Mac & Windows sharing a centralised/router-HDD

Cassady

Expert Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2011
Messages
1,968
Reaction score
65
Location
Die Kaap
Hello all,

I realise this could be placed in the general hardware section - but figured that with the Mac slant, I'd pop it up here. Mods - please move it if necessary!

I spent a fair whack of the morning reading up about external storage, having searched through MyBB ["external HDD"; "External Storage"; "External Backup" - if I missed an obvious search term - please share!] - and have a fair idea of what's cooking... But would appreciate any thoughts/comments.

The wife is due to replace her ageing laptop soon. It will probably be a Window OS machine.
I have a MBP.
Along with 2 iPhones and 3 iPads.

With the recent purchase of an Asus Rt-n55u router - I can now attach a External HDD to the router.
I have a few questions about this though, that I figured I would clarify, prior to purchasing the HDD:

1.) Can we "both" share that HDD? Would each of us simply "upload" whatever we want, over wifi, off our laptops and onto the HDD plugged into the Router? Since the HDD would not plug directly into either of our laptops, its formatting would presumably not be an issue (i.e. mine needing Mac compatible, hers being Windows)... Is that correct?

2.) Assuming the above to be correct - and I'm not sure it is at all - what about iTunes? If I send my 80gb's of music over to the Router HDD - and point my Itunes in that direction - will all work as it should? And when my wife does the same with her iTunes library? Can 2 co-exist on one HDD?

3.) All the above means we are effectively taking files off 2 computers, and putting all of those eggs into 1 basket - the router HDD... Which already has me nervous. So - what would be the best way to keep everything safe? Purchase a 2nd HDD, and back-up the shared router HDD? And then - how is this done? I have plenty of media stuff that I hardly ever access during the day - music/photos/movies - so it kind of makes sense to get it off my Mac, and onto a centralised HDD... But this would not amount to a "backup", since the data would only be found on the router HDD - so what do you all do to cover yourselves here?

Would love to hear how you all do it! :cool:
 
Further to the above - I would obviously need to convert the format of HDD to FAT32...
 
1. Yes. The Hard Drive will be seen as an Windows Share (Samba) and can be mounted over the network. (OSX -> Finder -> Go -> connect to server)
2. For iTunes on the Mac you will need to copy your library to that location, and change the path to your Music Library under iTunes Settings to the path of the hard drive.. it will be e.g. //192.168.0.1/Share or something

3. You cannot RAID this setup, so you will have to manually copy the files from one HDD to your backup HDD using a computer.
 
1. Yes. The Hard Drive will be seen as an Windows Share (Samba) and can be mounted over the network. (OSX -> Finder -> Go -> connect to server)
2. For iTunes on the Mac you will need to copy your library to that location, and change the path to your Music Library under iTunes Settings to the path of the hard drive.. it will be e.g. //192.168.0.1/Share or something

3. You cannot RAID this setup, so you will have to manually copy the files from one HDD to your backup HDD using a computer.

Thanks Stricken!

Re 2.) - I presume that means that TWO individual libraries can be stored on the HDD, since they would simply be stored in separate folders?
 
3. You cannot RAID this setup, so you will have to manually copy the files from one HDD to your backup HDD using a computer.

Also keep copies of important documents & email store backed up on both machines so between the two machines and 2 HDDs you will have 4 copies.
 
Thanks Ponder...

Must be honest - the more I dig, the more difficult the decision becomes... Just came across several websites extolling the virtues of converting that old PC of mine, into a little NAS setup.... Super tempting... But the plug-n-play appeal of an external into the back of my router, has much going in its favour as well...
 
Thanks Ponder...

Must be honest - the more I dig, the more difficult the decision becomes... Just came across several websites extolling the virtues of converting that old PC of mine, into a little NAS setup.... Super tempting... But the plug-n-play appeal of an external into the back of my router, has much going in its favour as well...

http://www.freenas.org/
 

Thanks - saw that. There are quite a few good ones around, and LifeHacker is pretty useful as well.
Having said this - a fair amount of comments in many of those threads, about how there's not much point in converting an old PC to fo the NAS job.

About how older PC's are noisy, heavy on electricity etc.. Much better etc. to take the plunge and settle on a proper NAS setup... I kind of agree with the latter - which makes the External plug-in even more appealing...

Think I will just take the plunge, and see what comes of it. Worse case scenario - I plug it out, reformat it, and use it as a secondary for my MBP.
 
Hello all. With one of the old externals starting to make some scary ticking noises over the weekend, had to pull the trigger on a new backup option, and quickly too.

Picked up a 1TB Seagate external, that I've plugged into the router. Working well from my MBP, wife's ancient HP saw it initially, but has lost it again - so will play around tomorrow again...

Silly question. Is it wise/possible/ok etc. to leave the External plugged in to the router 24/7? I mean - it would obviously put hours onto it much more quickly - but presumably, this is done quite often nowadays?

Super convenient to have it linked/on non-stop - but no biggie to keep it switched off until needed...

Thoughts?
 
Het Cassidy, I got the same router and sharing a HDD to mainly stream video to MBP, Win7 PC, iPad, iPhone and PS#. Works like a bomb.

Still need to move my iTunes library.
 
Het Cassidy, I got the same router and sharing a HDD to mainly stream video to MBP, Win7 PC, iPad, iPhone and PS#. Works like a bomb.

Still need to move my iTunes library.

Thanks Matewis!

Did a bit of fiddling with setting up VPN's etc. that could be accessed from the web through an Asus interface, but in the end cancelled all of it... Just have it set-up as an external now. Haven't moved my iTunes over - but have started doing it with some of my bigger iMovies projects, and works a treat...

Wife's laptop still picks it up sporadically - but to be honest, her machine is now close on 10 years old, so I guess I just don't understand it any more! ;P

Will sort hers out properly when we upgrade to a newer machine...

Oh - and in answering myself - have left the HDD on and plugged in now since the end of September. And it will probably stay like that. Will start worrying about making a backup of my external backup in a year or two's time! :)
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X