Mobile broadband subscribers surpass fixed broadband

That is a stupid survey, It is obvious with android phones that uses data.
 
Bad basis for analysis

That is a stupid survey, It is obvious with android phones that uses data.

I agree the survey is flawed for the reason that it does not include:
How many people use each connection - is it per line or per person?
If they have both types
What does wifi access count as?
Which is the primary connection?
What do they have access to, as in is it a choice or just what is available?
What is deemed as broadband use (does EDGE Blackberry or GPRS actually count)?
 
I tend not to shoot down this survey. The first question to ask is: "Do they base their findings on amount of users or amount of data?" If it is data, then fixed line should win. If based on users, all smart phone users are potential users as well!
 
I tend not to shoot down this survey. The first question to ask is: "Do they base their findings on amount of users or amount of data?" If it is data, then fixed line should win. If based on users, all smart phone users are potential users as well!

Maybe there's a hint in the title of the article?

"Mobile broadband subscribers overtake fixed broadband"

Or the 13 other times the word "subscriber" is used on the page?
 
Fixed line broadband is dying a dinosaur like death.

This is a terrible article. Not because it informs us about the current trend (that is good) but because it is stating what has become painfully obvious – particularly to the South African consumer.

With the high cost of setting up wired connections it makes no sense to think that wired broadband would still be growing in this day in age.

What the article fails to do (as has been pointed by some opinion contributors in this discussion) is to provide information of real substance. What type of broadband is it and how and who is using it?

These questions if they had been answered in this article would have highlighted some of the self-defeating strategies that our local network operators are employing. For instance, I was told that you will not get broadband speeds on your smartphone even though it is capable of speeds in excess of say 10mbps like my phone. I had to go for a USB dongle because my high speed phone simply is not allowed to get that speed. Correct me if I am wrong. Or tell me what I need to do to get proper speeds on my smartphone. Having a high speed phone and using it as a modem did not get me the high speeds that our local operators have been shouting about (the phone works on all spectrum in SA at high speeds - well at least it is supposed to).

I went out and bought myself a high speed dongle and - 'low and behold' – there is actually high speed in SA.

So, what this article could have done is to delve deeper into the issue of broadband connections and highlighted exactly how mobile broadband is being used by the 558million connections i.e. smartphone or dongle (USB), etcetera.

There is no arguing that fixed line broadband is dying a rapid death especially in SA (I laugh at Telkom derisively).

What matters is how operators are (or not) facilitating the proliferation mobile broadband. In my opinion, these figures should have been much greater if the operators were not stifling its growth with the aim of making quick bucks. I can go on - e.g. R2.00/mb on oob, long-term contracts (12 and 24 mths for data) and no data only options (i.e. when you have your own modem) for longer term data bundles (why are there not three month, six month and nine month data bundles?) and 30 day expiries on data bundles. Cell C is an exception – we all now well and truly know that.

While I commend your article on re-iterating on a trend that every person on the street can see, try to give us more substance please in such similar reports - reports that will create constructive and progressive debate.
 
Last edited:
It's not like we have a choice. This survey also makes the case for cheaper mobile broadband, I mean at the moment we're only limited by the exorbitant R289/Gig.
 
Fixed line is far from dead

The stats says really very little. We have ADSL at home with 4 users on it. All four has smartphones. So subscriber wise we are four mobile broadband subscribers, but only one ADSL subscriber....

Besides who really wants the instability and high prices of mobile broadband. :D
 
I was told that you will not get broadband speeds on your smartphone even though it is capable of speeds in excess of say 10mbps like my phone. I had to go for a USB dongle because my high speed phone simply is not allowed to get that speed. Correct me if I am wrong. Or tell me what I need to do to get proper speeds on my smartphone.
That is to do with your smartphone itself, not the network. To test the difference use your smartphone as a modem only so it does not have to do much on the application layer. Big difference. I had the same thought with my 3.5G phone, but realised the browser etc running on a little processor was the issue and running it as a modem for my notebook gave me full network speed.


There is no arguing that fixed line broadband is dying a rapid death especially in SA (I laugh at Telkom derisively)..
I really doubt that, Telkom dying doesn't mean fixed line is dying, it just means new competitors will have to come in to the market. Unfortunately the issue is fixed line take TIME to deploy which sucks for us. Watch, Vodacom etc. will be offering fixed line services once they have fibre to all their towers, the towers then becoming switching stations from which FTTH can be deployed. They are getting their networks ready and milking the profits in the meantime.

The government plans such as in the City of Cape Town are actually going to increase fixed line rather than reduce it. What we will see is a lot more wireless access due to the increased number of high speed fixed line deployment. Imagine picocells on each lamp post in the city:) Fixed line facilitates wireless.

Maybe we should draw a distinction between wifi type distance wireless and longer range to make the dialogue easier. Wifi should fall under fixed line for this discussion.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X