Technology20.12.2006

Finding the right price plans

The fact that Vodacom was generally the most expensive across both prepaid and contract options is somewhat of an anomaly considering the fact that they continue to outperform their counterparts in the local market. Makes you think about the power of marketing.

Cell C’s pricing seemed to be fairly on par with MTN and in some cases cheaper, but MTN has the clear advantage when it comes to SMS and data speeds/bundles. Cell C only has an Edge network, while MTN has both 3G and HSDPA, providing substantially faster download speeds.

Having made a comment on pricing, admittedly this article did not take into account every price option from every provider. In fact, the first thing that strikes you when you begin to look at what’s out there is the number of options and the confusion they create. However, where direct comparisons were made, every attempt was made to compare "apples with apples."

Pricing not everything:

Before we move onto pricing, if you’re willing to go deeper than just looking at the costs to make your choice, then there are other things you could take into consideration. Ask questions like: how efficient is the call centre of the other network(s)? What kind of value added services do they offer (for example, online billing)? How wide their data coverage is apart from GPRS? Do their packages meet my needs – for example, you might want to pick a network with data bundles that suite your needs as opposed to just one where you are forced to take a certain package because that’s all that’s on offer.

Bear in mind if you ask long enough you’ll dig up enough service horror stories from every network. Given the size of the organisations, there are always people who are going to get shocking service at some point. It is therefore important that your choice is not an emotional one or one made on a whim.

The free phone:

Probably the most common reason for choosing a contract is the free phone offered with it. However, it is important to realise your phone is by no means free. A recommended read in this regard would be "How to buy a cellphone in South Africa" by Arthur Goldstuck and Steven Ambrose (http://www.kalahari.net/bk/product.asp?sku=30371009&toolbar=mweb).

The book will not only help with understanding what the costs involved are, but how to choose a phone that has the right features for your needs. Its stresses an important point: in terms of pricing, users should be looking at the call costs and not the contract price.

Prepaid Pricing:

Here is a comparison between Vodacom’s 4u prepaid, MTN Pay-as-you-go classic, Cell C Easychat standard and Virgin’s V0 to other cellular networks.



Vodacom

MTN

Cell C

Virgin

Peak

R2.99

R2.85

R2.85

R2.35 (per second)

Off peak

R1.30

R1.40

R1.60

R1.55 (after 5th minute)

Based solely on cost, MTN or Virgin would appear to be the best option. However, while Virgin has a 50 cents saving on MTN during peak times, it only drops down to R1.55 after 5 mins, meaning over the first five minutes of an off peak call, you would pay R4.75 more on a V0 package compared to a Pay-as-you-go classic off peak call.

Also, Vodacom’s Vodago smartstep package sets all calls at R2.35 for the first minute and R1.55 thereafter which throws a spanner in trying to compare the costs of this package with other packages.

A comparison of calls made on the same network.


Vodacom to Vodacom

MTN to MTN

Cell C to Cell C

Virgin to Virgin

Peak

R2.85

R2.50

R2.50

R2.35 (per second)

Off peak

R1.12

R1.40

R1.40

R1.55 (after 5th minute)

Once again things to consider here: Virgin does not offer cheaper calls to Virgin phones. Vodacom has a much lower off peak rate, beaten only by Cell C’s off peak Cell C to Cell C family rate not listed above which is R0.75.

Contract Pricing:

If you don’t make many calls but want to be able to make calls if you need to, then the entry level contract is the way to go. Look for a phone you like at the cheapest price. They are substantially cheaper than business contracts, but generally only offer free off peak minutes.

Looking at some entry level business contracts, Vodacom is one again the most expensive, followed by MTN and then Cell C when calling another network. It’s easy to compare the entry level business contract because they are fairly similar.


Vodacom

MTN

Cell C

Free mins

120

120

100

Monthly contract fee

R300

R285

R250

Peak calls

R2.70

R2.35

R2.35

Off peak calls

R1.25

R1.15

R1.15

To Telkom

R2.10

R1.65

R1.70

Peak to the same network

R2.10

R1.65

R1.70

Off peak to the same network

R0.99

R0.90

R0.95

Here MTN would be the best option given that its data offering is substantially better than Cell C’s.

