Wolf at the door
Sanlam Investment Management (SIM) fund manager Claude van Cuyck says it is “just a matter of time” before things start to get really tough for Telkom. This Friday sees the group’s annual general meeting, and this will no doubt include the release of some fairly reasonable to upbeat earnings guidance for the first half of the year.
So, Telkom’s issues are not in the short term, says van Cuyck. He says the group still offers a compelling dividend argument, and the likelihood of positive earnings surprises. But, in the medium term, risks relating to the earnings path and management changes need to be carefully considered.
From a listing price of R28 – or R26,60 and R22,40 (the latter, called the Khulisa offer, was limited to R5000 worth of shares) respectively if one bought in at the discounted offerings – Telkom shares ran as high as R130 recently before cracks started appearing. At a share price of just below R119, Telkom is trading on a price-to-earnings (PE) ratio of just above nine times.
There are others who share Van Cuyck’s view of Telkom. Speaking on Moneyweb Radio recently, African Harvest head of specialist equity Saliegh Salaam said he believed Telkom still held value at current levels: “We are well aware of the competition and the regulatory issues that the company is facing, and that increasingly this will increase over time. But we think that it’s more than discounted in the current share price.”
The exact impact on Telkom’s revenues if the market opens up relatively more quickly from here, would be difficult to predict. But, Salaam says given that Telkom has held a comfortable monopoly position, “its not inconceivable that over the next few years Telkom will lose a fair amount of market share – over time.” At current prices though, Salaam says the market is expecting Telkom to lose about 15% market share, “which we think is a bit too extreme.”
Old Mutual Asset Management’s Steve Minnaar also thinks there’s still value in Telkom. Whatever regulatory interventions there are, one mustn’t forget government still holds a stake in Telkom, nor must one assume Telkom will sit back and watch its market share slip away. The question, he told Moneyweb recently, was whether valuation or sentiment – which can be “hugely” powerful – would win.
Sentiment too, has been playing a major role in the share price of MTN recently. The uncertainty in the sector, around its expansion plans, and the more cautious view of emerging markets adopted by international investors from time to time, mean the price has been volatile.
Rewind back to the early noughties, when investors were worried about the risks associated with going into Nigeria. For ages, the share seemed stuck below R10. But then the market woke up to the fact that Nigeria was going to be a winner for MTN. And the counter quickly said goodbye to R10, but more recently, y’ello to R53. At the current share price of around R47, MTN is on a PE of 12,4.
Two long-time institutional supporters of MTN have been Allan Gray and Rand Merchant Bank (RMB).
RMB chief investment officer Charles Booth told Moneyweb Radio recently this was still a particular favourite. This was “largely based on growth prospects, primarily in Nigeria.” RMB agrees the forthcoming opening up of the market presents risk to Telkom.
In the third quarter this year, Allan Gray added to its holding of MTN shares. But, Tim Allsop’s Nedbank Rainmaker Fund halved its number of MTN shares with the aim of taking some profits, and taking a view that the share would not be likely to outperform in the short term given the perceived uncertainty in the industry.
As with other institutions, SIM has been “structurally overweight” telecoms stocks, and this has proven to be the right decision so far, but what next?
At least MTN, says Van Cuyck, offers a medium- to long-term growth story, whereas Telkom’s is a no-growth story in the medium to long term. With Africa only at the start of its growth curve, there’s still huge opportunity for MTN on the continent. But, concerns include the possibility of overpaying for licenses in the clamour to secure future growth streams.
The attraction to Telkom however is still Vodacom, which is a growth story that few expect to unwind even in the long term, according to Van Cuyck. But, there’s always Venfin as a way in to Vodacom, with its 15% stake. Telkom holds a 50% stake in Vodacom.
Coronation fund manager Charles de Kock says that of the two mobile operators, Vodacom, through Telkom and Venfin, is the cheaper of the two.
MTN is an interesting story though, “where there is the possibility of them doing more deals elsewhere in Africa or even in the mid-East, and that is maybe juicy. On the other hand, there’s always risk in going into new markets and new ventures, and they may pay too much to obtain a licence for one of those. So I think there’s a bit more risk in MTN than in the others, and I think if you can see the future clearly, one of those two will be right. But our bet is that you’d rather be in the safer one.”
Another caveat to consider is the global consolidation in the mobile space, evidenced in part by the recent purchase by MTC of Celtel. Van Cuyck says MTN could present a very juicy acquisition target for a bigger global player.
Other variables to watch out for in Telkom will be whether or not it manages to secure a stake in the fixed-line operator in Nigeria, Nitel, in the current privatisation process. Telkom originally teamed up with Vodacom in that bid, with the latter expressing an interest in the mobile arm of Nitel, M-Tel. But, Telkom corporate communications head Lulu Letlape said recently Telkom had yet to firm up its possible partners, which could include Vodacom. Vodacom, in its separate bid for V-Mobile in Nigeria in conjunction with Virgin, had placed itself in conflict with its parent, she said.
MTN has Nigeria sewn up as a huge growth opportunity. But, it’s looking ahead to secure other avenues as well. The group chose in the recent financial year not to pay out a special dividend, but to keep the cash for expansion opportunities. So far this has included acquisitions in Cote d’Ivoire and Zambia. But, the big fish would be the chance of participating in the privatisation of Iran’s second GSM license.
The telecoms sector has been a no-brainer investment in the last two to three years. From here, medium-term visibility reduces. On a pure PE basis – although most analysts assess these companies on a number of valuation methods – MTN is the more expensive of the two. There’s some risk associated with MTN, but also potentially more explosive growth. Vodacom’s prospects also look excellent. But, unlike Telkom, MTN doesn’t come with the potential drag of a monopoly fixed-line operator in a soon-to-be competitive market.
Source: http://www.moneyweb.co.za