Technology4.11.2005

MIXED SIGNALS

Telecommunications industry regulator the Independent Communications Authority of SA (Icasa) will soon have to rethink its management of the country’s scarce radio frequency spectrum as companies clamour to offer new wireless services to consumers.

Icasa is likely to receive dozens of new applications for access to spectrum once the Convergence Bill, proposed new legislation that will govern the sector, is enacted. The new law, due later this year or early next year, should make it easier for Internet service providers (ISPs) to apply for licences to build their own networks to serve their clients.

Industry players say government and Icasa must provide leadership to prevent anarchy in the sector. Intense competition for available spectrum has already led to some companies using spectrum unlawfully. “It’s become a bit like the Wild West,” says Douglas Reed, MD of Internet service provider DataPro.

Some wireless ISPs are building networks in contravention of the law and bypassing Telkom’s fixed-line network. “People are trying to cut Telkom out of the last mile,” Reed says.

There is a general sense of lawlessness prevailing in parts of the industry. But legal opinion is divided on whether wireless ISPs are operating outside the law. A statement issued earlier this year by communications minister Ivy Matsepe-Casaburri has not done anything to clarify the situation. Though Matsepe Casaburri clarified an earlier determination, made in terms of the Telecommunications Act, to say that ISPs could not build their own networks, some lawyers argue that her statement was made extra-legally and therefore has no force in law.

Matsepe-Casaburri’s clarification might not have a bearing for long anyway. Government has hinted strongly that it might soon amend legislation to allow ISPs to self-provide network facilities after all. And, once the Convergence Bill is enacted, ISPs will be able to apply for licences to build their own networks (though it’s not entirely clear whether these licences would be issued).

Meanwhile, wireless ISPs, such as Cape Town-based UniNet, say Icasa is delaying the development of the sector by not issuing licences to companies to operate wireless networks.

Once the market is opened up, determining who gets access to spectrum could prove a big challenge. Applications could be rendered worthless if spectrum is not allocated properly, warns Telkom executive for technology strategy and integration Marius Mostert.

It also doesn’t help that new technologies such as WiMax, which delivers wide-area broadband wireless access, are still in their infancy. The standards for WiMax — including the frequencies it will use — must still be bedded down.

It’s clear that Icasa will have to look at new ways of allocating spectrum. Mostert says it must consider auctioning off access to spectrum. But many ISPs are not too keen on this option as it would mean companies with deep pockets, such as Telkom, would be able to outbid them.

The global trend, says Mostert, is for regulators to take a more hands-off approach and allow the market to decide who gets access and who doesn’t. He points to a prediction made by UK regulator Ofcom that by 2010 market mechanisms will allocate more than 70% of Britain’s radio frequency spectrum, up from zero in 2000.

UniNet CEO David Jarvis also prefers regulation by the markets. Icasa, he says, should act only as an adjudicator, and then only when the industry cannot resolve disputes.

To an extent, the market in SA is already doing this. Jarvis says when UniNet finds that someone is interfering with its frequency, a polite conversation is usually enough to resolve the problem.

Others prefer a more interventionist approach. Reed says companies should be fined if they don’t use frequency that has been allocated to them.

Government is proposing an even more hardline approach. The draft Convergence Bill says licences can be withdrawn if the “licensee fails to utilise the allocated radio frequency spectrum in accordance with the licence conditions applicable to such a licence”.

Icasa will have to submit a radio frequency plan to government for approval. This document, which has to be drawn up within 12 months of the bill’s enactment, must provide details of how Icasa plans to allocate spectrum. This plan must then be updated once a year.

Inet-Bridge  || Discuss this article

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

Which company do you trust the most for an ERP system?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter