Copyright Amendment Bill approved by SA Cabinet

Here's the draft - doesn't look good for photographers, at least not as good as it could have been. :o

http://www.gov.za/sites/www.gov.za/files/39028_gon646c.pdf
TL;DR which part is it you have a problem with?

How is this possible? I thought any photo you take belongs to you. The client gets copies, but you remain the creator. Surely?
That isn't always the case even in other countries. A photographer may not be the creator as they didn't do much other than click a button. In a collaborative effort where there is a photographer, a director and a model any of these can be the creator or it could be collaborative effort. People should learn that no matter what the law says there should always be a contract and in commissioned works this contract usually defaults to the commissioner having copyright.

So you feel that if a person commissions a painting that the painting should belong to the artist and not the client?

And if I ask a builder to build me a house you think the house should belong to the builder once completed? Should we all rent from builders?

Why is it that artist feel that their work is somehow special and should be treated differently from others.
I actually don't but if the person commissioning it wants to have copyright they should also pay an appropriate amount. I think this is largely an attitude that started with amateur photographers. They can't charge enough because they don't have the skills so their contracts state they retain copyright to make money off their photos. Professional photographers with the skills don't care about letting go of their work and you won't find any of the major publications where it states copyright to pictures belong to the photographer.
 
I attended the Copyright amendment bill conference last week in Boxburg. The bill is still in the public domain for written comments until the 16th of September. Some interesting insight between fair use, and fair dealing. Interestingly, the Google guy who spoke acknowledged the fact that any torrent or Pirate Bay searches are ranked to the 14/15 page as nobody will look that far (I know there were a reason I did not use Google as my default browser!). From one of the other speakers, the request was made to not rank it, but completely remove those sites from Google searches.
 
Interesting as I always have to scroll past 15 pages of torrents to get to the good stuff.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X