Technology25.10.2005

Microsoft vs. Google vs. Yahoo

But, this is exactly what has happened.

And now the world’s biggest web portals are battling it out for the lead of this increasingly lucrative space. Google, with its predicted operating profits of $2,4bn this year, is testament to just how lucrative it can be. This week’s Economist highlights this “battle of the portals”; how Microsoft (MSN), Yahoo and Google are aiming for dominance, and as part of that process, all three are trying to eliminate fourth largest competitor AOL by bidding for the Time Warner subsidiary.

The Economist quotes Piper Jaffray analyst Safa Rashtchy saying AOL is by no means “the prettiest girl at the dance”. Rather it is “big open real estate and you don’t want your competitor to get it.”

Interestingly, The Economist also quotes former Merrill Lynch analyst Henry Blodget, who was banned for his role in inflating the dotcom bubble. Blodget has resurfaced as president of a company called Cherry Hill Research, and pronounced to The Economist: “The web war is over and Microsoft lost.”

Not everyone, least of all Bill Gates, would agree with Blodget that the war’s been lost, or won for that matter. There are clear leaders in some areas, but the environment is evolving very rapidly. Google’s purchase of eBay is a case in point.

Conventional wisdom, according to The Economist, says Google is the leader, because of it is lead in Internet search, which is the “most technologically exciting and profitable end of the business”. Google is estimated to make an operating profit of $2,4bn this year, compared to MSN’s predicted $500m. Yahoo is second in search, and MSN, a “poor” third. In terms of the number of site visitors, however, Yahoo is first, MSN second, AOL third and Google, last. In instant messaging, AOL is first, with Yahoo and MSN competing for second place.

If, as Blodget suggest, Microsoft has lost the war, then a combination of AOL and MSN makes the most sense, says The Economist: “Both are unhappy step-children of parents that live in other industries (Microsoft in software, Time Warner in traditional – i.e., offline – media), whereas Yahoo and Google remain the pure internet businesses they have been since their inception.”

A deal between Yahoo and AOL might be the easiest culturally, while Google’s play for AOL seems defensive, The Economist says. But, a combination of Google (the search and monetisation), AOL (the content) and Comcast (the broadband) – which is what it is proposing – would be an effective way to counter Yahoo’s teaming up with broadband providers.

The war, while an interesting one, may seem pretty remote for South African web users. But, the renewed interest in the space is encouraging for technology investments the world over. The consolidation of content and Internet access is also not foreign to this market (i.e. MWEB) and the Internet is gradually becoming a more popular destination for the advertising rand. But, it all boils down to the availability of broadband, which should become more pervasive with a more competitive market.

Source:  http://www.moneyweb.co.za

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the download speed of your home Internet connection?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter