Krugersdorp girl killed in hunting tragedy

RedViking said:
If it is a wild cow, hunting is allowed as it can't be restrained. If it is a captured and restrained , ritual killing has to happen.
Click to expand...
Right... So the normal humane way of killing an animal for butchering wrong, but hunting one or slitting it's throat okay?
 
Lupus said:
Wait so let me get this right? A bullet to the brain or heart is acceptable? But a bolt to the head isn't? How is hunting the cow halaal?
Click to expand...
Go to the local casino and watch the Sunday morning rush for the bacon burgers.
 
RedViking said:
Hectic . I think I'm done with this thread for now.

Poor child didn't deserve this and having beef with religion to justify such an accident is a bit low.
Click to expand...
Of course the child didn't deserve this. I'm trying to understand how this works? It's not a beef against the religion, though not sure if you meant that as a pun?
It's more of an observation, how is this halaal? I'm trying to figure that part out. The poor child dying is a sad part of it all, I am trying to figure out the hunting portion.
 
Lupus said:
Of course the child didn't deserve this. I'm trying to understand how this works? It's not a beef against the religion, though not sure if you meant that as a pun?
It's more of an observation, how is this halaal? I'm trying to figure that part out. The poor child dying is a sad part of it all, I am trying to figure out the hunting portion.
Click to expand...
Wild animals are halaal if killed for food.
Must be killed quickly and humanely and you must say your intention before you pull the trigger.
iifa-aifi.org

Animal Slaughters

In the Name of Allāh,the Entirely Merciful, the Especially MercifulPraise is due to Allāh, Lord of the worlds, may the blessings and peace be upon our master Muḥammad, the last of prophets, on his family, and all his companions.Resolution
iifa-aifi.org iifa-aifi.org

if its a domesticated animal it must be slaughtered.
 
Suspect99 said:
Wild animals are halaal if killed for food.
Must be killed quickly and humanely and you must say your intention before you pull the trigger.
iifa-aifi.org

Animal Slaughters

In the Name of Allāh,the Entirely Merciful, the Especially MercifulPraise is due to Allāh, Lord of the worlds, may the blessings and peace be upon our master Muḥammad, the last of prophets, on his family, and all his companions.Resolution
iifa-aifi.org iifa-aifi.org

if its a domesticated animal it must be slaughtered.
Click to expand...
Thanks for this, now it's clearer
 
Lupus said:
Of course the child didn't deserve this. I'm trying to understand how this works? It's not a beef against the religion, though not sure if you meant that as a pun?
It's more of an observation, how is this halaal? I'm trying to figure that part out. The poor child dying is a sad part of it all, I am trying to figure out the hunting portion.
Click to expand...
This is going to end up in a derail very very quickly. I would think this should be discussed under the Ethical section. I'll happily participate then. Maybe.
 
RedViking said:
Hectic . I think I'm done with this thread for now.

Poor child didn't deserve this and having beef with religion to justify such an accident is a bit low.
Click to expand...
The beef is with the process... they called it hunting but its not hunting, none of it makes any sense - so its not an attack on the religion per se but on these guys just being idiots and not taking precautions.

Makes sense that a ritual slaughter shouldn't involve guns right ?
 
Nerfherder said:
The beef is with the process... they called it hunting but its not hunting, none of it makes any sense - so its not an attack on the religion per se but on these guys just being idiots and not taking precautions.

Makes sense that a ritual slaughter shouldn't involve guns right ?
Click to expand...
Yeah I've never heard of going hunting for Eid. Its usually domesticated animals slaughtered on a farm.
 
Cius said:
Only way I can see this happening is if the car was behind the animal somehow, so hunter did not clear the shot first. Perhaps it was a deflection. Still terrible either way.
Click to expand...
The cow was likely in motion and ran past the vehicle when the "hunter" took a shot without checking what was behind the target.

Negligence whichever way you look it.

The poor kid and family.

What an unnecessary and preventable tragedy.
 
OCP said:
The cow was likely in motion and ran past the vehicle when the "hunter" took a shot without checking what was behind the target.

Negligence whichever way you look it.

The poor kid and family.

What an unnecessary and preventable tragedy.
Click to expand...

The shooter is also on the young side so likely not his gun and his first time killing a wild cow. So many ways that can go wrong in the chaos.
 
EDIT: footage linked likely from a different incident. Thank you @Lupus

Nothing to do with hunting.
Was a very angry bull, not a cow.
Likely a handgun, or at least semi-automatic firearm involved trying to stop a rampaging bull that charged out of a truck.
At least three shots fired in a chaotic scenario with many people and vehicles around.
 
Last edited:
Unfortunate.
one poster said:
Nothing to do with hunting.
Was a very angry bull, not a cow.
Likely a handgun, or at least semi-automatic firearm involved trying to stop a rampaging bull that charged out of a truck.
At least three shots fired in a chaotic scenario with many people and vehicles around.

Click to expand...
While im sorry the kid died, when you see a **** show like that then its no suprise.

Next time get your meat at Spar.
 
one poster said:
Nothing to do with hunting.
Was a very angry bull, not a cow.
Likely a handgun, or at least semi-automatic firearm involved trying to stop a rampaging bull that charged out of a truck.
At least three shots fired in a chaotic scenario with many people and vehicles around.

Click to expand...
Not related at all.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X