Dual sim phones

SherylP

New Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2019
Messages
5
Reaction score
1
We acquired a Huawei P20 Lite from Cell C in December. My daughter was really happy with the phone. One sim slot held her Vodacom contract sim and the other her Cell C data sim. Regretfully she had it in her jeans back pocket and it fell in the toilet! She bravely fished it out, but it died over the course of the day - the same day she moved into her university residence in a different city from her home! I bit the bullet and went off to Vodacom to take out another contract for her, again choosing the Huawei P20 Lite. I did the sim swap for her contract at Vodacom and then went off to Cell C to do the data sim swap. What a relief when that was done and the phone delivered to my daughter!
That relief was short-lived as my daughter reported the following day that the phone didn’t recognize the second (Cell C) sim. I was horrified when I called Cell C today (thinking that something had gone awry with the sim swap) to be told that Vodacom have the second sim “port” blocked/disabled! Feeling sure this could not be the case, I then called Vodacom, who confirmed it. Had I known that the Vodacom version of the dual sim phone I had received from Cell C was actually single sim, I would never have signed a contract with Vodacom. I would have gone to Cell C! The branch manager where I entered the contract told me that it was illegal in South Africa to sell dual sim devices - that Icasa prohibited it. Clearly that can’t be true.
The bottom line is that I feel that I had a reasonable expectation that what I was receiving was a dual sim phone. Having just had exactly the same phone (which did accommodate 2 SIM cards) it would never have occurred to me to question whether the device was single or dual sim.
I feel cheated. Can anyone suggest how I can fight this?
 
We acquired a Huawei P20 Lite from Cell C in December. My daughter was really happy with the phone. One sim slot held her Vodacom contract sim and the other her Cell C data sim. Regretfully she had it in her jeans back pocket and it fell in the toilet! She bravely fished it out, but it died over the course of the day - the same day she moved into her university residence in a different city from her home! I bit the bullet and went off to Vodacom to take out another contract for her, again choosing the Huawei P20 Lite. I did the sim swap for her contract at Vodacom and then went off to Cell C to do the data sim swap. What a relief when that was done and the phone delivered to my daughter!
That relief was short-lived as my daughter reported the following day that the phone didn’t recognize the second (Cell C) sim. I was horrified when I called Cell C today (thinking that something had gone awry with the sim swap) to be told that Vodacom have the second sim “port” blocked/disabled! Feeling sure this could not be the case, I then called Vodacom, who confirmed it. Had I known that the Vodacom version of the dual sim phone I had received from Cell C was actually single sim, I would never have signed a contract with Vodacom. I would have gone to Cell C! The branch manager where I entered the contract told me that it was illegal in South Africa to sell dual sim devices - that Icasa prohibited it. Clearly that can’t be true.
The bottom line is that I feel that I had a reasonable expectation that what I was receiving was a dual sim phone. Having just had exactly the same phone (which did accommodate 2 SIM cards) it would never have occurred to me to question whether the device was single or dual sim.
I feel cheated. Can anyone suggest how I can fight this?
I'm sorry as I can understand your frustration. Unfortunately, only knowledge gained has taughte and many other forumites and tech savvy people that Vodacom and MTN do not sell dual s devices, while Telkom and Cell C do.

Your only hope now would be to try and sell the single sim P20 lite and buy a dual sim from Rain.co.za (cheapest I have found) delivered to you door.
 
No way to fight it. There are 2 things to consider here.

Firstly the phone actually belongs to the operator until the contact has completed. Even though you pay a monthly "device fee" this is not like a vehicle HP.

Secondly, the operator can do what they like about the abilities of the phone because of the first point.

A remedy? Willing to pay around R1400? Get something like a Doogee BL5000 (https://www.sunsky-online.com/view/583650/[HK Stock] DOOGEE BL5000 4GB 64GB.htm R1155+R230 delivery)
 
No way to fight it. There are 2 things to consider here.

Firstly the phone actually belongs to the operator until the contact has completed. Even though you pay a monthly "device fee" this is not like a vehicle HP.

Secondly, the operator can do what they like about the abilities of the phone because of the first point.

A remedy? Willing to pay around R1400? Get something like a Doogee BL5000 (https://www.sunsky-online.com/view/583650/[HK Stock] DOOGEE BL5000 4GB 64GB.htm R1155+R230 delivery)
I don't know which models they have, but Ive seen that brand being stocked by cash crusaders. Don't know if their mark up is excessive either.
 
We acquired a Huawei P20 Lite from Cell C in December. My daughter was really happy with the phone. One sim slot held her Vodacom contract sim and the other her Cell C data sim. Regretfully she had it in her jeans back pocket and it fell in the toilet! She bravely fished it out, but it died over the course of the day - the same day she moved into her university residence in a different city from her home! I bit the bullet and went off to Vodacom to take out another contract for her, again choosing the Huawei P20 Lite. I did the sim swap for her contract at Vodacom and then went off to Cell C to do the data sim swap. What a relief when that was done and the phone delivered to my daughter!
That relief was short-lived as my daughter reported the following day that the phone didn’t recognize the second (Cell C) sim. I was horrified when I called Cell C today (thinking that something had gone awry with the sim swap) to be told that Vodacom have the second sim “port” blocked/disabled! Feeling sure this could not be the case, I then called Vodacom, who confirmed it. Had I known that the Vodacom version of the dual sim phone I had received from Cell C was actually single sim, I would never have signed a contract with Vodacom. I would have gone to Cell C! The branch manager where I entered the contract told me that it was illegal in South Africa to sell dual sim devices - that Icasa prohibited it. Clearly that can’t be true.
The bottom line is that I feel that I had a reasonable expectation that what I was receiving was a dual sim phone. Having just had exactly the same phone (which did accommodate 2 SIM cards) it would never have occurred to me to question whether the device was single or dual sim.
I feel cheated. Can anyone suggest how I can fight this?
Why did u not take out another phone from cell c in first place if u dont mind me asking?
 
Get the damaged one repaired at a Pakistani shop, sell it and the single sim Vodacom one and buy a dual sim Huawei from Takealot.
 
Why did u not take out another phone from cell c in first place if u dont mind me asking?
It was quite arbitrary. I went to Vodacom first to do the sim swap on my daughter’s contract because the Vodacom shop was closest. Saw no reason not to get the new contract and device from them. Thought a Hauwei P20 Lite was the same regardless of where it was acquired.
 
How long ago did you get it from Vodacom? You should be able to return to Vodacom within 7 days.

If you can not, some other options are:
Buy a mobile router for the data sim and connect the current phone to it via wifi. Something like this:
https://www.takealot.com/huawei-e5573cs-4g-lte-mini-wifi-mobile-router/PLID51970425

Sell/swop it.
Apparently not. Bought the phone on Monday, queried it on Thursday. The 7 day rule allegedly only applies to manufacturers faults.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X