Tidal: CD-quality Lossless Music Streaming Service

CuppaJoe

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 4, 2014
Messages
532
Reaction score
0
Tidal's CD-quality lossless music streaming service is now also available in SA.

https://tidalhifi.com/za

Currently on the 7-day free trial and must say it is quite good.

Anyone else also trying it out?
 
Any site that wants CC details for a trial can feck off no matter how good they are.
 
Any site that wants CC details for a trial can feck off no matter how good they are.

They accept Paypal, mate.

That way you have control over it, and they cannot keep on charging you if you cancelled.

They are asking the details to make it more difficult for the chancers to register the trial under different email addresses, once the 7 days have passed.
 
I tried it at the beginning of Feb - signed up for the trial with paypal and used Hola through Chrome.

Was really easy.

While the quality is excellent and stereo soundstage incredibly good (FLAC/ALAC, as it should be) - it simply isn't much better than Spotify High Quality mode to warrant double the price.

For reference testing, I used my iBasso D10 Cobra DAC + Windows and Monster Turbine Copper Pro IEM's, also tried streaming via Airplay and ALAC from my iPad / iPhone to my Anthem MRX300 + Infinity Speakers.

There is a Tidal Hifi Test you can take, and I consistently only got 2 out of 5 correct. I consider myself an audiophile and am a classically trained musician with perfect pitch. I can readily spot the difference between OGG and MP3 compression modes of varying quality in blind A B testing. Then again, everyone's ears perceive sound differently, more so as we get older and our hearing deteriorates.

Also, the desktop app is terrible on Windows and MAC, slow and often has drop outs.

The iOS app is really good, but feels like a version 1 app and pales in comparison to Spotify's mobile apps which are arguably the best in the business.

I tried and wanted to like it. They even have a beta Spotify playlist import tool to help users move over to their service, but the issues above, plus the time taken to start a lossless stream (which sometimes take 20s per track) is just pointless.

Staying with Spotify and glad I did, but admire Tidal for their effort.

Hope that helps ...
 
Last edited:
I tried it at the beginning of Feb - signed up for the trial with paypal and used Hola through Chrome.

Was really easy.

While the quality is excellent and stereo soundstage incredibly good (FLAC/ALAC, as it should be) - it simply isn't much better than Spotify High Quality mode to warrant double the price.

For reference testing, I used my iBasso D10 Cobra DAC + Windows and Monster Turbine Copper Pro IEM's, also tried streaming via Airplay and ALAC from my iPad / iPhone to my Anthem MRX300 + Infinity Speakers.

There is a Tidal Hifi Test you can take, and I consistently only got 2 out of 5 correct. I consider myself an audiophile and am a classically trained musician with perfect pitch. I can readily spot the difference between OGG and MP3 compression modes of varying quality in blind A B testing. Then again, everyone's ears perceive sound differently, more so as we get older and our hearing deteriorates.

Also, the desktop app is terrible on Windows and MAC, slow and often has drop outs.

The iOS app is really good, but feels like a version 1 app and pales in comparison to Spotify's mobile apps which are arguably the best in the business.

I tried and wanted to like it. They even have a beta Spotify playlist import tool to help users move over to their service, but the issues above, plus the time taken to start a lossless stream (which sometimes take 20s per track) is just pointless.

Staying with Spotify and glad I did, but admire Tidal for their effort.

Hope that helps ...

What? Aren't both +-$9?
 
What? Aren't both +-$9?

Tidal is $20 in the US and 20 Pounds in the UK :wtf:

Spotify Premium US is $10.

I cannot justify the price. If it comes down and the app experience improves ... then maybe yes. But I've been on Spotify for 3 years (almost since inception) and I'm pretty hooked.
 
Any site that doesn't require CC details for a trial is retarded.

It's way too easy to just create a free email address and carry on using the trial forever.

There are virtual credit cards as well. You could do pretty much the same thing.
 
Tidal is $20 in the US and 20 Pounds in the UK :wtf:

Spotify Premium US is $10.

I cannot justify the price. If it comes down and the app experience improves ... then maybe yes. But I've been on Spotify for 3 years (almost since inception) and I'm pretty hooked.

Yikes. o_O

Guess this article got it wrong.

Seems that $19.99 is for the US/UK. backstreetboy gets $9.99 when he goes to payment on the website.
 
Seems that $19.99 is for the US/UK. backstreetboy gets $9.99 when he goes to payment on the website.

This is very weird.

Ok I see they don't have a geo-restriction for SA IP addresses anymore - a few weeks ago you needed to bypass it using Hola etc.

And the price is $9.99 for SA bound IP addresses.

Then it is a good deal - but what I wrote still stands - Spotify and their US catalogue and app awesomness are still better.

I wouldn't be surprised if the Tidal SA music catalogue has quite a few tracks missing - it did for me even using the US one.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X