Are generic posters and flyers that are obviously AI-generated off-putting?

Are generic posters and flyers that are obviously AI-generated off-putting?

  • I don't like it, but it's not enough to avoid a business

    Votes: 56 41.2%

  • I don't like it, and I will avoid that business

    Votes: 56 41.2%

  • I'm indifferent

    Votes: 23 16.9%

  • Other

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • Total voters
    136
BCoetzer

BCoetzer

MyBroadband Staff
Staff member
Super Moderator
Joined
May 17, 2023
Messages
202
Reaction score
131
It seems that posters and online flyers for things like weekend events, markets, conferences, expos, etc, are frequently AI-generated these days.

A lot of them seem to be in an almost identical style.

Do you find that off-putting? Would it steer you to avoid a business?
 
Its become so generic, I think it does make things less effective.

Everything looks the same so its hard to stand out.
For small businesses and kids parties its ok to have low effort but I do think as you get bigger and want to catch attention you need to do more than just spend 30 seconds on Chat-GPT
 
Yes - AI slop in marketing has replaced humans with a few Claude AI prompts - there's NO actual cognitive skill, creative talent & years of effort / training required...

AI Overview

AI slop marketing posters refer to low-effort, mass-produced promotional images and flyers generated by artificial intelligence. They are defined by an over-reliance on automated prompts rather than human design strategy. [1, 2, 3, 4]

Common Traits of AI Slop Posters
    • Visual Smear and Smoothness: Over-saturated colors, waxy or overly airbrushed textures, and nonsensical background artifacts.
    • Text Rendering Issues: Garbled, misspelled, or blocky pseudo-text that fails to communicate basic event or product details.
    • Homogenization: A repetitive "sea of sameness" look that strips away local personality, quirkiness, and brand distinction.
    • Lack of Hierarchy: Overcrowded layouts where essential information (dates, times, locations) gets lost behind decorative AI clutter. [1, 2, 3]
Why Businesses Use Them
    • Speed and Cost: Small businesses, local event organizers, and solo operators use tools like Canva, Adobe Express, or general LLMs to bypass the expense of human graphic designers.
    • Accessibility: Anyone can type a quick prompt and spit out a finished image in seconds without design training. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
Why Audiences and Designers Push Back
    • Cognitive Fatigue: Research by Nielsen IQ found that overtly AI-generated ads require extra mental effort to process, causing viewers to feel annoyed, bored, or confused.
    • Loss of Trust: Consumers increasingly associate AI-generated graphics with a lack of authenticity, empathy, or brand prestige.
    • Backlash: Fans and local communities frequently mock or call out businesses that rely on cheap AI flyers for public events.
1793261969292.png 1793262060240.png

1793262128734.png 1793262162506.png

P.S.: these posters were apparently all created by AI...

/s

spectator.com

AI is turning the world into slop

We are hurtling ever closer to a flattened future in which everything converges towards the average, the mediocre, the visual mean.
spectator.com spectator.com
 
The main problem is prompting. Most people define only very small and specific parameters for the ai to use. Better prompting = better results.
 
Same thing with Youtube thumbnails these days - so many channels' are starting look the same. Love it when you get channels where it's clearly not AI and doesn't even matter when it's sloppy.
 
For a free/community event, I think they are OK.

If a business does it, it depends what they do. If they make a conscious effort to embrace the slop (which is a cultural trend, whether we like it or not), it is fine. So doing something completely absurd would be fine with me.
Make a 100% AI slop poster for advertising a cat grooming business. Go full absurd with it.
Click to expand...
1793263454010.png

Funnily enough, asking Grok to make a low effort Word95 clipart poster is actually how people should be using it.
Make a low effort poster for a cat grooming business that looks like it was made by word 95, with comic sans and clipart
Click to expand...

1793263529329.png

If they try and use without being intentional, then it is bad, very bad.
 
HAL 9000 said:
Yes - AI slop in marketing has replaced humans with a few Claude AI prompts - there's NO actual cognitive skill, creative talent & years of effort / training required...

AI Overview

AI slop marketing posters refer to low-effort, mass-produced promotional images and flyers generated by artificial intelligence. They are defined by an over-reliance on automated prompts rather than human design strategy. [1, 2, 3, 4]

Common Traits of AI Slop Posters
    • Visual Smear and Smoothness: Over-saturated colors, waxy or overly airbrushed textures, and nonsensical background artifacts.
    • Text Rendering Issues: Garbled, misspelled, or blocky pseudo-text that fails to communicate basic event or product details.
    • Homogenization: A repetitive "sea of sameness" look that strips away local personality, quirkiness, and brand distinction.
    • Lack of Hierarchy: Overcrowded layouts where essential information (dates, times, locations) gets lost behind decorative AI clutter. [1, 2, 3]
Why Businesses Use Them
    • Speed and Cost: Small businesses, local event organizers, and solo operators use tools like Canva, Adobe Express, or general LLMs to bypass the expense of human graphic designers.
    • Accessibility: Anyone can type a quick prompt and spit out a finished image in seconds without design training. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
Why Audiences and Designers Push Back
    • Cognitive Fatigue: Research by Nielsen IQ found that overtly AI-generated ads require extra mental effort to process, causing viewers to feel annoyed, bored, or confused.
    • Loss of Trust: Consumers increasingly associate AI-generated graphics with a lack of authenticity, empathy, or brand prestige.
    • Backlash: Fans and local communities frequently mock or call out businesses that rely on cheap AI flyers for public events.
View attachment 1949073 View attachment 1949074

View attachment 1949076 View attachment 1949077

P.S.: these posters were apparently all created by AI...

/s

spectator.com

AI is turning the world into slop

We are hurtling ever closer to a flattened future in which everything converges towards the average, the mediocre, the visual mean.
spectator.com spectator.com
Click to expand...
In a thread about AI slop you use AI overview to explain what AI slop is :)
 
It depends. I have long said that the issue isn't AI, but its users. Also, people vote with their wallets. There is also enough evidence out there that people don't really care about AI use in practice, and I am speaking about sales & marketing. I have seen the data.

A well-produced AI poster won't turn people away; people won't even question whether it is AI. Did people previously care about who designed these, who approved them, who published/printed them, no. Unless you are seeking such poster services.

So, meh.

Users here pump out AI things all the time.
 
It only bothers me when the content on it isnt correct or missing key stuff.

Ive seen lots of people using it but then they forget price or contact number, etc... that frustrates me.
But i find it better at relaying info than when they didnt have it
 
They are distasteful because I know that many people have been put out of work because of it.
To my artistic eye it represents an abomination... nauseating me.
 
I hate AI slop. I hate AI on social media. Fake AI nonsense has killed off Twitter, Facebook and Instagram.

But having said that, people are already struggling in this economy, I'll cut them some slack when it comes to marketing and advertising their business, as long as it looks legible.
 
LazyLion said:
I hate AI slop. I hate AI on social media. Fake AI nonsense has killed off Twitter, Facebook and Instagram.

But having said that, people are already struggling in this economy, I'll cut them some slack when it comes to marketing and advertising their business, as long as it looks legible.
Click to expand...
The working class are struggling... them greedy mofo rich CEOs are the ones who contributed it, by believing that AI would replace people..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X