Camera : Xperia Z2 vs Galaxy S5 vs HTC One M8 vs LG G Pro 2

Dubes

Expert Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2013
Messages
1,509
Reaction score
0
A camera is important to me so I found this Chinese site with comparison shots from the four flagships useful. Full images here: http://www.eprice.com.tw/mobile/talk/124/4899662/1/rv/sony-xperia-z2-review/ Be careful, translate messes up the format so difficult to tell which photo is which.


The main two I am focussing on, for now, is the S5 and the Z2 so I did some 100% crops from each to compare.

Interesting to see most of the Z2 shots appear to be too "soft" and the S5 possibly too "sharp". If I were to choose I'd pick the S5 purely because there is more detail as can be seen in the daytime crops below. My phone barcode scanner was able to read the S5 barcode, not the Z2.

In each case the Z2 crop is on top, the S5 crop at the bottom. Please note these are taken from three different images so it seems unlikely it was a focus issue on each occasion. If it was then there is a focus problem to be worried about.

Shield.jpg

Shops.jpg

Wheel.jpg

Plants.jpg


I realise these things can be tweaked via software upgrades, and it is still early days, but I still find it interesting to do comparisons at these early stages. The Z2 has the sensor size (1/2.3" vs 1/2.6") and the pixel advantage (20MP vs 16MP) so theoretically it should produce better images.


I know many of you will argue against pixel peeking but it's something I like to do when assessing a camera. The overall picture is obviously most important though and these can be viewed on the link at the top of this post.
 
Last edited:
There were some low light samples on the site too : http://www.eprice.com.tw/mobile/talk/124/4899661/1/rv/sony-xperia-z2-review/

In certain instances here, although at pixel level they are both not great, I'd argue that the softening effect of the Z2 may well result in more appealing images (the statue face) while other times there is just no detail at all (the stained glass window and green ferris wheel).

Again in each case the Z2 crop is on top, the S5 crop at the bottom.

Window.jpg

Building.jpg

Statue.jpg

Sign.jpg

Shield.jpg

Wheel.jpg

Please note these are not the views as a professional photographer but as a layperson without any technical expertise attached. I am calling it as I see it, you may see it different. Seeing as I was doing it for myself I thought I'd share.
 
Last edited:
Strange... My Z1 takes more detailed pics than that. Sadly asking what modes they used would be fruitless as I doubt OP can read chinese
 
The Z2 NR Algorithm is to aggressive it will produce way better images when turned off on my Nubia Z5s with it images are similar to to the z2 luckily Snapdragon Soc has wavelet denoise camera parameter to turn it off also there is another another post process called DOC/pretty Mode turning this of also results in less soft images. So it's a software thing that can be dealt with a few mods.
 
Not gonna read that article. Doesn't even have the Nokia. Can't have a camera shoutout without that these days.
 
Strange... My Z1 takes more detailed pics than that. Sadly asking what modes they used would be fruitless as I doubt OP can read chinese

I can't but Google translate gives it a good go and all phones were set on auto mode with centre weighted focus:

Also, because the manual selection of focus and touch focus will result in different phones have different settings on the meter, so in contrast to day photo shoot part, we compare the way cf night shoot, all mining in general shooting mode, the central point is automatically Focus and press the shutter button to take pictures of the way to do the test, in addition, no other additional settings for individual models.

Remember that this is pixel peeking. The full size photos for the Z2 look detailed too until you zoom right in. But yeah, as admitted both these phones can be tweaked still.
 
Not gonna read that article. Doesn't even have the Nokia. Can't have a camera shoutout without that these days.

What Nokia flagship was released in the last few weeks though? I agree that a control photo from the 808 or 1020 would've been nice. I have seen another comparison where the 1520 (I think it was) was used and I was saddened to see the poor colour reproduction and white balance when compared to the others.
 
Derp forgot about Google translate.

Now my question, was the Z2 in superior auto? That doesn't run full megapixel pictures, I know in my Z1 I'm limited to 8mp on superior auto, manual mode gives the full 20. No idea if this still holds for the Z2 though.
 
Derp forgot about Google translate.

Now my question, was the Z2 in superior auto? That doesn't run full megapixel pictures, I know in my Z1 I'm limited to 8mp on superior auto, manual mode gives the full 20. No idea if this still holds for the Z2 though.

EXIF from the full size image showing the shield:

Sony.jpg

Samsun.jpg
 
What Nokia flagship was released in the last few weeks though? I agree that a control photo from the 808 or 1020 would've been nice. I have seen another comparison where the 1520 (I think it was) was used and I was saddened to see the poor colour reproduction and white balance when compared to the others.

that 1520 is supposed to be the best they have. isn't it some stupid amount of megapixels? you telling me it isn't even worth it? stupid nokia.
 
that 1520 is supposed to be the best they have. isn't it some stupid amount of megapixels? you telling me it isn't even worth it? stupid nokia.

The 1020 is the "stupid amount of megapixels" one at 41MP. The 1520 "only" has 20MP. Don't get me wrong, the photos I have seen from these two phones are far superior to anything else out there but I have seen some complaints about colour reproduction. The black update ma have resolved some and I'm sure software tweaks could resolve more.

Those 1020 will always kill others based purely on physics...

sensorsizes.jpg
 
The 1020 is the "stupid amount of megapixels" one at 41MP. The 1520 "only" has 20MP. Don't get me wrong, the photos I have seen from these two phones are far superior to anything else out there but I have seen some complaints about colour reproduction. The black update ma have resolved some and I'm sure software tweaks could resolve more.

Those 1020 will always kill others based purely on physics...

View attachment 108880

ahh so the 1020 Is the one to get. nice. when I upgrade its hopefully costs something sensible.
 
ahh so the 1020 Is the one to get. nice. when I upgrade its hopefully costs something sensible.

I've been very tempted to get the 1020, still am... but keep getting lured by Android :(

Here is a comparison review including the 1520, S4, S5, Note 3 and Z1. You can see the colour is different to the rest for the 1520. It could be argued, and is often shown, that Nokia favours "as close to reality" images whereas others seem to favour over-processed, over-saturated images. You'd need to have actually been there to decide which best mimics reality. I have not pixel peeked these images yet but may do so.

http://www.soyacincau.com/2014/03/25/samsung-galaxy-s5-camera-photos-video-comparison/
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X