Hamster's Home Network

Hamster

Resident Rodent
Joined
Aug 22, 2006
Messages
45,927
Reaction score
18,425
I'll start off by saying that the hardware used here is not cheap, that I paid for it in Euros, it's probably overkill and that I am not a network expert. However, stuff doesn't buffer in this house.

Setting the scene...
Here in the Netherlands our houses are vertical and very well insulated against to retain heat and kill wifi signals. Also our fiber/internet connections typically sit in a metering cabinet at the front door together with the mains, gas and water connections behind a door. So unlike in RSA where you put a strong wifi router in say your living room which provides adequate network access to your huge but mostly single story houses, your shitty ISP provided router often sits in this cabinet - which sucks because your wifi signal is basically non existent by the time you exit the foyer.

So your options are mesh or some sort of repeater setup which is the average setup here or you use the network cables running to every floor at setup access points. When we moved in I had my TP-Link Archer AX73 with me. To make do I bought another one and an Omada ER605 router which is a small little tin box with no wifi I can can easily hang up in the metering cabinet, connect the two AX73's as access points in the living room (ground floor) and one on the second/top floor office (three story house). For my 1000/1000 line I easily got 900 download on speed tests but the middle floor where the bedrooms are was a dead zone. There I had a smal AC1900 100mbp wire access point just to run our mobile phones on in the evening (because cell signal is pretty **** here).

And then...
So everything is running fine when the wife decides, "Hey, that ‎ bedroom would make a good hobby room/office. Once less flight of stairs to climb!" followed by "The internet is so ****!" at which point it became my problem.

So with an excuse in hand to spend way too much money, I expanded the network with more Omada devices:
  • ER605 - router/gateway used as the DHCP server (had it already)
  • ES205GP switch which will supply POE to the access points
  • 3x EAP655 access points (AX3000)
And we ended up with the below. All the access points are powered via POE and provides a further ethernet ports.

Extra to this is a Technitium DNS server running on a NUC.
 
Last edited:
The Controller...
Each of these devices are running standalone on the network, so you need to log into each independently in case you need to change something or update firmware. The Omada app provides easy enough access to the access points but not the router and switch.

For this you can buy a hardware controller (OC200) which is stupid expensive for what it is, install a software controller on a NUC or a Pi or use the Omada Cloud "Essentials" controller, and in my shortsightedness that is exactly what I went for - the cloud.

Now first, the reason you may want a controller is for a unified view of all the devices and an easy way to manage everything, and if you know what you are doing and want to take advantage of the more advanced Omada feature then this is probably what you'd use. Me, well - and I partly blame the free cloud controller which probably has a limited feature set compared to running your own - quickly realised a made a huge mistake.

A fired up the cloud controller and it all looked great until I wanted to set static IPs/reserve IPs in my DHCP list. For the Omada devices (router, switch and APs) that was easy enough, but I couldn't get it set for any connected client including my NUC with my DNS server on it. The static IP is set on the device, but I still want to be able to reserve it via the DHCP server. So I got frustrated and tried to login to the router directly....

"Access denied, device managed by a controller".​

That's right, you cannot access the router directly anymore, you have to do it via the controller. It also happens that there was a notification message on the controller UI saying there will be maintenance on the 31st where access to the cloud controller will be unavailable. Then it dawned on me.... if my internet connection dies I cannot get into that router to do anything. So I was like "**** that and **** this controller bullsh*t", I went to the devices menu and clicked "Forget this device"
"Confirm you want to forget this device. It will be removed and reset".
Fan-f***ing-tastic.... now everything will be factory reset. Now you may think "well that's not too big a deal" until I tell you I had to (without the help of T-Mobile who are as helpful as wet sand in a wet suit) that you have to setup some vlan IDs to get a connection working with them and for a non network guy like me it was quite a missing to figure out what I had to do before and I've been fearing this day would come again and now because I messed around, here that day is!

So I performed the factory reset under duress, sat without internet for 30 minutes, reconfigured everything and now running it all in standalone mode. Having a software controller is probably still a great solution if you want, but I dont think I need it and if I could leave anybody wanting to set something up similar to this with one piece of advice:

DO NOT USE THE CLOUD CONTROLLER, THAT IS A STUPID IDEA.
 
Stick to ubiquiti unifi lol. Local and cloud access no issue. Same experience both locally and on the cloud
 
The two flights of stairs would have driven me more mad than the poor wifi signal...
 
ER605 - router/gateway used as the DHCP server (had it already)
Hows the router treating you?
I've got an ISP provided TP-Link EX511 thats causing **** and I'm thinking of upgrading to the ER605 for stability
 
Hows the router treating you?
I've got an ISP provided TP-Link EX511 thats causing **** and I'm thinking of upgrading to the ER605 for stability

Haven't really touched them since the post. Everything is working.
 
Friends near Utrecht got a couple of GL.net routers to replace their setup which didn't work -- they took my advice and stuck clean OpenWRT on the routers. Suddenly their ESP8266 based devices started playing nice and good bandwidth for their work from home setups.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X