Going higher up the contract packages it can become harder to compare as there is no equal packages, but here are some prices from mid range contracts.


Vodacom

MTN

Cell C

Free mins

500

600

700

Monthly contract fee

R800

R949

R1100

Peak calls

R1.80

R1.90

R1.75

Off peak calls

R1.15

R1.15

R1.10

To Telkom

R1.15

R1.15

R1.15

Peak to the same network

R1.43

R1.55

R1.43

Off peak to the same network

R0.90

R0.90

R0.90

Right at the top, there is not much in it, although for some reason, Vodacom’s peak call rate actually increased.


Vodacom

MTN

Cell C

Free mins

1000

1000

1000

Monthly contract fee

R1540

R1499

R1500

Peak calls

R1.88

R1.85

R1.70

Off peak calls

R1.15

R1.15

R1.10

To Telkom

R0.99

R1.00

R0.99

Peak to the same network

R1.43

R1.46

R1.43

Off peak to the same network

R0.90

R0.90

R0.90

Here Cell C is hands down the cheapest. However, its data offering is still a concern. Having said that, if you don’t mind getting two bills in the post, then you could get your data from another network. Edge is sufficient for small emails and local web pages, but becomes frustrating when you have to download files over 1MB and look at international websites.

SMS:

On the SMS front, MTN is the big looser here. Both Vodacom and Cell C provide an off-peak SMS rate, MTN does not. If you are a MTN user, I strongly suggest you get a SMS bundle.

Virgin is a great SMS option. Only MTNs larger bundles are more competitive in price and Virgin to Virgin SMS are a mere R0.20, the cheapest in the market.


Vodacom

MTN

Cell C

Virgin

Peak SMS

R0.80

R0.75

R0.80

R0.60 (first five SMS)

Off peak calls

R0.35

R0.75

R0.36

R0.30 (after five SMS)

SMS bundles:

Bundles are clearly the way to save on SMS. Vodacom often beats MTN here on price and range, but MTN generally has cheaper out of bundle SMS rates.

Vodacom bundles:

Bundle Size

Cost per Bundle

In Bundle SMS

Out Bundle SMS


Peak

Offpeak

50

R25

50c

80c

35c

100

R33.00

33c

80c

35c

200

R45.00

22.5c

35c

35c

500

R112.50

22.5c

35c

35c

1000

R225.00

22.5c

35c

35c

1500

R337.50

22.5c

35c

35c

2000

R450.00

22.5c

35c

35c

MTN bundles:

Bundle Size

Cost per Bundle

In Bundle SMS

Out Bundle SMS


Peak

Offpeak

50

R25

50c

60c

60c

100

R35.00

35c

44c

44c

200

R50.00

25c

30c

30c

500

R114

22.8c

23c

23c

2000

420

21c

21c

21c

Cell C did not have SMS bundle information on their site that I could find.

Data:

Data is fairly easy to compare. While Vodacom has split its 3G and HSDPA data charges, for the rest Vodacom and MTN are for the most part exactly the same. Vodacom does have many more bundles to choose from. Cell C only has Edge coverage and therefore does not play in the high speed data space as yet.


Vodacom HSDPA 500 MB

MTN 500 MB

Monthly charge

R350

R350

Data included

500MB

500MB

Data cost

R0.70/MB

R0.70/MB

Out of bundle cost

R1.50

R1.50

The 1GB package:


Vodacom HSDPA 1 GB

MTN 1 GB

Monthly charge

R499

R499

Data included

1024 MB

1024 MB

Data cost

R0.49/MB

R0.49

Out of bundle cost

R1.20

R1.25

The contract option comes with an HSDPA card. However, first prize would be to buy the card upfront if you can afford it or get it on a cheap contract where you pay in for it. The reason being is that if you own the card, then you can cancel your bundles at anytime.

Unless mobility is important to you, if you’re using a lot of data, it is worthwhile looking at ADSL. At R599 for the card and 1GB of data, ADSL is definitely cheaper. Once again, if you buy the HSDPA card, then you could load a small bundle onto it and use ADSL from the home or office.

The advantage in data through the cellular networks is that you only need to pay for what you use, but when it comes to using 1GB or more from the cellular networks, then ADSL is currently the better option.

Discuss this article

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the size of your main TV at home?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter