Head Transplant -Would you?

Ekstasis

Honorary Master
Joined
Dec 21, 2010
Messages
13,206
Reaction score
13
Location
/\/¯¯¯¯\/\™
So I was talking to a collegue of mine yesterday about his daughter (she's paralyzed from the waste down). Then he suddenly asked me about a head transplant and what I thunk about it. So naturally I almost threw up, but that's just me. After composing myself and trying to put this idea into perspective I found myself in a two way street. On the one hand the idea of having someone elses body ( remember not your own feet,hands,penis/vagina etc. etc. ) sounds horrific to say the least. On the other hand...... a new life?

Here's a short section from wiki. Although not much research has been done other than experiments on monkeys, the fundis reckon it's possible.


A head transplant is a surgical operation involving the grafting of an organism's head onto the body of another. It should not be confused with another, hypothetical, surgical operation, the brain transplant. Head transplantation inevitably involves decapitating the patient. Although it has been successfully performed using dogs, monkeys and rats, no human is known to have undergone the procedure.

Since the technology required to reattach a severed spinal cord has not yet been developed, the subject of a head transplant would become quadriplegic unless proper therapies, presumably along the lines of stem cell therapy, were developed. This technique has been proposed as possibly useful for people who are already quadriplegics and who are also suffering from widespread organ failures which would otherwise require many different and difficult transplant surgeries. It may also be useful for people who would rather be quadriplegic than dead. There is no uniform consensus on the ethics of such a procedure
. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Head_transplant

Now the question - If you were paralyzed and couldn't walk or you had some other condition/deficiency and some doctor presented "head transplant" as an option or solution, would you consider it?
 
Last edited:
If you couldn't walk ...

Yebo gogo! ****ing yeah. Within a heartbeat. There shouldn't be any question.

I've got VERY unattractive legs and knees but I'm still very grateful for the job they have done for me. Even though I can't walk up stairs with some suffering.

With some conditioning (getting rid of an over-weight stomach) and building some upper-leg muscle, I might realistically break my PB of 12 seconds (of 10 years ago).
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Frankly, I believe that if medicine had advanced to where such a thing would be possible (reconnecting nerves) then there would be no point to it.
 
No. Stem cell therapy would be a much easier and more successful method of treating the nerve damage. If that doesn't work, I'll accept my condition.
 
Frankly, I believe that if medicine had advanced to where such a thing would be possible (reconnecting nerves) then there would be no point to it.

Exactly. They would fix the broken, not transplant a head.
 
Since the technology required to reattach a severed spinal cord has not yet been developed
Huh? I call BS on that. If it can be done on a dog then it can be done on a human. On a cellular level the tech is exactly the same.

In fact I think the entire section was written by a joker:
Head transplantation inevitably involves decapitating the patient.

If you were paralyzed and couldn't walk or you had some other condition/deficiency and some doctor presented "head transplant" as an option or solution, would you consider it?
tbh I don't attach _that_ huge an importance to being able to walk. Not enough to go for a super risky procedure like that anyway. If the condition being fixed is an early death then I might go for it though.
 
Now the question - If you were paralyzed and couldn't walk or you had some other condition/deficiency and some doctor presented "head transplant" as an option or solution, would you consider it?

Not at all, and not because I feel someone else's body would be repulsive to me, but rather because if I did so, I would be condoning and contributing to the unnecessary and barbaric practice of animal experimentation.
 
Not at all, and not because I feel someone else's body would be repulsive to me, but rather because if I did so, I would be condoning and contributing to the unnecessary and barbaric practice of animal experimentation.
You've already contributed in one way or another ;)
 
Huh? I call BS on that. If it can be done on a dog then it can be done on a human. On a cellular level the tech is exactly the same.

Unless I misunderstood, spinal cords were never reattached in those experiments. Arteries, veins, etc sure but not spinal cords or nerves.
 
Unless I misunderstood, spinal cords were never reattached in those experiments. Arteries, veins, etc sure but not spinal cords or nerves.
"Successfully performed" to me means spinal cords. :confused: The page is kinda vague though so I doubt we'll ever know.
 
If I had a compelling reason, sure. Would be pretty cool actually. :p

I'd like a dolphin body though, or perhaps a stoat's.
 
"Successfully performed" to me means spinal cords. :confused: The page is kinda vague though so I doubt we'll ever know.

From my understanding, "successfully performed" just means that it was alive (for a few days) when they were done but there's no word about it being mobile beneath the neck unless nerves and other tissue were left intact:
The first dog heads to enjoy, if that word can be used, full cerebral function were those [of] transplantation whiz Vladimir Demikhov, in the Soviet Union in the 1950s. Demikhov minimized the time that the severed donor head was without oxygen by using "blood-vessel sewing machines." He transplanted twenty puppy heads—actually, head-shoulders-lungs—and forelimbs units with an esophagus that emptied, untidily, onto the outside of the dog—onto fully grown dogs

The word, "barbaric" comes to mind.
 
The Josef Mengeles of medical science

[video=youtube;SodaOTZWPPg]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SodaOTZWPPg[/video]

[video=youtube;MKITm6OGeTo]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MKITm6OGeTo&NR=1[/video]

[video=youtube;UiG8v5ui1AY]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiG8v5ui1AY&NR=1[/video]

[video=youtube;OWcoAtDr9tI]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OWcoAtDr9tI&NR=1[/video]
 
Last edited:
I don't see any problem with it. What's the difference between a heart or a whole body. But as has been mentioned if they can transplant it the they should be able to fix it.
 
Wouldn't ppl like Okkie die TikTokkie welcome such an option? Sorry Okkie! That's to say if it was safe (no complications - in a perfect world that is). I think those who say they're stuck in the body of the opposite sex might go for something like this, rather than normal sex change operation.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X