Football Managers...

smokey

Honorary Master
Joined
Dec 12, 2007
Messages
13,465
Reaction score
1,393
Location
/\_____/\
Which managers are true winners and which aren't. Talent, brians and philosophy are all uselss unless a manager has that certain spark. Call it a will to succeed. My question is... who do you think are the true winners and who are big talents that lack that "something extra"...
 
Talking about managers anyone going to see the movie "The Damned united", its about Brian Clough's time as manager of Leeds United.
 
is this past or present or both :D

Both. Me? Firstly, I'd go for Fergie and Mourinho at the present time. Shankly and Bubsy for history (as far as England is concerned...).

Though to honest, Fergie is my rank best of all time. Screw what he did with United. He won the Scottish League twice with Aberdeen! I mean... FTW!
 
Both. Me? Firstly, I'd go for Fergie and Mourinho at the present time. Shankly and Bubsy for history (as far as England is concerned...).

Though to honest, Fergie is my rank best of all time. Screw what he did with United. He won the Scottish League twice with Aberdeen! I mean... FTW!

for me the 2 managers that stands out the most is Bill Shankly and Rinus Michels the father of modern/total football ;) Now i know Shankly wasnt as succesfull as other managers but the man was ahead of his time in his thinking of the game ,

Eg : in one of the interviews i read , he had been retired for several years and told the interviewer how he would mess with the oposition mentally ,like once Manure was visiting Anfield and he waited for them to arrive and just before they came to the door he handed the doorman a toilet roll and said with a serious face "Give this to them ,they'll need it after we done with them" and he made sure the opposition players heard him saying it to the doorman :D

currently i would say Rafa is proberly the best tactical manager in the game ,and you can see why as he learnt from the games greatest tactician Arrigo Sacchi ,I rate Mourinho as a motivator and for his will to win at any cost :D

Fergie i have alot of respect for ,but i find him to be tactically naive at times ,because he never changes his style to adapt,still a great manager tho

I also rate Lippi,Cappelo very highly and both immense managers

my top 5 would be (in no particular order)

Lippi
Fergie
Bentiz
Cappelo
Mourinho
 
Rinus Michels was the best manager ever as far as tactical awareness and innovations are concerned. His trophy count doesnt have the same zing to it as some other managers, but he is deffo the Godfather of modern footie.

While I agree with your Fergie comments, he is still my greatest, despite his tactical weaknesses, because he chooses amazing and tactically/technically talented Assistants while keeping everything else under his thumb. He is a pure winner and all he needs is the right type of support (like all the best top-tier management, you are only as good as your team - and he has drafted in some amazing people to complement his natural abilities).

Mourinho is different because he is a dictator, but he is tactically more astute, so he doesn't really need someone to complement him in that direction. Though he also has that knack of choing the right people for the job. He could have gotten rid of Clarkie at Chelsea, but instead he chose to keep him and they had a brilliant 2,5 years together (and it shows, what with Clarke leaving and Chelsea practically falling apart).

Also, I really do feel that you do Sir Matt a great injustice, because he created 3 super generations at United in the (50's/60's - forget which era) and made them great champions despite the Munich disaster. Something which completely destroyed one of the greatest football teams ever (Torino) was merely a blip on United road to success.

Also, he was responsible for Manchesters still famed scouting/youth system. He would recruit all the best schoolboy players and bring them through the ranks in the Bubsy way - which was not common during that time.

There are others, but the names elude me currently. More later, quite busy now...
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X