Deadly Knysna blazes not started deliberately - fire chief

schumi

Honorary Master
Joined
Mar 26, 2010
Messages
25,095
Reaction score
2,032
Location
Durban
Cape Town - There was no evidence that the devastating fires in Knysna and Plettenberg Bay in June were set deliberately, Knysna Fire Chief Clinton Manuel said on Monday.

"I cannot say that the fire was set deliberately," said Manuel, as the report into the fire, which killed seven people and destroyed at least 1 000 houses, was released.

Scientific analysis showed that the fire probably started in a clearing on private land in a mountainous area called Elandskraal, and that the fuel was probably pine cones. There are no pine trees in the area, but there was a footpath and an access road, which indicated human activity at the clearing.

"The probable cause comes down to that pine cone," said Manuel.

The investigators had also considered the possibility that a lightning strike in April had caused a smouldering fire, but the pine cone theory was more likely, he said.

A second fire was believed to have been started at Kruisfontein by somebody sleeping in the bushes, but high winds had changed direction so quickly, that that fire had moved over the mountain towards Plettenberg Bay, before changing direction again and heading back towards Noetzie.

Municipal Manager Kam Chetty said that the estimated losses to municipalities, as a result of the fires, were valued at around R496m.

Nobody had been arrested in connection with the fires, but the matter would be handed to the police who would investigate further.

Seven people were killed as the fires raged across the Eden Municipality - which includes Knysna and Bitou - between June 6-10.

Gale force winds exceeded 90km/h, making it difficult for firefighters to bring the blaze under control, and over 10 000 people had to be evacuated from their homes at night, some by boat.

Volunteer firefighter, 24-year-old Bradley Richards, was among those who died, and his colleague Ian Barnard was injured.

The Western Cape Premier Helen Zille declared Knysna and Plettenberg Bay a disaster zone, and massive relief and rebuilding efforts had been underway since then, with the municipality waiving some of its usual planning fees.

At the time, there were questions over whether the fires had been started deliberately, with a voice note being circulated with this aim, but authorities wanted to wait for the outcome of an investigation before pronouncing on this.

News24
http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/N...-not-started-deliberately-fire-chief-20170814
 
Motive, mad man or negligence? I seriously doubt we will ever have a concrete answer.
 
Knysna inferno bill estimated at R4bn

Knysna - The catastrophic fire that engulfed the holiday town of Knysna, cost R4 billion and was probably started by someone burning pine cones.

Yesterday the municipality’s Fire and Rescue Services released the fire report detailing the extent of the damage. The report found that the fire was started by burning pine cones in a clearing on private land in the Elandskraal area. It is unclear whether the fire was started deliberately only that “human activity” was to blame.

The Chief of Fire and Rescue in Knysna, Clinton Manuel, said the investigation started on June 8, a day after three fires broke out in Knysna. “Using the scientific method while investigating the fire I came up with two hypotheses. The first one is based on the fostering part that the fire started in the Non V area (Which refers to the shape in which the fire was burnt) and that the fire was caused by lightning on April 12. This forms the basis of hypothesis one.

“Hypothesis two is that the fire originated in the V pattern area in the Elandskraal area (the fire spread in a distinctive pattern) and is probably man made and not an act of God,” Manuel said.

He also said the wind played a huge role in the spreading of the fire. “What we know about wildfires is that it first ignites light fuel and then spreads to heavy fuels. What we also know is that the fires also form a distinctive V pattern, we also know heavy fuels were found in the clearing.”

Manuel used science to assist him to compile the report.

More at: https://www.iol.co.za/capeargus/news/knysna-inferno-bill-estimated-at-r4bn-10800232
 
What shyte reporting :erm:
Deadly Knysna blazes not started deliberately - fire chief
..then ...
There was no evidence that the devastating fires in Knysna and Plettenberg Bay in June were set deliberately, Knysna Fire Chief Clinton Manuel said on Monday.
...then ....

"I cannot say that the fire was set deliberately," said Manuel
..then ...

Scientific analysis showed that the fire probably started ...[snip] and that the fuel was probably pine cones. There are no pine trees in the area, but there was a footpath and an access road, which indicated human activity at the clearing.

"The probable cause comes down to that pine cone," said Manuel.

W... T ... actual ...F ?
Spontaneous combustion of a pine cone ?
 
Article was so badly written and so full of stupid that the Andromeda Galaxy moved away from us a little and John Crichton decided to rather not come back at all.
 
I've been there not too long ago, the houses we stayed in are no longer there. Only a gate lying against a piece of wall, nothing else left.
 
If evidence was found it would likely have been buried.
 
W... T ... actual ...F ?
Spontaneous combustion of a pine cone ?

Or just shyte understanding?

Pine cones could have been there for ages... Heck, could have been some boy scout group that dropped a few and then months later those are the culprit pine cones. There is a good reason why arson is mighty difficult to prove
 
Or just shyte understanding?

Pine cones could have been there for ages... Heck, could have been some boy scout group that dropped a few and then months later those are the culprit pine cones. There is a good reason why arson is mighty difficult to prove

So it was possible to glean from the report whether the fire chief had actually concluded that the fires were started deliberately or not?
Spontaneously combusting pine cones comments were executed with tongue firmly in cheek seeing as that seemed the the most believable part of the story to me:D
...because in another report ....
The report found that the fire was started by burning pine cones in a clearing on private land in the Elandskraal area. It is unclear whether the fire was started deliberately only that “human activity” was to blame.
 
Last edited:
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X