porchrat
Honorary Master
No it's a nonsense scenario. Not every person is exposed because herd immunity is a thing and the levels vary from place to place.That's just an absolute worse case scenario exaggeration, it would never get that far due to immunity of the larger group. A few thousand is a drop in the bucket compared to the population size, it's not a catastrophe, other countries have had similar numbers but you barely hear about it.
Also, some people who are vaccinated are still able to be infected and pass it on, just the duration is usually shorter. So instead of infecting like 18 people they infect maybe 3. It's not a hard binary "infect or not" like you're treating it. It varies from person to person.
The idea that some people are never even exposed is basically herd immunity as a concept. It's to keep the people who, for valid medical reasons, can't use the vaccine themselves, or for whom the vaccine isn't as efficacious, safe. You are very unlikely to ever have 100% vaccine uptake.
You can't do the calculation you've just done in epidemiology. It's not as straightforward as that. It's meaningless.
Last edited:


