The War in Gaza That Nobody Cares About
Hamas is fighting a second war in Gaza. Its enemy is Palestinian.
HEN MAZZIG
NOV 19
What is Hamas and why is it fighting with Israel in Gaza?
Shortly after midnight on Thursday, November 12, an Israeli airstrike hit Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis, in southern Gaza. Gaza health officials said six people were killed. One of them was a surgeon, Dr. Rezik Abushira, and another was a 13-year-old boy. The Israeli military said its target was Muhammad Abu Ismail, the commander of Hamas's Khan Younis Brigade, who had turned a floor of the hospital into a headquarters.
A doctor and a child are dead, and no description of the target changes that fact. I am starting there because I am about to tell you something else about that hospital and I don't want you to read this as an excuse.
Palestinians in Khan Younis have been saying for three years that Hamas brings its Palestinian prisoners to Nasser Hospital. In June, a United Nations human rights commission documented 249 cases of extrajudicial punishment in Gaza between August 2024 and January 2026, and 108 of those cases ended in death. The commission described "executions, kneecapping, bone-breaking with metal pipes or cement bricks and beatingsạẠi Hamas operatives and police were tied to nearly a quarter of the cases, and other armed groups account for more.
Witnesses told the commission that some of the punishments were carried out in hospital compounds, and they named Nasser. Earlier this year, Doctors Without Borders suspended its non-critical work at the hospital after its teams saw masked, armed men arresting patients.
Hamza al-Masri is a journalist from Gaza with more than a million Facebook followers. He reports on Hamas's violence against other Palestinians. He told the Saudi channel Al Arabiya what he says happened near that hospital: "Hamas executed 22 young men without trial inside a bus that it claimed belonged to armed militias.
This happened near Nasser Hospital, and whoever survived was executed inside the hospital.
So the building Israel bombed last week was a working hospital with surgeons and child patients, but it was also where Hamas interrogated and killed Palestinians. Both descriptions are true.
Most of the coverage I read mentioned only the first.
The enemy Hamas fears most is Palestinian
To understand why Hamas needs an interrogation site at all, you have to go back to the 1980s, before Hamas governed Gaza. A young man from Khan Younis named Yahya Sinwar helped build a unit called al-Majd. Its job was to hunt Palestinians suspected of working with Israel.
Israel arrested Sinwar in 1988 for murdering Palestinians he accused of collaboration. Thirty-five years later, he planned the October 7th massacre.
After Hamas took Gaza by force in 2007, al-Majd grew into the Internal Security apparatus, a full secret police. It planted informers in rival factions and punished anyone who criticized Hamas in public. Al-Masri described to Al Arabiya how the system handles a family that complains:
"If a family sits quietly, we don't talk; but if they speak up, then your son is an Israeli agent." In Gaza, that accusation is a death sentence. Hamas decides who they want to brand as such.
Three years of war killed many of the men who ran that apparatus, so Hamas rebuilt it, albeit in cruder form. Two units now do the work in the streets. One is called Sahm, the Arrow, and the other is Rada, Deterrence. Their members wear masks. They shoot people in the legs, break bones with pipes, and film the attacks. On October 13, 2025, three days after the ceasefire with Israel took effect, masked gunmen dragged a group of men into a square in Gaza City and shot them in front of a crowd.
Sahm shared the footage itself. The UN commission found that Hamas publicized these attacks intentionally, to frighten everyone watching.
The Gazans Hamas is trying to frighten have started shooting back. Five main armed groups now operate against Hamas, with at most a few thousand members between them. They are based in the parts of Gaza that the Israeli army still holds, east of the Yellow Line, which is the line Israeli forces pulled back to under the October 2025 ceasefire. The largest is PFR, the Popular Forces in Rafah. Its founder, Yasser Abu Shabab, was killed last December by Hamas, and his deputy Ghassan al-Duhayni now leads it. In Khan Younis, a former Palestinian Authority security officer named Hussam al-Astal runs a group called the Counter-Terrorism Strike Force. Another tormer Palestinian Authority officer, Shawqi Abu Nasira, commands the Free Homeland Forces in central Gaza.
These men raid Hamas positions and film their own operations. Hamas's actions taught them that video is how you tell Gazans who is winning. Al-Duhayni taunts Hamas on camera: "Let's see what you've got, Hamas." At the start of September, Israel's Shin Bet captured Mu'in al-Arabid, the head of Hamas's internal security apparatus, in a daytime raid in Gaza City. Israel's official statements credited its own forces. Arabic media and later the Jerusalem Post reported that Palestinian militiamen took part. Al-Araby TV said the fighters belonged to al-Duhayni.
It would be wrong to overestimate these militias' power or potential. Israel tried to build a friendly local leadership in the West Bank in the late 1970s, called the Village Leagues, and it fell apart before the first intifada. Israel armed the South Lebanon Army for two decades, and that army collapsed within days when Israeli troops left Lebanon in 2000. Michael Milshtein of Tel Aviv University, one of Israel's most respected analysts of Palestinian politics, wrote in August that the Gaza militias are isolated and close to collapse.
Still, it is wrong to overlook the fact that the Palestinians with the most to lose are the ones who say out loud that they want something other than Hamas. Al-Astal says it on camera now. He told an interviewer that there are people in Gaza today "capable of signing a stable peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians so that both peoples can live in peace." You can doubt his motives and his backers. He is still a Palestinian in Gaza risking his life for a better future.
Who is missing from the marches
For three years, the streets of London and New York have been filled with people who say they stand with Palestinians. I have watched those marches closely. I have never seen a sign for the men shot in that square in Gaza City, or a chant for the people the UN says were beaten with cement bricks. The movement has a full vocabulary for Palestinians killed by Israel, and no words at all for Palestinians killed by Hamas.
The consequence of that silence is not abstract. It allows Hamas to keep its grip on power. Milshtein reported in August that Hamas won a clause in the current negotiating framework requiring the militias to be disarmed and their members barred from any future Gaza security force. A Palestinian source told him that Jared Kushner showed "full understanding" of the demand.
Hamas itself has still not disarmed. If that clause stands, the Palestinians who took up arms against Hamas will hand over their weapons, and the masked men of Sahm and Rada will keep theirs.
Abu Nasira knows what that outcome would mean for him. "Even if they execute my entire family, from oldest to youngest, I will not back down from my decisions and my actions," he said in an interview with the pan-Arab outlet Jusoor News. He has said that Hamas raided his home and arrested his wife.
I don't know whether the militias will survive, and nobody has to cheer for them. A movement that wants Palestinians to be free should be able to say who is shooting them in the legs. I would like to hear Mayor Mamdani say the words Sahm and Rada once. I would like to see one sign at one march for the men in that square.