Technology1.10.2005

LAW SHOULD HELP BLOCK JUNK

Spam is more than a nuisance, it’s a financial drag on businesses, says technology lawyer Ryk Meiring.

At the moment there’s little companies can do to ease this burden because, under SA law, only an individual recipient of the unwanted e-mail can lay a charge. Companies whose operations are hurt by spam do not have the right to complain under the Electronic Communications & Transactions Act. The limitations of the act mean the hands of Internet service providers (ISPs) are tied even though the service they provide is hampered by spam.

“There is huge scope for improvement,” says Greg Massel, acting joint chairman of the Internet Service Providers’ Association, on the laws governing spam. Massel says government is not deaf to ISP concerns and has indicated it’s prepared to change the act.

Massel says the association is still drawing up its recommendations on what government can do to help tackle spam. Several workshops have been held with the department of communications.

It is not surprising that ISPs and government are taking the issue seriously, considering that spam is estimated to cost SA business between R7bn and R13bn a year.

A European Union study estimates the worldwide cost of spam to Internet subscribers at R79bn. Spam is estimated to make up between 60% and 80% of e mail traffic.

Besides giving business the right to complain, ISPs want the law to provide tighter definitions of what constitutes spam.

Though the act refers to spam as “unsolicited commercial communications”, it does not give a definition of what makes theses communications unsolicited or commercial.

Unisa graduate Michelle Lara Geissler points out in her doctoral thesis on spam that it is often difficult to detect whether a communication is unsolicited, especially when there is a prior relationship between the sender and recipient. Meiring says that as the act defines spam as commercial only, this leaves e-mail open to abuse from noncommercial correspondence, such as chain letters.

Geissler points out that the bulk nature of these e-mails is the real nuisance and has not been dealt with in the act.

Electronic junk mail is a serious money-spinner: those sending spam have no overheads — finding e-mail addresses and sending e-mails costs virtually nothing — and the revenues generated from sales can be huge.

One study found that 3,5m messages (at a cost of less than US100/million messages), generated 81 sales worth $19 dollars each in the first week (a total of $1500) on a take-up rate of only 0,0023%, Meiring says.

Meiring says spam is the equivalent of a telephone salesman calling to sell you something and then making you pay for the call. “Users pay to access content they didn’t ask for,” he says.

Though a change to the act will go some way to limiting e-mail abuse, other measures will also be needed.

These include more widespread use of filtering software, as well as self-regulation by the marketing industry, which has been damaged by the abuse of e mails.

As spam is an international problem, SA is not alone in fighting it. The laws applying to spam in SA govern companies falling under local jurisdiction only.

Inet-Bridge

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter