Technology17.09.2005

SQUEEZED BUT SURVIVING

Strong subscriber growth, the introduction of mobile number portability and a tie-up with Richard Branson’s Virgin Mobile could finally deliver Cell C, SA’s youngest and smallest cellular operator, from a sea of red ink.

When Cell C was launched, concerns were expressed in some quarters that the SA market was not big enough for a third player. But now, with 2,5m customers (or just more than 10% of the market), Cell C has proven those sceptics wrong — or at least partially. Despite its success at signing up subscribers, Cell C still has a way to go before it generates profits at the operating level. The company’s Saudi backer, Oger Telecoms, has yet to see a return on its investment.

Jonathan Newman, adviser to CEO Talaat Laham, says Oger and Cell C’s other shareholders are comfortable with the operator’s profit forecast. The company expects to start making a net profit on a monthly basis in late 2006, he says.

Analysts say it’s not surprising Cell C has not yet turned a profit, given how entrenched MTN and Vodacom are. Cell C had to invest R9bn to set up its network.

“Building, operating and maintaining a cellular network and service provider in SA against the two well-established competitors is a complex, difficult and expensive business,” Newman says.

A two-year delay in getting its operating licence did not help either. Vodacom and MTN were able to sign up 500000 subscribers during that time.

Despite this, analysts say Cell C is holding its own. It increased its revenues in the June quarter by 39%, to R1,28bn, and earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation came in at R87,7m, compared to a loss in the corresponding period.

“It is always going to be third, but it is showing positive gains,” says Richard Hurst, a senior research analyst at BMI TechKnowledge.

There is evidence that it is on the right track:

It says it signed up 24% of all new contract subscribers in the three months to June for an overall 11% market share (see graphs).

It now carries 80% of its own traffic on its network, though Vodacom still carries traffic for it in the rural areas. It says it has nearly completed its network. Cell C plans to spend R950m on its network in 2005, but it’s likely to spend only half that next year.

It has taken out two high-yield bonds — à225m and à400m — to fund its capital expenditure. The proceeds have been used to settle project finance debt and repay loans from its Saudi parent. Remaining proceeds will be used to carry Cell C’s cash flows to the time when it turns cash flow positive, which should happen by the end of the year. “Cell C will never need to refinance again,” says chief financial officer Muhieddine Ghalayini.

The company says there is a potential market for 8m new cellular phone subscribers in SA by 2013 and it is aiming to sign up 2,5m of these.

Most of these subscribers, though, will be at the low end of the market, and not likely to spend much on telephony. The bigger challenge for Cell C will be to gain subscribers at the upper end, and that will mean luring away contract customers from MTN and Vodacom.

Hurst says Cell C has positioned itself at the lower end of the market by focusing on prepaid subscribers and building community service telephones in “underserviced areas”.

To lure higher-paying clients, Cell C will have to make the latest technologies, such as high-speed 3G access, available to its clients, says Hurst. This is an expensive proposition.

Laham concedes that Cell C needs a 3G network but is sceptical about the growth potential the technology offers.

It’s a view echoed by Grant Brewer, partner for information systems at Ernst & Young, who says a lack of penetration of 3G handsets, high costs and “lacklustre consumer appetite” may stem the success of the technology.

Newman says Cell C will grow by adding subscribers. Its proposed joint venture with Virgin Mobile, in which Virgin will use Cell C’s network to provide Virgin-branded cellular services, may help it do this. Talks are at an advanced stage and details should be announced later this month.

Virgin could be key to pushing Cell C out of the bottom end of the market by attracting subscribers who are prepared to take out contracts.

An alliance with Virgin, though, is a “doubled-edged sword”, warns Hurst. It will boost traffic on Cell C’s network but Virgin may migrate to another network later, taking its subscribers with it.

Though Cell C has not seen a fall in average revenue per user (a key industry measure), at R120/month it is substantially lower than its rivals’. The average MTN customer spends R169/ month while Vodacom users spend an average of R150/month.

Government’s plans to introduce number portability, allowing consumers to switch networks without losing their telephone numbers, is also expected to broaden Cell C’s prospects.

“Number portability is crucial for consumers and crucial for Cell C,” says Newman. “Our competitors have been able to lock in the highest-spending customers because these are the people who are most affected by having to change their numbers.”

INet-Bridge

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter