Iphone review .. not looking good

The Guy

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2006
Messages
887
Reaction score
0
Location
Cape Town
Is the iPhone Enterprise Material?

By James Alan Miller
April 24, 2007

Several sites are reporting that AT&T (formally Cingular) intends to target the iPhone, about as consumer-friendly a mobile handsets as there's been, to the enterprise and market as well.

An anonymous source told InfoWorld that AT&T is even in the process of getting backend enterprise billing and support systems ready for such an eventuality, for example.

Analysts recommend businesses not take the bait.

That is, if they would consider rolling out a device like the iPhone in the first place, which many won’t. As Gartner analyst Ken Dulaney put it to InfoWorld: "We'd be against it. We'd immediately tell our customers that'd be a very serious mistake."

Here's a list of caveats against the iPhone for enterprises to consider:

The lack of a removable battery; the all-touch screen device lacks a hard keypad (or keyboard), which could make dialing while driving (or not looking at the iPhone directly under any circumstances) difficult, if not impossible; a lack of support for business e-mail and messaging (Microsoft Exchange, RIM BlackBerry, etc.); and the fact that it is Apple's first go at a mobile handset. Businesses, which good reason, tend to go with the tried and true first.

And then there's the inability for third-parties, including enterprises, to write applications for the iPhone, which runs on a scaled-down version of Mac OS X. By contrast, Windows Mobile, Symbian, and BlackBerry, the three most popular smartphone operating systems in the U.S., all allow developers to develop software to run on devices built on them.

"Companies like to extend corporate apps to the mobile space, and in order to do that, you need an open OS," Current Analysis principal analyst Avi Greengart explained to InfoWorld.

Apple's iPod/phone/Internet device is scheduled to be released in June. A 4 GB edition of the iPhone is slated to cost $499 with a 2-year contract, while an 8 GB model will sell for $100 more.
 
It does support MS Exchange.

And that is hardly a review. It is an opinion that it might not be suited to the Enterprise. Which is based on speculation that it might target the enterprise
 
We all know who's going to buy it and its not corporate mom or dad but their children. There's a huge market outside of the corporate one and despite the devices numerous shortcomings they're going to sell.
 
We all know who's going to buy it and its not corporate mom or dad but their children. There's a huge market outside of the corporate one and despite the devices numerous shortcomings they're going to sell.

Damn expensive then aint it ... :cool:
 
Damn expensive then aint it ... :cool:
Hype alone will be enough to give the product an incredible boost.

iirc they're hoping to sell 10 million in the first year - out of the billion phones sold annually and considering all the hype that's probably a realistic expectation.

I'm interested in the reviews that come out once the phone is actually available. Right now these authors are just trying to cash in - I wonder how many ads are on the page the story came from. Have you got a link for us?
 
I'm happy carrying my N95 around with my iPod Video when I need it.:rolleyes:
While I wouldn't say no to a wide screen ipod (my ipod Photo is getting a bit long in the tooth) the iPhone holds little appeal to me. I like my blackberry and I'd sooner upgrade that.
 
Hype alone will be enough to give the product an incredible boost.

iirc they're hoping to sell 10 million in the first year - out of the billion phones sold annually and considering all the hype that's probably a realistic expectation.

I'm interested in the reviews that come out once the phone is actually available. Right now these authors are just trying to cash in - I wonder how many ads are on the page the story came from. Have you got a link for us?

here is the source ... http://www.infoworld.com/article/07/04/23/HNattenterpriseiphone_1.html
 
The lack of a removable battery
Not clever, I admit, but isn't the iPod the same?


the all-touch screen device lacks a hard keypad (or keyboard), which could make dialing while driving (or not looking at the iPhone directly under any circumstances) difficult, if not impossible;

Should we be dialing whilst driving anyway. What about bluetooth and voice dialing?

And then there's the inability for third-parties, including enterprises, to write applications for the iPhone, which runs on a scaled-down version of Mac OS X.
Why can't 3rd parties develop for OSX?? I'm sure they will make provision for this soon enough.
==
These criticisms are not very credible.
 
Not clever, I admit, but isn't the iPod the same?




Should we be dialing whilst driving anyway. What about bluetooth and voice dialing?


Why can't 3rd parties develop for OSX?? I'm sure they will make provision for this soon enough.
==
These criticisms are not very credible.

With the first trojan to infect a Apple Mac OS X computer last year only i think it could be why they are selfish on 3rd party development ...
RIM has the same approach which in part is why their platform is so stable.
I personally don't see the Apple boys opening up to 3rd party developers anytime soon ... for one they themselves need to finish the operating system platform ... with their current selfish source code trends they will most probably develop a protocol stack for 3rd party developers instead of releasing source ...
But hey lets wait and see
 
@The Guy - I'm guessing you're referring to OSX.Leap.A? Did anyone ever manage to get infected with it? I didnt have an intel mac at the time so I didnt pay much attention to it.

Have they restricted 3rd party development to OsX since then?
 
@The Guy - I'm guessing you're referring to OSX.Leap.A? Did anyone ever manage to get infected with it? I didnt have an intel mac at the time so I didnt pay much attention to it.

Have they restricted 3rd party development to OsX since then?

That be the one ... i am not quite sure if anyone had that bugger spoil their day.
the articles all say antivirus researchers apparently discovered a trojan ... all i can say is it is a damn impressive record for the Apple boys being pretty much bullet proof for such a long time .
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X