comparative purposes were inappropriate based on factors like their size, urbanisation, population density, teledensity and per capita GDP.

Asked what other countries would be more appropriate, Knott-Craig said direct comparisons were difficult, but independent data provided by organisations like the OECD and Prodata, which Vodacom quotes from in its submissions, provided probably the most accurate comparisons. In these, South African tariffs rank below the average, Knott-Craig says.

He says it is particularly inappropriate to compare South African tariffs to those in countries like China or India – which are sometimes cited as examples of countries with affordable telephony – because of the economies of scale resulting from having 1-bn people. “You can’t achieve these kinds of prices unless you’ve got that kind of economies of scale”, he says. “If you want to pay those kind of tariffs, you must go live there.”

Knott-Craig says South African mobile costs are “reasonable: not the cheapest, but certainly not the most expensive”.

At the 2005 year-end, Vodacom’s operating, or EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation) margin was 35,1%, while MTN’s was 41,5% (total, therefore including international operations).

In its discussion document, Icasa asked whether the mobile operators were earning super profits.

The operators don’t believe so, and on various occasions (Vodacom in relation to a proposal to remove handset subsidies, and Telkom in relation to the possible future unbundling of the local loop), have warned that interfering with pricing could prevent the necessary investment needed to maintain and develop telecoms networks going forward.

In its submission, Vodacom says its EBITDA margins are in line with mobile operators elsewhere in the world. The established operators – itself and MTN – had performed well, “providing investor returns commensurate with the risks taken.”

Source:  http://www.moneyweb.co.za

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter