Technology9.01.2006

Down, but not out

Almost all old media companies shared the pain last year, whether focused on distribution (Comcast shares fell 22 per cent) or content (Disney fell 14 per cent). In fact,the biggest beneficiaries of thedigital revolution have been new "distribution" companies from the technology sector.

Take the iPod. The music industry is still struggling with piracy and the decline in CD sales unleashed by digital distribution over the internet. Apple’s iPod created a way for the music industry to benefit from legal downloads.

But growth there has not yet offset the decline in CD sales. The real winner has been Apple, whose combined hardware and software distribution platform has taken the lion’s share of profits from new digital sales. Apple’s shares have soared seven-fold in two years.

Google’s rise has been even more extreme, and disruptive. Now boasting a market capitalisation bigger than Time Warner and Disney combined, Google has become a powerful gateway for free internet content. As Google, and others such as Yahoo, have grown in popularity, advertising dollars have naturally followed audiences online.

But the likes of Google are not simply competitors for the same advertising pie. They pose a deeper threat to some media business models.

Take newspapers. Google users do not have to buy specific newspaper titles. Instead, they can select individual stories on a topic of their choice from a range of online publications, usually for free. That harms readership of established offline brands. It also cuts newspapers’ online advertising opportunities by taking readers straight to the relevant page of a site.

Separately, search-based advertising targets individuals seeking specific information. That contrasts with traditional branded advertising on, say, television, where effectiveness is harder to measure.

New technology allows consumers to choose what media they consume and when – through digital video recorders, video-on-demand or, increasingly, broadband internet connections. Google last week unveiled a service for consumers to pay for video downloads.

That all poses serious questions over owners’ ability to keep a firm grip on their content – as the music industry failed to do. Top-quality content will still thrive – see Pixar’s valuation. However, in a more transparent world, media companies will have to respond better to what consumers really want and will find it tougher to push second-rate products down people’s throats.

Feel the fear

Media executives are rightly scared. Rupert Murdoch has made no secret of his belief in the power of new media, investing heavily in richly-priced acquisitions last year.

The success of new business models has reinforced the bear case for US media, which has underperformed the S&P 500 by 16 per cent over one year and 25 per cent over two.

Technology shifts have exacerbated the problems of slowing growth in some businesses. Advertising has been relatively lacklustre in areas such as network television and radio. For films, the DVD wave that long boosted profits is ebbing. A slowing economy could put pressure on advertising revenues, piracy could increase for filmed content, and new technologies could continue sucking money from old media.

However, not everything is negative. Big media groups still enjoy robust growth from their international arms, their largely fledgling online properties, and, for now, cable networks.

With managements under pressure to breathe life back into their share prices, and facing new technology threats, they could start taking tough decisions. That means restructuring cost bases in some areas and experimenting with business models (recent examples include selling episodes of TV shows on iTunes). A healthy dose of fear could be exactly what the businesses need to spur them into action.

Glimmers of value

Having been stripped of their traditional premium, old media stocks could be due a bounce.

Merrill Lynch estimates US media majors trade on just over 17 times earnings, slightly above the S&P 500 – but that they will increase earnings by over 15 per cent this year against 10 per cent for the market.

Admittedly, that is only one year. Growth further out will be tougher and investors have so far ignored possible catalysts for a bounce. Time Warner, for example, has faced calls for a break-up, increased its share buy-backs and achieved a headline valuation of Dollars 20bn for AOL through Google’s investment. In response, the shares have hardly budged.

But optimists are right that there are opportunities for the best content companies, as well as threats. Their skills are hard for new media companies to replicate. And new forms of digital distribution, including mobile devices, should add new audiences (and potentially new revenues). The coming years will be full of uncertainty as profits shift around the industry. But consumers overall are likely to keep increasing the amount they spend on media-related products.

In 2005, Google and Apple could do no wrong. Traditional media could do no right. That is reflected in the relative valuations. But the resilience of old media’s earnings, coupled with any signs that fear is prompting real action, should trigger a stronger performance in 2006.

Inet-Bridge  ||  Discuss this article

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

Which company do you trust the most for an ERP system?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter