Technology26.09.2005

Acer defends its equity stance

Acer Africa MD David Drummond said those ventures were being unwound, as they proved unprofitable because the aims of Acer and the expectations of its local partners were incompatible.

The experience has convinced Acer to apply for exemption from a clause in the empowerment charter requiring companies to be 30% black owned.

So far few other multinationals have said outright that they will not sell any equity, as most are waiting for the charter to be officially enacted before they declare their hand. But the lesson from Acer clarifies one reason for the anti-equity stance.

Acer’s joint ventures in Turkey and Mexico were designed to share the benefits with local investors just like the empowerment charters aim to achieve in SA. But they failed because of the different expectations. "Equity ownership in a PC company is problematic," said Drummond.

"Our interest is in developing our brand and gaining market share on very low margins, and a local investor would be disappointed in our return of a 3% profit margin after tax."

"That’s not exciting for a local investor who can find better returns in other industries," he said.

As the sales and marketing arm of a global entity, Acer Africa draws its knowledge, products, support systems and spare parts from the group for free.

Although Acer continued to supply those services to the joint ventures in Turkey and Mexico for free, the local partners pushed for higher profits and raised the price of its computers to generate a 10% margin. But customers would not pay those prices and simply bought PCs from rival suppliers, Drummond said.

"Trying to move to higher margin levels in Turkey and Mexico was killing the brand. If you try to make more money you end up losing because the products don’t sell," he said.

Acer was not refusing to sell equity out of stubbornness or greed, he said, but because it had found that it did not work in a business where companies survive by massive sales volumes on extremely thin margins.

Nor does Acer see much merit in the calls for multinationals to set up manufacturing plants with local partners. Although Acer PCs are assembled in SA, the plant was set up by a local distributor, MB Technology, rather than by Acer itself.

The best way for a foreign PC company to support empowerment was to create jobs by using local firms to sell its products and to carry out skills transfers, regional vice-president Emanuele Accolla said.

Business Day/Inet-Bridge

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter