Technology20.02.2007

Why Erwin backs the state to get infrastructure working for SA

It’s an update on the public sector’s infrastructure spending plans for the next three years. It goes back to 2004, when the newly re-elected government targeted infrastructure spending as key to reducing the cost of doing business and raising the economy’s growth rate — and at the same time seemed to move away from privatisation, affirming the “developmental” role of state-owned enterprises.

That’s the table that details the R410bn of public sector infrastructure investment planned over three years. As much as half of that falls under Public Enterprises Minister Alec Erwin. And his department’s role in government and in the economy is clearly growing. Two of the projects on which he briefed journalists last week served to highlight that.

One is Infraco, the broadband network shortly to become a new public enterprise in its own right. The other is the local supplier development programme, which aims to build or rebuild capital goods industries that can supply into Eskom, Transnet and the pebble bed modular reactor’s huge capital spending programmes, so reducing the need for SA to import equipment.

Essentially, the argument is that these are strategic assets that the state must own, even though there is space for the private sector to come in as financier, via the capital markets. But Erwin goes further, to suggest that the public sector is taking the long-term view that the private sector can’t or won’t.

The department and the parastatals are planning 20 years ahead, in areas such as energy and transport. And their programme to stimulate the development of local equipment manufacturers aims likewise to shape industrial sectors over the long term. As Erwin put it last week: “If the private sector was so keen on infrastructure, they would have done it.”

The public enterprises are “strategic companies invested in strategic sectors”. Infraco, which comprises the fibre-optic networks formerly owned by Transnet and Eskom (which were originally meant to be sold to the second network operator, now Neotel), is in this category.

Erwin argues it must be publicly owned because broadband is such a strategic issue. Where some other countries have allowed broadband provision to be dominated by multinational companies, here it was considered important to have one of the systems under state control. The promise is it will help to bring down telecommunications costs.

Government is, in a sense, taking a gamble on this one, and on some of the other networks it owns, but it may be decades before we know whether we have won or lost. The problem with network industries is that they usually are dominated by only one or two players.

It becomes a question of whether the state should own them, or regulate them such that private sector players are attracted to come in and invest to provide services that are competitive, rather than abusing their dominance. Regulating these industries is complex and difficult, though it can be done. It may well look easier, though, to go the state ownership route, with the state doing the investing and capping the prices it charges.

The risk is that that might lead to underinvestment in the long term. We may never know whether the private sector might have invested more and charged less, had the regulatory and market structure been right. For now, though, there’s an urgent need for the infrastructure investment the state-owned enterprises are planning.

Government sees an urgent need, too, to reduce the level of imports prompted by that investment drive. The deficit on the current account of the balance of payments is one reason that’s important. But the other, as Erwin has frequently emphasised lately, is that there’s a worldwide infrastructure spending boom and SA may be quite far down in the queue for supplies.

The Industrial Development Corporation has estimated 40% of Transnet and Eskom’s capital equipment will have to be imported. The local supplier development programme aims to cut that, by offering long-term contracts or incentives (as yet unspecified) to companies willing to invest to supply items such as railway wheels and sleepers, not to mention all sorts of turbine and boiler type equipment for the electricity industry — items of which there is a worldwide shortage. If necessary, the state itself will invest in such industries, in partnership with private sector players.

The idea, though, is that now there’s a stable long-term investment plan, companies will come in. But it’s not a quick fix for the balance of payments. In the first round, government aims to reduce the import requirement by five to six percentage points. “We would be doing very well if we reduced the import requirement from 40% to 30%,” says Erwin. “Over 20 years we may have it down to 20%.”

Any large company investing for the long term would surely be forging longer term relationships with suppliers. Whether the public sector does it any better and has more of an impact on industry than the private sector, well, we’ll be able to judge that only in time to come.

Comments

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

What is the size of your main TV at home?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter