Telecoms28.08.2007

Lust for monopoly power

The first was why, according to the tribunal, Telkom really wanted to buy BCX.

The second was the extent to which BCX prejudiced its own BCX Communications subsidiary – unwittingly or not – by working towards merging with Telkom even before the tribunal had been allowed to rule on the deal.

The third was just how bleak the prognosis is for Neotel as a timely and formidable competitor to Telkom.

On the first of those the tribunal asserted that Telkom’s rationale for the merger wasn’t a search for alternate revenue streams. Given that margins in SA’s IT services market were very small and barriers to entry were low, the tribunal said it was difficult to understand why Telkom couldn’t enter that market organically but was rather willing to pay a premium for such a small margin gain.

The tribunal found the merger was rather an “attempt by an erstwhile monopolist to thwart the beneficial impact of deregulation in the form of greater economies of scale and scope for rival managed network service (MNS) providers and lower cost for customers”.

That again raises the question of what Telkom would put forward as an alternate strategy to significantly enter the IT services market, particularly if it wasn’t just seeking additional revenues but rather looking for a player with significant clout.

There aren’t too many of those around. In fact, Dimension Data is really the only other and both sides previously scoffed at suggestions of a tie-up between them (not to mention what SA’s competition authorities would say).

Acting Telkom CEO Reuben September said at the time of the annual results in June that it had an alternative course of action. However, nothing has yet been forthcoming. Perhaps it’s been waiting to see the tribunal’s ruling on BCX before announcing its next steps?

The transaction with BCX, the tribunal said, would have resulted in Telkom removing an effective competitor in the “dynamic MNS market in which the VPN (virtual private network) is becoming the product of choice”.

And although Telkom had argued that it would keep BCX operating as a separate subsidiary – hoping that would quell some concerns regarding cross-subsidisation – the tribunal said that would “have provided Telkom with an unregulated subsidiary through which it would seek to evade regulation”.

The tribunal believed that the merger wouldn’t only have removed a competitor but could also have tipped the market in favour of the merged entity, constraining the expansion of rivals and deterring new entrants.

Second, the tribunal’s ruling hits home concerning the extent to which BCX Communications would have suffered as a result of the contemplated transaction.

The tribunal outlined how BCX had raved about the capacity and potential of BCX Comms before the Telkom deal was on the table but downplayed its potential and emphasised its underperformance during the hearings.

The tribunal said while it was conceivable that BCX Comms wouldn’t enjoy rapid growth in revenues or client base while upgrading the network “its subsequent difficulties seem to have been caused more by Telkom’s presence and influence in the business of BCX than by BCX Comms”.

The tribunal said: “The merger, for all intents and purposes, had been implemented without authorisation from the tribunal” – instancing integration meetings between BCX and Telkom employees, Telkom attending client meetings with BCX and attracting at least one significant client.

Telkom’s actions in attempting to win customers at all costs – even to the detriment of a potential subsidiary – point to an almost desperate desire to shore up revenues in the face of impending competition.

However, BCX also seems to have been negligent in allowing itself to have been walked over in that regard. Apparently it didn’t protect the value of an investment that it made with shareholders’ money.

The extent to which BCX will be able to rectify that will be evident when CEO Benjamin Mophatlane reports on the company’s results over the next few periods.

The third observation relates to Neotel’s market presence. The tribunal paints a pretty bleak picture, saying that although Neotel’s entry into the market is likely, it won’t be timely or sufficient to be a major threat to Telkom in the MNS market.

A negative verdict by the tribunal did seem to have been the only course of action on political grounds; allowing the deal would have gone against the overwhelming groundswell towards reducing telecoms prices by increasing competition. However, it appears it would have been difficult to refute the thoroughness of the tribunal’s findings even if Telkom had decided to take its decision on appeal.

Comments

Finweek

 

Show comments

Latest news

More news

Trending news

Poll

If money was no issue, which brand of smartphone would you buy?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter