Open market ‘only real telecoms solution’
SA should have a highly competitive market after planning privatisation for several years, but the communications department had erred in granting Telkom a monopoly and in licensing only three cellular networks, according to Tim Kelly, head of policy for the International Telecommunication Union.
Kelly told a government-sponsored telecommunications colloquium that policy changes proposed by industry stakeholders were the best way to shake up the sector, but were no substitute for real competition.
One key proposal presented yesterday is to unbundle the local loop, so other operators can access the Telkom line that takes communications services to consumers’ houses.
Voice and data carriers should be allowed to set up their own networking infrastructure, and the fees Telkom charges other operators to access an undersea cable linking SA to the rest of the world should be regulated. Telkom must also be forced to stop disconnecting customers who default on their bills, the task force suggested.
Its proposals will be debated at the colloquium today, so that firm policy proposals can be presented to Communications Minister Ivy Matsepe-Casaburri.
Giving Telkom a monopoly had been “a disaster”, Kelly said. Telkom had no incentive to perform better, and its high fixed-line prices meant SA’s internet access had stagnated and broadband services were slow and overpriced.
Telkom had also used its monopoly to stifle innovative technologies offered by rival players, he said.
The Government then made another mistake by licensing only one more fixed-line operator, creating an ineffective duopoly.
Instead of tweaking the regulations now, government should throw open the market and license more fixed-line operators, more cellular networks, and allow new players to offer cellular services by leasing the networks of the established operators, Kelly said.
“The task force is aiming to use regulations as a surrogate to competition, which is not a bad strategy but it’s not as good as having full competition,” he said.
The proposed regulatory changes would not transform the market overnight, but changing the pricing structure, unbundling the local loop and introducing number portability for cellphone users were “an excellent place to start”, Kelly said.
Inet-Bridge