South African e-commerce platform suffers data breach

That isn't even the point; the card numbers and expiry dates are compromised. Bob Shop knows that and is now placing the onus on its shoppers to protect their CVV. The CCV is but a twig. It doesn't matter whether their record held a CCV or not. All these users are exposed.
Bob screwed up, we know that. That's the usual feeling when a breach occured.

All the scammers now need is the last leg auth, the cvv or otp. Bob simply stated not to share it with anyone. This is usually a perfect time for that to happen as users may think they are being helped by bob, when the scammer contact them.

To think that a simple warning after the fact is them trying to place the onus on shoppers is ridiculous.

It doesn't matter whether their record held a CCV or not
It actually does matter. Storing the CVV is forbidden under PCI DSS...encrypted or not.

And no...its not necessarily "poor security". A zero day exploit, for example, is not your fault.
 
Last edited:
Bob screwed up, we know that. That's the usual feeling when a breach occured.

True.

All the scammers now need is the last leg auth, the cvv or otp. Bob simply stated not to share it with anyone. This is usually a perfect time for that to happen as users may think they are being helped by bob, when the scammer contact them.

To think that a simple warning after the fact is them trying to place the onus on shoppers is ridiculous.

It actually does matter. Storing the CVV is forbidden under PCI DSS...encrypted or not.

Yes, a warning is good, but Bob Shop took the position that, though their users are exposed it is the users responsibility to protect their own CCV. As I said, the CCV is a twig now. There are merchants, many global ones, that make CCV optional. Enumeration attacks are real. Phishing is one method. Bob Shop should have been honest and instructed their users/shoppers to renew their bank cards where virtual ones weren’t in use, and that it will cost them time, money and inconvenience.

And no...its not necessarily "poor security". A zero day exploit, for example, is not your fault.

So Bob Shop is in the clear; it could not possibly have been due to poor security. Now I am a Bob Shop customer, and I guess you are right; it was my error to use them. Never again.
 
..but Bob Shop took the position that, though their users are exposed it is the users responsibility to protect their own CCV.
but it is their responsibility...even though bob didn't say that. The bearer of the card is in possesion of the CVV.
There are merchants, many global ones, that make CCV optional.
Now why would you want to do that? Just think of the damage that would've been done by now.
Bob Shop should have been honest and instructed their users/shoppers to renew their bank cards where virtual ones weren’t in use, and that it will cost them time, money and inconvenience.
Best option yes. Something a card user should always do. As for cost, yes...there's always a cost for convenience. Breaches do happen, and more now with the help of ai, so if a little cost, time, etc stand in one's way to protect yourself, then she/he must accept the consequences.
Or rolling the luddite way and have no digital problems.

So Bob Shop is in the clear; it could not possibly have been due to poor security.
Come on now, you know i did not say that.

The only thing i blame them for, is...they took way too much time before they warn their users.
 
Bob screwed up, we know that. That's the usual feeling when a breach occured.

All the scammers now need is the last leg auth, the cvv or otp. Bob simply stated not to share it with anyone. This is usually a perfect time for that to happen as users may think they are being helped by bob, when the scammer contact them.

To think that a simple warning after the fact is them trying to place the onus on shoppers is ridiculous.


It actually does matter. Storing the CVV is forbidden under PCI DSS...encrypted or not.

And no...its not necessarily "poor security". A zero day exploit, for example, is not your fault.
As a merchant you are allowed to store CVV under PCI DSS, but only temporarily. It must be stored encrypted and securely erased once authorisation has completed.
 
That isn't even the point; the card numbers and expiry dates are compromised. Bob Shop knows that and is now placing the onus on its shoppers to protect their CVV. The CCV is but a twig. It doesn't matter whether their record held a CCV or not. All these users are exposed.
Agreed. If your card data was exposed you need to disable your card (even if it's a virtual card) and get a new one. There are many merchants locally and globally that don't do 3D secure, and don't require a CVV to perform a transaction.
 
but it is their responsibility...even though bob didn't say that. The bearer of the card is in possesion of the CVV.

Now why would you want to do that? Just think of the damage that would've been done by now.

Best option yes. Something a card user should always do. As for cost, yes...there's always a cost for convenience. Breaches do happen, and more now with the help of ai, so if a little cost, time, etc stand in one's way to protect yourself, then she/he must accept the consequences.
Or rolling the luddite way and have no digital problems.


Come on now, you know i did not say that.

The only thing i blame them for, is...they took way too much time before they warn their users.

I still haven't received the notice. MyBroadband was my source.
 
As a merchant you are allowed to store CVV under PCI DSS, but only temporarily. It must be stored encrypted and securely erased once authorisation has completed.
Nope.

You capture the CVV for authorization, you don't store it, ever. Auth happens right that very second/s after its captured and for that second or 3 it is kept in RAM. After authorization, you do not need the CVV to process the transaction. That is why you sometimes can see something like "authorized but not processed" as the transaction goes into a queue.

I think because it states "you cannot store the CVV after authorization" you understand it as, that means you can store it before the fact.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X