{"id":546677,"date":"2005-08-21T13:02:42","date_gmt":"2005-08-21T13:02:42","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/localhost:8888\/wordpress\/technology\/546677-internet-litigation-rapidly-increasing-in-sa.html"},"modified":"2005-08-21T13:02:42","modified_gmt":"2005-08-21T13:02:42","slug":"internet-litigation-rapidly-increasing-in-sa","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/technology\/546677-internet-litigation-rapidly-increasing-in-sa.html","title":{"rendered":"INTERNET LITIGATION RAPIDLY INCREASING IN SA"},"content":{"rendered":"<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cFearing that the courts were not well equipped to handle technology disputes, many IT businesses rather submitted their disputes to confidential arbitration proceedings in the past,\u201d says Mujahid Adams, technology lawyer at IT law firm Buys Inc. <\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cThe recent increase in technology related litigation shows a growing trust in our justice system and relatively young technology laws such as the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act.\u201d<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">Since 2000, the vast majority of Internet disputes resulted from wrongful domain name use. Companies such as Nandos, Sanlam and Truworths had to fight for their domain names in international arbitration proceedings based on local trademark rights. <\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">Since trademark rights form the basis of domain name rights, cities and regions throughout South Africa have no remedies against other who use domain names such as southafrica.com, capetown.com and kalahari.com.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">In 2001 a disgruntled SAA passenger registered the domain neverflysaa.com and hosted a website describing his bad experiences during a London to Cape Town flight. The public was also encouraged to post their experiences with SAA to the site. SAA responded by referring a dispute to the National Arbitration Forum in terms of the UDRP domain name arbitration rules. The judgment, widely regarded as a test case for so-called criticism websites, was handed down in May 2002 and held that free speech rights weigh stronger than trademark rights if the website in question is actually used for legitimate criticism. <\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cAlthough not directly related to the Internet, the unexpected judgment of the Constitutional Court in Laugh It Off v SAB will undoubtedly have a huge effect on freedom of speech on the Internet,\u201d says Reinhardt Buys, also from Buys Inc.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">Laugh It Off produced t-shirts mocking certain famous South African trademarks, including a reference to the SAB mark associated with the words \u201cBlack labour \/ White guilt.\u201d <\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">Notwithstanding rulings in favour of SAB from the Cape High Court and the Supreme Court, the Constitutional Court ruled on 27 May 2005 that free speech rights outweigh trademark rights if the trademark owner cannot prove actual financial loss.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">Recent unhappiness with the the prices and services of Telkom resulted in the registration and use of hellkom.co.za and telkomsucks.co.za. These sites also distribute pictures mocking the Telkom brand and encourage the public to post Telkom experiences. Telkom responded by threatening website owner Andrew von Hoesslin with litigation.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cThe neverflySAA.com decision as well as the Laugh It Off judgment basically rings the death bell for Telkom\u2019s case\u201d says Buys. \u201cThe current development of the law seems to favour free speech rights and not traditional trademark rights in most circumstances.\u201d<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">In an April 2004 judgment, the Cape High Court held that Eat Out magazine had a right to the eating-out.co.za domain name. In May 2005 the same court held that Getaway magazine had a right to the domain name wegbreek.co.za. <\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">Another local judgment on Internet free speech resulted from litigation initiated by Natasha Tsichlas, then manager of the Sundownds Soccer Club, against Touch Line Media because of an anonymous and allegedly defamatory posting on the Kick Off website\u2019s discussion forum. On 26 June 2003 the High Court ruled in favour of Touchline Media based on, amongst others, the fact that online free speech would be severely restricted if bulletin board operators had a duty to monitor all postings for potential defamatory content.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">As early as 1998 the Supreme Court balanced free speech rights and reputation rights with the National Media v Bogoshi judgment. The court held that the media had a central role in any democracy and may even publish untrue words if such publication was reasonable in the circumstances.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cThe vast majority of local Internet defamation disputes result from anonymous postings to chat rooms or discussion forums\u201d says Buys. \u201cFor the operators of such sites both the Touchline Media and Bogoshi judgments are good news and significantly reduce potential liability for third party defamatory content.\u201d<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cThe question whether or not a bulletin board operator must disclose the identity of a person who made a defamatory anonymous posting was not yet dealt with by the courts. People are more confident to call a spade a spade when they talk anonymously and can do so without fear of later harassment by employers and others.