So this is what my cart looks like right now:
Intel Core i5-4570, 3.2GHz, LGA1150, Quad Core (with 4 threads), 22nm, 6MB L3 caIntel Core i5-4570, 3.2GHz, LGA1150, Quad Core (with 4 threads), 22nm, 6MB L3
R2,422
be quiet! Shadow Rock TopFlow SR1, copper base + 53x aluminum fins with 4x heatpbe quiet! Shadow Rock TopFlow SR1, copper base + 53x aluminum fins with 4x
R425
Corsair CMZ8GX3M1A1600C10, 8GB, Vengeance with black heatsink, DDR3-1600, CL10,Corsair CMZ8GX3M1A1600C10, 8GB, Vengeance with black heatsink, DDR3-1600, CL10
R1,011
ASRock Z87 Extreme3, all-in-one LGA1150, Intel Z87, 4x dual channel DDR3 2933+,ASRock Z87 Extreme3, all-in-one LGA1150, Intel Z87, 4x dual channel DDR3 2933+,
R1,855
The RAM and motherboard I'm happy with.
1. CPU: Not sure - wondering if I can shave some cost off by going with an i3 (given what I currently have)
2. Heatsink - Not going to be overclocking, you guys think I could get away with one of the Zalman's? (1/2 the price)
Also, what power supply do you recommend?
I ended up using this exact same CPU with the stock cooler. It's very quiet, and I can not recommended an aftermarket cooler seeing as this is not a K CPU so you will not be overclocking at all. I also agree that the MoBo, will probably be overkill for the CPU.
You should be fine with a 500 - 600 Watt PSU. I'm a big Corsair PSU fan boy so I would recommend a GS500 or CX500.