Anger over Mandela 'corpse' painting

d7e7r7

Executive Member
Joined
May 30, 2009
Messages
8,945
Reaction score
938
Location
Cape Town
http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Anger-over-Mandela-corpse-painting-20100709

Johannesburg - A painting depicting Nelson Mandela as a corpse undergoing an autopsy is causing a stir in a Johannesburg shopping centre, the Mail & Guardian reported on Friday.

The painting is a modern take of a 17th century Rembrandt painting called The Anatomy Lesson of Dr Nicolaes Tripp which depicts an autopsy being undertaken in front of a group of doctors.

In artist Yiull Damaso's version, former president Mandela is the cadaver with late Aids orphan Nkosi Johnson performing the autopsy. Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu and politicians FW de Klerk, Jacob Zuma, Cyril Ramaphosa, Trevor Manuel, Thabo Mbeki and Helen Zille look on.

This week the Hyde Park shopping centre, where the painting is being housed, received complaints about the work.

Damaso said he was called into the shop because a person wanted to speak to him on the phone.

Freedom of expression and art

"The person on the phone told me that she was a friend of one of Mandela's daughters and that the daughter was very upset about the painting. I was told that they had recently had a death in the family and that they are still very bereaved".

The Hyde Park shopping centre's marketing manager Nicola van Kan told the newspaper: "We feel it is a controversial piece... but we support freedom of expression and art."

She said the centre had spoken to Damaso after the complaints.

"He explained the piece and we were happy with that."

Talking about the controversy, Damaso told the Mail & Guardian: "The eventual passing of Mr Mandela is something that we will have to face, as individuals, as a nation."

Nelson Mandela turns 92 on July 18.

In 2000 Damaso produced a series of paintings depicting Mandela with dreadlocks and as elderly and wearing boxing gloves and a tiny belt.

At the time the Nelson Mandela Foundation apparently took issue with the paintings.

"They told me that his image was copyrighted. But how can you copyright the image of a public figure," he told the newspaper.

- Mail & Guardian story
- SAPA

Does anyone know where I can get an image of this painting? There is one here: http://www.mg.co.za/article/2010-07-09-anc-outraged-over-mandela-painting but its mostly the artist and you cant see the painting very well.
 
The comments under the article illustrate the real problem - ignorance.

The artist is using a famous painting by Rembrandt while intentionally, (I hope), making it look like a knock-off so that people will do a double-take. I immediately interpreted it as a lesson to the politicians who are looking on. If anything this is complementary to the subject of the painting. Anyone that didn't get that misconstrued the artist's intention, perhaps wilfully in some cases if those article comments are anything to go by.

I would also question the journalist's comment about the artist being "no stranger to controversy". What about the portrait of Mandela wearing an AIDS ribbon? There doesn't seem to have been any controversy about the depiction in that particular painting.
 
Last edited:
The comments under the article illustrate the real problem - ignorance.

The artist is using a famous painting by Rembrandt while intentionally, (I hope), making it look like a knock-off so that people will do a double-take. I immediately interpreted it as a lesson to the politicians who are looking on.

What sort - an anatomy lesson? ;-)

I don't think I understand it, or like it very much. Not something i'd have on my wall even if it wasn't full of politicians. But the ANC is well within its rights to be disgusted, outraged, angry or whatever else it wants to be.

Not within its rights to do anything constuctive with the following, though:

"We therefore remain resolute and unmoved in our call for an independent arbiter in the form of a media appeals tribunal to monitor, regulate and chastise the kind of gutter, soulless and disrespectful journalism of Mail & Guardian." - Jackson Mthembu

Suck it, you dumb varks. There will be no sacred cows in this country! Where do you think you are -- India?
 
Mandela corpse painting is insulting - ANC

http://www.tonight.co.za/index.php?fArticleId=5549280

Mandela corpse painting is insulting - ANC

The African National Congress says a painting depicting Nelson Mandela as a corpse undergoing an autopsy is appalling.

The painting, by Yiull Damaso, is being housed in the Hyde Park shopping centre in Johannesburg.

It is a modern take of a 17th century Rembrandt painting called "The Anatomy Lesson of Dr Nicolaes Tripp" which depicts an autopsy being undertaken in front of a group of doctors. In this version, former president Mandela is the cadaver with late Aids orphan Nkosi Johnson performing the autopsy. Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu and politicians FW de Klerk, Jacob Zuma, Cyril Ramaphosa, Trevor Manuel, Thabo Mbeki and Helen Zille look on.

The painting has prompted complaints to the art gallery.

In a statement, the ANC says that it is appalled and "strongly condemns in the strongest possible terms" the painting.

"It is in bad taste, disrespectful, and it is an insult and an affront to values of our society," the statement says.

The ANC also launched an attack on the Mail & Guardian, which carried the orignal report about the painting. The statement says that the paper carried the picture on the front page and the story "only on page 10 (which) (by any measure of newsworthiness is less significant)". The statement says this adds insult to injury and is "gutter journalism and soulless sensationalism which knows no limit and will exploits anything to increase its bottom line".

The statement goes on: "In African society it is a foreign act of ubuthakathi (bewitch) to kill a living person and this so called work of art which is also racist. It goes further by violating Tat' uMandela's dignity by stripping him naked in the glare of curious onlookers some of whom have seen their apartheid ideals die before them.


"Mandela is our international icon, respected and celebrated the world over as the source of wisdom and the humanity well from which to drink. He is a man whose ideals would live forever and whom we should cherish and respect and forever hold dear. That is why we are more shocked and disgusted this so called art that depicts a dead Madiba.

"Why would anyone dream of a dead Madiba? Why would newspapers including the Mail and Guardian put to prominence this work of rubbish in their publication? Why would a respected public space and business site, Hyde Park be a home for the creation of such insulting work to our icon, our leaders and all of us?

"We strongly condemn the practice and promotion of the freedom of expression and freedom of the arts which knows no bounds and only sees itself as the most supreme freedom that supersedes and tramples other people's constitutional rights to dignity and privacy, and undermines our values.

"This unbridled freedom of the media, as evidenced by projection of this so called art in the Mail and Guardian, confirms that the self-regulated print media environment is a recipe for disaster and negates the core values we hold dear as the society as contained in our constitution.

"We therefore remain resolute and unmoved in our call for an independent arbiter in the form of a Media Appeals Tribunal to monitor, regulate and chastise the kind of gutter, soulless and disrespectful journalism of Mail and Guardian."
 
What sort - an anatomy lesson? ;-)

I don't think I understand it, or like it very much. Not something i'd have on my wall even if it wasn't full of politicians. But the ANC is well within its rights to be disgusted, outraged, angry or whatever else it wants to be.

The metaphor is simple enough, that those looking on can learn from Mandela.
Analysing it any further would require unnecessary subjectivity.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X