Technology6.10.2005

Down with telecoms prices!

That prices are too high is not in dispute. This has been confirmed on a number of occasions – including the Genesis Analytics report earlier this year commissioned by the South Africa Foundation, which found some areas up to nearly 400% more expensive than other countries. The first colloquium – next week’s is a follow-up gathering – came to the same conclusion.

The next step is to make it happen.

But, one’s view of whether this will actually be the case depends on how optimistic one is. The less optimistic point to the last few years of government’s failing in the telecoms sector.

Dobek Pater, telecoms analyst from Africa Analysis, says there have definitely been increasing overtures from government. The question is whether that political will is going to translate into the market becoming more free and competitive, or whether it wants to bring the sector more closely under its control (as demonstrated by mixed messages coming out the Icasa Amendment Act). He obviously hopes for the former.

But, the danger of any colloquium – and the sector has seen many in the past – is that it ends up translating into a high-level talk shop.

Business lobby group, the South Africa Foundation believes things are going to get moving. Speaking at the launch of the report that it commissioned into making concrete suggestions for bringing prices down, CEO Michael Spicer said although there were vested interests that would resist changes, the broader national interest seems to be overarching. This against the backdrop of aiming for 6% economic growth.

On Moneyweb Radio, Absa economist Chris Hart said reform was “absolutely critical. And it’s also not just the telecommunication sector. It’s in health as well. We’ve had the problems in health. I think we’ve had a lot of idealism coming through in a lot of legislation to get the Utopian society. The strong rand has exposed the inefficiencies of a slew of regulations, not just telecommunications.

Said Hart: “It’s also one of the reasons why I believe in privatisation – not because it really matters a jot who owns Telkom or who owns Absa or who owns Transnet, for instance, but governments, if they are the regulators, in other words setting the rules, they tend not to allow competition to their own businesses. And that’s why governments should not be in businesses, because they cannot give a decent, coherent objective set of regulations.”

The only parties that argue telecoms costs are not too high are, naturally, the incumbents. They say they’ve invested a significant amount in the country’s infrastructure and deserve a decent return. No one’s arguing with that either.

This significant investment means the country now has a world-class telecommunications infrastructure.

The mobile growth story is a case in point. The phenomenal growth has led to 50% penetration – in other words, where 10 years ago, just 4-m people had access to a telephone, now 21-m odd people do. Vodacom CEO Alan Knott-Craig believes mobile penetration could exceed 75% in less than five years.

Although there has been a public outcry recently around the high cost of mobile calls, there’s less concern about the mobile sector than the fixed-line and facilities market, which is stifling competition across the board.

At least the mobile outcry led to a mini-price war. The operators know they’ll get kudos from the public for cutting prices, but if they do so carefully, their revenues won’t suffer.

But, while the mobile market was growing fast, Telkom was wasting money on installing millions of new landlines in remote areas, in accordance with its license commitments. It wasted roughly R17-bn on this, according to Genesis Analytics’ competition and regulatory economist James Hodge, as customers could not pay their landline bill and had to be disconnected, but found they could afford a cell phone. This botch-up emphasises the need to be nimble in regulations and licensing conditions. Hodge called for an overhaul of the universal service obligations and a relook at licensing fees, among other things.

Most of Genesis Analytics’ suggestions for bringing prices down were aimed at Telkom. Like cutting the cost of local calls to zero, and introducing per second billing in fixed-lines. Suggested changes to the mobile side are merely aimed at further stimulating an already competitive arena, like number portability and providing a mechanism for consumers to accurately compare complicated tariff bundles. But, it also focused on longer-term initiatives that will give competitors on the fixed-line side more chance of surviving. And this is where it’s a question of time and capacity.

Like unbundling the local loop. Government has said it will look at this. Great, so there’s high-level commitment. But, when will this translate into action?

And bringing down the cost of connecting between operators, or interconnection fees in techie-speak. Pater says he expects Icasa to start a process of reviewing interconnect charges by next year. Again, it’s a process – of issuing discussion documents, inviting comment, holding hearings, then making recommendations that have to be approved by the Minister – and this will take time.

Then there’s the issue of international bandwidth. This comes to South Africa mostly via an undersea cable. Telkom owns a stake in the consortium that laid the cable, as does SNO shareholder VSNL. But, Telkom has landing rights in South Africa. And unless this is charged at cost price, the SNO, and other players like the value-added network service providers (Vans) will battle to compete with Telkom on this score.

One also needs to throw two important pieces of legislation into the mixer; the Convergence Bill (since renamed the Electronic Communications Act) and the Icasa Amendment Act. The former will reform the way that operators are licensed and Pater says this should improve the competitive landscape. But, once passed into law, it will be up to Icasa to implement the licensing changes. And it needs sufficient capacity to do so quickly, which is partly why the Icasa Amendment Act comes in.

Are the changes happening quickly enough? This depends on where you’re coming from, says Pater. If you’re Telkom, or a shareholder in Telkom, then the slower the pace of reform, the better. But, for consumers, and the broader economy, things are certainly not happening quickly enough.

But we know this. And we’ve said it all before (in fact, I’ve felt like a stuck record on more than one occasion). Thankfully, there have been some changes. But, the current pace is not going to mean the country can grow at 6%. And that’s the challenge to government – just do it. And, do it for the right reasons.

Source:  http://www.moneyweb.co.za

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter