SauRoNZA
Honorary Master
There's zero chance they got into the phone. Unless they guessed the PIN number within 3 tries or so as after that it starts setting a timer on the lock screen and you have to wait before you can try again. Each wrong try increases the time.
As for password managers. I disagree with @SauRoNZA - I use 1Password and it works Bette than Apple's implementation. I use apps on the Mac that need a password and Apple's system, won't pic that up unless the developer as catered for it (A lot of times they don't). Also I keep other things in there like CC info which makes it hand to access when I need it.
To be fair I was putting myself in the shoes of Joe Average where the lesser complex way in which iCloud Keychain just works is better for most users.
That being said due to company policy I’ve been locked out of iCloud Keychain on my work Mac and so I’ve been using a self-hosted Bitwarden instance for most of my needs which works equally well but is a little bit more cumbersome for being third party.
But I do agree the real magic of iCloud Keychain is when it’s fully integrated. In my case it’s very rare that it’s not so it all comes down to which apps you use.
On one hand if someone is using an iPhone only from the Apple ecosystem I want to say all the more reason to use just the Keychain. At the same time because their other devices wouldn’t be compatible with it you need a third party tool to sync across devices.
Even so as a Bitwarden user privately and a LastPass user for Enterprise I think iCloud Keychain is the better product for Joe Average. Especially the older generation...
Between an iPhone and iPad only workflow it’s fantastic, but yes I can agree when the Mac comes into the mix you may want a little bit more from it.