[Opinion]: Is darkness really such a disaster?

Vox Populi Vox Dei

High Tory
Joined
Mar 6, 2004
Messages
53,917
Reaction score
38,769
Location
Cape Town
It was only a matter of time once Iqbal Surve took over that there would be an article sneering about the middle-classes and how electricity black outs just aren't that bad.

A very badly thought out article. What about people who have medical devices? Not to mention that security is compromised without electricity and some people work on weekends from home. Why the author only focuses on the "middle-class teen" is baffling.

Can it be right that the life of a middle-class teen becomes a disaster without electricity? asks Murray Williams.

Cape Town - In the darkness of the latest rounds of power failures, it’s easy to identify the national mood: powerlessness. Powerless to fix – as a nation, until new power sources are constructed. Powerless to blame – because who really knows whose “fault” this disaster is?

Powerless even in our outrage – because it will achieve zero, no matter who we are. We understand our nation needs this, right now, like a hole in the head. That it comes at the worst possible time – when the need to grow our economy, the need to create jobs, is most acute, as desperation mounts, as hope fades.

And so we wait. Powerless.

But there’s a great irony here for the middle class: This crisis is equally, actually, a time to reclaim great power.

Electrical power is indeed the lifeblood of much of our economy. But so too has it become the solitary enabler for many people’s private lives.

The owner of a small business which relies upon refrigeration can be empathised with, in his bleakness.

But the suburban family at the weekend, feeling power failures as crises? Not so sure.

Can it be right that the life of a middle-class teen becomes a disaster without electricity? Without power for his smartphone, tablet, laptop, Xbox, PlayStation 4, 3D Blu-Ray player and 51-inch Smart TV?

That without these firmly clutched in fist and mind, the world suddenly seems empty of meaning?

And increasing droves of adults too. Who have little to say or do around the dinner table without updating their Facebook status or scanning Twitter for titbits. As if the delicious titbits on their plates – which so many are denied – were no longer sufficient.

The profound irony, of course, is that as holidays near, many still romanticise the notion of being “technology-free” – that caricatured lazy afternoon in the hammock, snoozing, book in hand.

The candle-lit dinner, dancing shadows on delighted faces. Stories around the campfire.

Well, now’s that chance. To turn powerlessness into power. Into gratitude.Not just during load shedding, but every day.

As Henry David Thoreau wrote in Walden: “I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately, to front only the essential facts of life, and see if I could not learn what it had to teach, and not, when I came to die, discover that I had not lived.

“I did not wish to live what was not life, living is so dear; nor did I wish to practise resignation, unless it was quite necessary. I wanted to live deep and suck out all the marrow of life, to live so sturdily and Spartan-like as to put to rout all that was not life…”

What flickers on the face of “that hopeless little screen”, in the words of Leonard Cohen, is certainly “not life”.

Power to the people.

With thanks to you, Eskom.

http://www.iol.co.za/capeargus/is-darkness-really-such-a-disaster-1.1795037#.VIvfU9LQppU
 
Was thinking the same thing when the lights went out last week. It was ok to be without power for 3 hours. In that 3 hours I could have silence, had a chance to talk with my family without background noise. The neighbourhood was suddenly transformed into a remote rural village I grew up in. That brought back some happy memories of a peaceful upbringing. It was like we had travelled back in time. In a way I wasn't concerned about when the power would be back as I was caught up in a reminiscent moment. So thanks Eskom, we should do this more often
 
Was thinking the same thing when the lights went out last week. It was ok to be without power for 3 hours. In that 3 hours I could have silence, had a chance to talk with my family without background noise. The neighbourhood was suddenly transformed into a remote rural village I grew up in. That brought back some happy memories of a peaceful upbringing. It was like we had travelled back in time. In a way I wasn't concerned about when the power would be back as I was caught up in a reminiscent moment. So thanks Eskom, we should do this more often
Tell that to businesses reliant on power for survival.
Tell that to the mother who had to take her baby to the emergency room because she was unable to run her nebulizer when the kid had an asthma attack
Tell that to the family of the old man who nearly died when his oxygen machine stopped working.

If you want to get nostalgic, turn your own power off. Don't wish it upon everyone else too.
 
Was thinking the same thing when the lights went out last week. It was ok to be without power for 3 hours. In that 3 hours I could have silence, had a chance to talk with my family without background noise. The neighbourhood was suddenly transformed into a remote rural village I grew up in. That brought back some happy memories of a peaceful upbringing. It was like we had travelled back in time. In a way I wasn't concerned about when the power would be back as I was caught up in a reminiscent moment. So thanks Eskom, we should do this more often

If you are relying for Eskom to give you quite time you need to reevaluate your priorities :rolleyes:

Some small business owners work from home and dont have normal working hours either. And btw, in some instances its not just 3 to 4 hours. I had 9 the other day. So if you want quiet time, disconnect yourself from the grid and give power to the rest of us that needs it. You wont mind the sacrifice.

/sarc
 
Go fsck yourself iqbal... I'm guessing your little private residence has backup generators etcetera... We aren't actually worried about the 2 or 3 hours without power, they're merely an inconvenience. We're worried about what the future holds in terms of eskom being able to provide us power in the long term. Without power this country will collapse in very very short order and even your little secure compound will be overrun.
 
Go fsck yourself iqbal... I'm guessing your little private residence has backup generators etcetera... .

Just like Nkandla has a 275kw generator paid for by the taxpayers.
I wonder if anyone thought to order fuel for it.
 
