ICT skiils, a shortage or a myth

dataforc

New Member
Joined
Nov 19, 2013
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Location
South Africa and USA
South Africa need ICT skills, that is not a debate. In the past, a distinction was made between the shortage of black ICT skills and shortage in general, in the 2010.s this distinction has evaporated.
if an organisation can take a survey in the private sector of black CIO's or IT Managers, of who hold these positions that come with huge ICT budgets, the result will speak for themselves. The industry is dominated by white CIO's, but does this mean that there are no competent blacks to hold these positions ? well, during the affirmative action years in South Arica, there was a big rush in search of black talent, that rush disappeared with the introduction of the black economic empowerment Act where many employers were not pressurised to employ black talent as they could make up by partnering with a black owned ICT company for the delivery of services.
Often I come across many ICT skilled black professionals with over 15 years experience in public or private sector who are available to take up positions but claim to be discriminated by the employers as they now favour white ICT employees for the chief Information Officer positions. The public sector is not far this trend and behaviour. The value derived from these skilled professional must not be led down the drain. SouthAfrica need the talent, the skills to move the country forward especially in various government owned enterprises. It is so common these days to find a non- ICT skilled person leading the technology department of an organisation.
Now, the definition of black ICT skilled resources is further populated by the distinction between black african and black Indian resources. Yes, there will be black Indian resources in these commanding positions, but not that of black africans. Therefore from the employer point of view, the black equity numbers have been satisfactorily satisfied,while the streets are full of black africans who have digressed into non ICT to make end meet and not by choice, who will be happy to re-enter the growing and ever growing industry.
The growth in the mobile sector commands even more participation by young future Bill Gates of South Africa. I would like to see an industry as vibrant as that of Kenya, Silicon Valley with full black participation. The development of mobile APPS is complex and differ by far from the traditional programming languages that are still being taught in various universities around South Africa. The industry C level executives will have to foot the cost of training new entrants if academia does not fully prepare graduates based on new emerging technologies and technology trends.

by
jabu madlala
C-level Advisory Services
 
Often I come across many ICT skilled black professionals with over 15 years experience in public or private sector who are available to take up positions but claim to be discriminated by the employers as they now favour white ICT employees for the chief Information Officer positions. The public sector is not far this trend and behaviour. The value derived from these skilled professional must not be led down the drain. SouthAfrica need the talent, the skills to move the country forward especially in various government owned enterprises. It is so common these days to find a non- ICT skilled person leading the technology department of an organisation.
Now, the definition of black ICT skilled resources is further populated by the distinction between black african and black Indian resources. Yes, there will be black Indian resources in these commanding positions, but not that of black africans. Therefore from the employer point of view, the black equity numbers have been satisfactorily satisfied,while the streets are full of black africans who have digressed into non ICT to make end meet and not by choice, who will be happy to re-enter the growing and ever growing industry.

The idea that businesses would discriminate against talented people based purely on their race is ridiculous and makes no business sense whatsoever. Businesses are in the business of making money. If you are talented enough to make a business money, they will go out of their way to hire you whether you are black or white or pink or purple. If you do not get hired, then sorry for you, you're just not good enough.

The true racism comes from morons like you who seem to assume that black people need some sort of special help or consideration in order to get ahead in life. Most educated black people I know are deeply insulted by the idea of employment equity and affirmative action.

You really are out of touch with the technology industry in South African if you think "the streets are full of black africans who have digressed into non ICT to make end meet and not by choice", as if there are all these talented people just sitting at home with no job just because they're black. I've never heard such utter nonsense and drivel in my life.
 
You really are out of touch with the technology industry in South African if you think "the streets are full of black africans who have digressed into non ICT to make end meet and not by choice", as if there are all these talented people just sitting at home with no job just because they're black. I've never heard such utter nonsense and drivel in my life.

Have to agree with you. The only reason anyone in software development or similar is sitting at home without work, is because their skills aren't up to scratch. My company is constantly on the lookout for developers and it's a mission to get people with decent skills.

Also, the fact that you have 15 years of experience doesn't mean you're entitled to become a CIO or CTO. It means you have 15 years of experience under the belt, not that you're any good at your job.
 
Also, the fact that you have 15 years of experience doesn't mean you're entitled to become a CIO or CTO. It means you have 15 years of experience under the belt, not that you're any good at your job.

I agree. I'd also like to point out that many CTOs and CIOs come from an auditing, accounting or legal background. Just being a developer for 15 years does not mean you are now qualified to become your company's next CTO!
 
I agree. I'd also like to point out that many CTOs and CIOs come from an auditing, accounting or legal background. Just being a developer for 15 years does not mean you are now qualified to become your company's next CTO!

I'd actually venture to say that 15 years as a developer would make you a terrible CTO as odds are you have had little experience with accounts, managing large groups of people, managing budgets, conforming to company goals with regards to projects, etc.
At the very least, you would need several years of non-developer experience somewhere in the mix.
 
I'd actually venture to say that 15 years as a developer would make you a terrible CTO as odds are you have had little experience with accounts, managing large groups of people, managing budgets, conforming to company goals with regards to projects, etc.
At the very least, you would need several years of non-developer experience somewhere in the mix.

I've actually seen this happen way too often. It often happens in a smallish company when the senior developer has been there for ages, and the CTO position has all of a sudden become vacant. Someone on the board of directors comes up with the bright idea of promoting the lead or senior developer to the CTO position. It usually ends on tears when it becomes clear that being an awesome developer does not make a good CTO.
 
No matter what your ethnic group, expertise, education and problem solving ability in the ICT sector, you always get the lazy bunch, my pet peeve and laziness always escalates into bigger problems like missing deadlines, lies, general lack in productivity and mismanagement (and abuse), furthermore MALadministration (empathised). There is many more variant calculations to scenarios like these.

I know the above might be OFF-TOPIC, but I agree with evilstebunny.

Again, this article relates to top-management positions (CTO’s), learn that there is also mid-level. I’m not going to rant here, since I deal with these players and respect the industry.

Then I also support and agree with deweyzeph and Messugga.

@ dataforc, you should really reavaluate your advisory services, do note that I worked with some excellent black top-level administrators.
 
@OP, you do make some valid points. However, I would not say that this applies to all black people. I am a Black developer and I will admit I have faced racial discrimination on numerous occasions. Some people may dismiss that as ridiculous but it happens. To make the assumption that 15 years experience is sufficient to be a CTO is erroneous. Merit and skills should be the criteria. I do not dismiss the fact that it can happen that a Black person is not afforded the same opportunities as other races as I have seen this happen many times. In my view, most Black people are not ambitious enough to take opportunities and make the most of them.
 
thank you for the open responses. it was a discussion and not meant to ANGRY and RRTATE anyone or defend any TERRTORY like some of the no name or anonymous respondents have shown N THER RESPONSES. thank you
 
thank you for the open responses. it was a discussion and not meant to ANGRY and RRTATE anyone or defend any TERRTORY like some of the no name or anonymous respondents have shown N THER RESPONSES. thank you


This makes no sense.... Whats up with the caps and the ""?
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X