\u201d<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cAnonymous tip offs form a corner stone of our criminal justice system and the identities of those providing useful information about criminals are strongly protected. The same argument should apply to anonymous speech on the Internet \u2013 it encourages free speech, accountability, and transparency and should not be restricted lightly.\u201d<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">The Van Duivenboden judgment of the Supreme Court in August 2002 is another example of a court decision that, although unrelated to technology, has a huge effect on technology law. The court had to decide whether or not the Police were negligent in issuing a firearm license to a person with a criminal record and therefore liable for injuries sustained in a related shooting incident. <\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">In its finding against the Police, the court formally established the principle of liability for a co-called \u201cnegligent omission\u201d or failure to act when required to do so into the South African law.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">According to Adams \u201cmany online liability issues such as ISP liability for down time and a company\u2019s liability for unknowingly distributing a virus to others, are based on the principles laid down in the Van Duivenboden judgment.\u201d<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">In the May 2005 judgment of Valutel v eTel the High the Court examined disclosure of technology-related trade secrets and know how and in November 2004 the same court provided clearer guidelines for software reverse engineering in the Sure Travel v Exel Travel judgment.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cThe area that shows the most rapid increase in Internet related disputes is probably in-house disciplinary actions against employees who misuse email and the Internet\u201d says Buys.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">In one of the first such cases an arbitration forum confirmed the dismissal of a number of Energizer employees who distributed pornography through their employer\u2019s email system in October 2001.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cSince the Supreme Court held that an employer may be held liable for the harassing actions of an employee, the number of in-house cases increased rapidly, resulting from the downloading of copyrighted music, email defamation, and mostly email and sms harassment in the workplace. Notwithstanding clear indications of employee wrongdoing, some of these disputes were decided in favour of employees because evidence collected by employers did not meet the conditions of the Electronic Communications and Transactions Act and as a result had no or little evidential weight\u201d.<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">As recently as June 2005, the Supreme Court confirmed a finding of the Cape High Court in Media24 v Grobler that employers have a duty to create a working environment free of harm and harassment \u2013 failure to do so resulting in liability for damages suffered by the harassed person. <\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">Asked about the major IT judgments expected in South Africa Buys stated that \u201ca judgment of the High Court in the Men\u2019s Health domain name matter is expected any day now.\u201d<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">\u201cIn my opinion the big local cases of the next five years will probably deal with the protection of tech<br \/>\nnology trade secrets, source code, and related experience locked up in key employees when such employees are employed by competitors. Other big issues are the liability of directors for failure to ensure good technology governance and the liability of ISPs for poor service such as a failure to provide sufficient security to protect third party hosted sites against hackers. On average more than fifty local websites are hacked daily and website owners are increasingly looking at ISPs to recover their damages.\u201d<\/font><\/p>\n<p><font size=\"2\">In celebrating \u201cEight Years of Technology Litigation in South Africa\u201d, Buys Inc. released a summary of all the important IT disputes since 1998 with links to related media reports and downloads of the full judgments. The document is available as a free download from: <\/font><a href=\"http:\/\/www.buys.co.za\/downloads.asp\"><font size=\"2\">http:\/\/www.buys.co.za\/downloads.asp<\/font><\/a><font size=\"2\"> (850 KB, PDF format).<\/font><\/p>\n<p \/>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Since the start of 2005 there has been a significant increase in the number of Internet related judgments from South African courts.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":23,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_sma_x_autopost_status":"idle","_sma_x_autopost_error":"","_sma_x_post_id":"","_sma_facebook_post_id":"","_sma_instagram_post_id":"","_sma_threads_post_id":"","_sma_x_attempts":0,"footnotes":""},"categories":[17],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-546677","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-technology"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/546677"}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/23"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=546677"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/546677\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=546677"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=546677"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/mybroadband.co.za\/news\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=546677"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}