Abracadabra!
Back when the rand was declining daily, at almost every dinner party I attended, one person would ask me what was going to happen next to the currency, supposing that, as a a financial journalist, I should know these things.
It’s the same thing – if not worse – being a financial journalist specialising in the information and communication technology (ICT) sector. Almost everyone one meets wants to know why his or her telephone bill is so high. Others have a view on how this should be fixed, inevitably citing the cheap cost of calls and broadband in other markets like the UK.
The reality is, however, that this is not the UK, or the US, or South Korea for that matter. It is a market whose ultimate deity, the Department of Communications, has taken an inordinately long time to introduce competition. It is therefore going to take more time to fix the market structure so that prices can come down dramatically. With the best will in the world from government – and even if it regulates lower prices – it will still take more time to implement.
Numerous studies can be cited which reflect just how high SA’s telecoms costs are relative to those in the rest of the world. Logic says this cannot be sustainable. And Telkom gets lambasted all the time.
But, although many disgruntled consumers would tend to disagree, Telkom is not the devil. In fact, it has been the perfect incumbent, doing what incumbents all over the world do – protecting its profit streams. As a listed company, its first duty is to its shareholders.
As a financial journalist specialising in ICT, one must almost wear two hats; that of a capitalist and that of a socialist. The capitalist focuses on the value that the company adds for shareholders, and the socialist advocates cheap calls and inexpensive broadband, which many countries have come to expect as their right.
Of course, there’s a broader role one has to assume as well – one that takes into account that low telecoms costs and cheap broadband are drivers of economic growth.
The day will come, but in meantime, we continue to wait and we view promises with a healthy dose of cynicism inspired by years of broken promises.
Telkom and Vodacom’s results, which are delivered twice a year in November and May, are always a big event on the calendar of every ICT journalist and telecoms analyst.
One receives a good picture of past performance and some idea of their future plans and where they think things are headed, and one catches up with a host of old and current contacts.
It was not surprising to see the chairman of Icasa Paris Mashile attending the results – it’s a good opportunity for him to understand more of Telkom too. But, a little surprising to hear him pipe up during question time.
Mashile’s questions were all directed at Telkom’s costs and good performance, asking whether this was not directly linked to its status as a monopoly operator and the fact that it thus has a relatively captive audience.
All valid questions, whose ever fault this situation may be. And people that I’ve spoken to think new CEO Papi Molotsane handled them very well.
But was it the right forum in which to ask them? As the regulator, Icasa can call the operators in for a chat any time it likes. And the operators would seemingly welcome this interaction.
With my capitalist hat on, I counted at least seven analysts who left the room simultaneously in the middle of Mashile’s questions.
Molotsane said his first few weeks were a “baptism of fire”, particularly because he had to deal with management unhappiness within weeks of his arrival.
After the initial introductory interviews and meetings with institutional shareholders, Molotsane enjoyed a short reprieve, when the company kept him from the media limelight to give him a chance to get to know the business.
In the two and a half months he’s been there, he seems to have done pretty well at that. It is a complex industry that could take years to master.
On results day, like the CEO of any listed company, he was flooded with interview requests but also made time to come through to the Moneyweb studio in the evening.
Off air, he outlined a hectic schedule running over the next few weeks of visiting institutional shareholders in Cape Town, then coming back up to Joburg for more visits, before heading off to do the same in London, New York and then back to London again.
It will be interesting to watch the share price in the next few weeks to see what kind of impression he’s made on international investors.
South African telecoms shares, both Telkom and MTN, have been re-rated on the strength of Vodafone’s vote of confidence in Vodacom. The latter is not listed separately but is 50% owned by Telkom. Vodafone will soon have the other half, making Telkom the only entry point for investors into Vodacom.
But, investors wanting an exposure to Telkom have to take the fixed line business too. Interestingly, Vodacom accounts for nearly half the market value of the group, but only a third of profits.
The question is whether the fixed line side of the business is being properly valued, or whether the market has been too pessimistic and factored in a worst case scenario for the fixed line business in the face of competition. Although vulnerable to competition,
Telkom also remains in a strong position to retain the bulk of its market share by virtue of its established infrastructure.
Molotsane scoffed at the suggestion that Telkom may have missed a trick in not increasing its shareholding in Vodacom, rather than letting Vodafone increase its share to 50%. But, it doesn’t seem a seller either.
Speaking on Moneyweb Radio, Molotsane said: “We did not miss a trick…we were also bidders for the Venfin stake.” But, he said Telkom did not want to engage in an auction and the price had gone too high.
“Yes, we missed out, we were disappointed that we missed out, but at the same time one has to be philosophical about it and say that the venture with Vodafone, a 50:50 venture, is actually positive for us as an organisation. There’s nobody in his right mind that would put R16bn (what Vodafone will pay for the stake) in a business and not do a lot to grow it aggressively.”
And the analysts tend to agree that it would have been a bad thing for Telkom to overpay and hence overgear itself. Particularly since buying the increased stake would still not have meant taking control. In terms of the shareholders agreement, Telkom shares control with Vodafone. Most on them hold a similar view to that of Molotsane – that Vodafone’s increased shareholding will be good for Vodacom.
Source: http://www.moneyweb.co.za