Not maybe, Karens should learn to mind their own god damn business.
If they don't like something, don't do it or buy it. Should stop preaching to other people what they can and can't do.
If they want a power trip, they can go play HOA.
Comparing sugar to cigarettes is a major error. Cigarettes damage cells via direct toxicity and mutation, meaning their ideal physiological dose is zero. Refined sugar is a carbohydrate; the human body has highly evolved pathways (glycolysis, glycogenesis) explicitly designed to process it into cellular energy (ATP). To call a fundamental energy source "objectively unhealthy" shows a total lack of basic biochemistry knowledge.
Ignorance of Industry and History
The prediction that "industries will collapse" because people will just stop eating sugar is economically and behaviorally incorrect:
- Humans have a hardwired evolutionary preference for sweetness because it signaled safe, calorie-dense energy in nature.
- Sugar is a highly functional ingredient used for preservation, texture, and fermentation, not just sweetening.
- The global food industry isn't collapsing; it is simply diversifying into different formulations because people want options, not because sugar is going extinct.
Arrogant Dogmatism vs. Real Life
The line,
"Maybe people should rather just get with the times and adapt?" is incredibly elitist and detached from reality. It Completely ignores:
- The 90-year-old man who just wants a pleasant cup of tea.
- The elite marathon runner who needs fast-acting glycemic carbs to avoid hitting the wall.
- The billions of people for whom food is a source of cultural connection, joy, and comfort, not a clinical optimization maths problem.
Even the World Health Organisation does not ban sugar out right but recommends it only make up to 10% of the energy intake.
WHO fact sheet on healthy diet with key facts and information on essential dietary elements, practical advice, salt, sodium and potassium, sugars, health diet promotion, WHO response.
www.who.int
Unlike cigarettes for which there is no minimum safe dose.
The issue with sugar or any energy intake is balance. Once you do something out of moderation, it's becomes bad for you 'objectively'. Too much exercise and too much sedentary life are both bad. Too little energy intake is also bad. Your body will break down your muscles.
Also talk to obese people you see, you will likely find that few stuff their faces with sweets or Coke, but most probably have high starch diets with relatively little exercise going back decades. Should the maize, wheat and rice industries also go extinct?