A Tainted Deal
Right from the start the deal, which came into the spotlight again in Parliament on Friday, was highly controversial.
In his role as director-general of the communications department, Ngcaba helped create Thintana as Telkom’s strategic equity partner. There was an obvious conflict of interest in his role as a private entrepreneur who sought to profit from Thintana’s exit strategy.
There was also little clarity on the beneficiaries of the Elephant empowerment consortium, which included Women’s Investment Portfolio Holdings (Wiphold) head Gloria Serobe and African National Congress (ANC) spokesman Smuts Ngonyama.
However, given the PIC’s growing reputation as a champion of good corporate governance, there was hope that a transparent, broad-based deal would emerge.
There is scant evidence that this transpired in the final deal. The stake intended for Ngcaba and Serobe was, granted, pared back to 6,67% of Telkom, while 3,37% was reserved for an undefined broad-based empowerment consortium.
But that only suggested that the PIC was unconvinced that the original Elephant consortium was sufficiently broad-based.
Under Brian Molefe, the PIC has made a positive impact on the South African corporate sector in recent years, championing good governance and shareholder activism. Molefe’s defence of the Telkom-Elephant intervention is that the decision was made purely on a commercial basis. And it has certainly succeeded from a financial perspective, having made an estimated profit of R2bn in six months.
But at what cost? Whatever the merits of his argument, the perception is that the deal was little more than an exercise in enrichment for a few senior ANC members. This was evident in the type of questions put to Molefe by members of Parliament’s finance committee, which included whether the organisation had come under any political pressure to salvage the deal.
Rightly or wrongly, the saga has tarnished the PIC’s reputation. Its only option now is to be as transparent as possible in all its transactions, and to avoid any hint of cronyism in future.
INet-Bridge