Every year it is suggested (sometimes by me) that England's fourth Champions League spot should go to the FA Cup winners. Yes, the big four have dominated that competition, but they have been aided by clubs lower down the Premiership fielding weakened teams. The prize at stake - glory and a UEFA Cup spot - is not considered important enough in these money-obsessed times until sides have reached the last eight or even the semi-finals.
I love the Cup in particular and knock-out football in general, so would welcome such a move to reivingorate the world's oldest tournament. There is another competition that could do with livening up, however: the Premiership. Copy an idea from Holland and some of the kinks could be ironed out of England's top flight, too. And this idea has more chance of being adopted than giving a place in Europe's elite to the Cup winners.
Holland gets two Champions League places. The title winners enter the group stage, but the teams finishing second to fifth in the table play off for a place in the third qualifying round. Twente play Alkmaar and Heerenveen play Ajax in the first legs of the semi-finals on Wednesday.
England has four places in the Champions League. The top two enter the group stage and third place gets a third-qualfying-round berth, as does fourth. It would be nice if the last place went to the FA Cup - but imagine instead that it was the subject of a play-off disputed between the teams finishing from fourth to seventh.
For a start, there would be a difference between third and fourth, where currently there is none. Rafa Benitez has done nothing wrong by fielding weakened teams and some complaining have done the same in inverted circumstances. Neil Warnock rested players at Old Trafford - would a full-strength Sheffield United have fared better and aided Chelsea's title challenge?
However, if fourth place meant only a play-off then Liverpool would have been at full strength against Portsmouth and Fulham to hold off the challenge of Arsenal.
How much fiercer, too, would be the contest for seventh. Reading are up there almost by default, thanks to Steve Coppell's attitude to the UEFA Cup. But there would be none of that ambivalence if Reading were in with a chance of a Champions League play-off.
The big four come ever closer to establishing an uncontestable supremacy. Everton broke into the top four when Liverpool's Spanish contingent were learning the ropes. Spurs came close last year when Arsenal lost their way. But this season a gap has opened up despite some indifferent displays from Arsenal and Liverpool's poor start, and the biggest serious challenge to the top four's monopoly on the Champions League is now large-scale outside investment.
If, however, each year one of the quartet had to face a play-off, then anything could happen.
Such a prospect would damage the FA Cup further, it's true, giving challengers for the top seven another excuse to downgrade the FA Cup. But given the general determination to downplay that competition's importance, the change would not be that noticeable.
The Premiership would be on a similar footing to the lower divisions, with the play-offs helping to maintain interest well down the table and right until the end of the season.
Liverpool, as they did in 2005, would be complicating matters this season if they were to slip to fourth on Sunday. The holders of the European Cup now defend their title at the expense of the last-placed qualifiers from another country, entering the group stage as of right. In 2005 UEFA rightly rewrote the rules. Now, with Liverpool in the final, if they slipped to fourth in the end-of-season Premiership standings, then the play-offs could not begin until after 23 May and their meeting with Milan in Athens.
But if Liverpool did win the competition and finish fourth, then Arsenal would go in the play-offs, to be held in late July and early August. Yes, that would be an inconvenience, but worth the prize at stake rather more than the Intertoto and UEFA Cup qualifying.
It would also be awkward if a top-seven team were in the FA Cup final. But in most seasons the play-offs could be accommodated easily enough. The League Two final would move to Friday night, League One to Saturday and the Championship to Sunday, leaving Bank Holiday Monday for the Premiership play-off final at a packed Wembley.
To enact this change would require the votes of two-thirds of the Premiership clubs, that is 14. A high threshold, but as the change would give anyone with dreams, hopes or expectations of seventh a shot, such a move would not be out of the question. Indeed, you would need three clubs to vote against their own interests for this to happen.
If one or more of the big four slip up, then this system could allow them a chance to get back into the Champions League. But more likely is that in a knock-out context, a poorer club would make the extra effort.
I would rather see the FA Cup bolstered, to restore the balance between leagye and knock-out football. But the resistance to that idea may be too strong - you would have to change the Champions League rules - unless Michel Platini backs it in his new role as UEFA president. The Premier League could introduce play-offs next season if they voted for them now.