West Indies Men Tour of South Africa

Luke7777 said:
Verreyne defenitely....not too convinced about Rickelton yet. I'd rather have Petersen back for now.
Click to expand...
Tough call because a lot of noobs are looking like they’re worth an extended run (Peterson, de Zorzi, Rickelton, Verreynne). And then add in Markram v.2 who is maybe worth a run as well. But yeah, KP is in my playing XI.
 
From the current team I would drop Elgar, Klaasen and Harmer (To be reaplced by Nortje anyway)

Veryene in for Klaasen and the Peterson, Malan or Brevis in for Elgar. NOt sure who would open?
 
L-Dog said:
From the current team I would drop Elgar, Klaasen and Harmer (To be reaplced by Nortje anyway)

Veryene in for Klaasen and the Peterson, Malan or Brevis in for Elgar. NOt sure who would open?
Click to expand...
I won't drop Elgar. He scored runs in the first innings. Also a very good slip fielder. As the saying goes 'catches win matches'.
 
L-Dog said:
NOt sure who would open?
Click to expand...
De Zorzi because God only intended lefties to open the batting.

(I love left-handed test openers, including Elgar from five years ago).
 
Dan C said:
I won't drop Elgar. He scored runs in the first innings. Also a very good slip fielder.
Click to expand...

He has guts and usually puts up a decent fight especailly on tough wickets but over the last two years he has been out of form only avering 26.7. He is also 35 so would rather give a young gun a shot
 
KP hasn't been able to buy a run since coming back from injury and that includes for the dolphins.
I would give rickelton more chances.
Verreynne or klaasen, neither fully convinces me as test batsmen but kyle plays less loose . So I would go with kyle.

The bowlers depends on conditions, kg and anrich the only certaintys. Coetzee,Jansen, keshav, harmer and ngidi competing for the last 2 spots.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X