If you are relying for Eskom to give you quite time you need to reevaluate your priorities :rolleyes:

Some small business owners work from home and dont have normal working hours either. And btw, in some instances its not just 3 to 4 hours. I had 9 the other day. So if you want quiet time, disconnect yourself from the grid and give power to the rest of us that needs it. You wont mind the sacrifice.

/sarc

Shouldn't a small business (profit making entity ) factor backup power into their operating cost equations? Load shedding isn't the only threat to power supply. There are unplanned power failures as well. Just like big business small business must invest in business continuity. If they don't then they accept the risk of being down at some point.
 
Just like Nkandla has a 275kw generator paid for by the taxpayers.
I wonder if anyone thought to order fuel for it.

Trust me.. its not a 275kw generator. R275k in cost yes... not 275kw though.

But I doubt anyone has planned for the maintenance aspect that such a generator will require.
 
Shouldn't a small business (profit making entity ) factor backup power into their operating cost equations? Load shedding isn't the only threat to power supply. There are unplanned power failures as well. Just like big business small business must invest in business continuity. If they don't then they accept the risk of being down at some point.

Small businesses can't afford to contemplate any real kind of BC until they get to a certain point... the same goes for backup power.... these are not cheap things, and if they HAVE to be factored in when starting up a small business 90% of people just won't even bother, it will make most small businesses cost prohibitive.
 
Shouldn't a small business (profit making entity ) factor backup power into their operating cost equations? Load shedding isn't the only threat to power supply. There are unplanned power failures as well. Just like big business small business must invest in business continuity. If they don't then they accept the risk of being down at some point.

What ToxicBunny said. I suggest you start your own business and go through the motions. You are right about the backup power, but that type of stuff only comes when a business is much more established and/or have a very good profit margin. If it becomes a crises when you are still small you would sacrifice something of your business so that you can have power. In a friends case its was not employing another person even though they really needed that position filled. You know, more people = more work that can be done = more money coming in. Alas now growth and money coming in is affected. And just remember its a continuous cost, because if its say a generator you have to buy fuel for it. If power would fail once in a blue moon it could be managed, but we are talking about continuous days of power failures and for longer than 4 to 5 hours of downtime per day in future.
 
Relax. The article isn't trying to tell you that it's okay not to have power, but is rather commenting on how reliant we have become on it in areas where perhaps we shouldn't. It's no different to a hundred other pictures circulating social networks showing a group of people sitting around a table in a restaurant, all staring down at their phones.
 
Shouldn't a small business (profit making entity ) factor backup power into their operating cost equations? Load shedding isn't the only threat to power supply. There are unplanned power failures as well. Just like big business small business must invest in business continuity. If they don't then they accept the risk of being down at some point.

Definitely here, just a pity that such extra cots for the business means less people get employed and the country's economy tanks. Actually that's no problem we can give the unemployed just grants. It is easy to print money.
 
It was only a matter of time once Iqbal Surve took over that there would be an article sneering about the middle-classes and how electricity black outs just aren't that bad.

A very badly thought out article. What about people who have medical devices? Not to mention that security is compromised without electricity and some people work on weekends from home. Why the author only focuses on the "middle-class teen" is baffling.



http://www.iol.co.za/capeargus/is-darkness-really-such-a-disaster-1.1795037#.VIvfU9LQppU

I'd say it's a disaster. Reliable and regular electricity supply has been the cornerstone of civilisation in the urbanised West for what- a 100 years? It's not as if people in the 50's had Playstations and 51 inch TVs or Facebook.

One needs light, one benefits from refrigeration of food. Those two are important if not vital. In addition one needs ones' alarm system to function, because of modern crime. And electricity is also needed to pump water. There have been pump failures around Cape Town brought on by these blackouts. So running water is now also an unnecessary bourgeois luxury?

But the suburban family at the weekend, feeling power failures as crises? Not so sure.

These people do not have fridges. Everyone eats crackers I guess. And as long as power cuts are very short maybe it's not such a big deal but then why is it a big deal for a small business which relies on refrigeration? Close your fridges and the temp should not go up more than 2-3 degrees in that 2-3 hr gap. And if you need to keep food or medicine colder, you need emergency backup or run them colder so that 2-3 deg won't spoil your product.
 
Relax. The article isn't trying to tell you that it's okay not to have power, but is rather commenting on how reliant we have become on it in areas where perhaps we shouldn't. It's no different to a hundred other pictures circulating social networks showing a group of people sitting around a table in a restaurant, all staring down at their phones.

It's making a pretty banal point. It's arguing about trivialities when Rome is burning. These blackouts are not just temporary effects of a once in a hundred years earth quake but are symptoms of a systemic, structural and long term disease of the power supply. I'd say there are more worrying things than smartphones and "social media". (I speak this as a hater of social media and a feature phone owner.)
 
Relax. The article isn't trying to tell you that it's okay not to have power, but is rather commenting on how reliant we have become on it in areas where perhaps we shouldn't. It's no different to a hundred other pictures circulating social networks showing a group of people sitting around a table in a restaurant, all staring down at their phones.

I get it that its a commentary on peoples lifestyle choices, but what irks me is that people assume their viewpoint is the only such viewpoint (and I am referring to in general) and that everyone has to abide by it. By all means if you want to live with less power or less technology you are welcome to do so but not everyone has the same aspirations.
 
And as long as power cuts are very short maybe it's not such a big deal but then why is it a big deal for a small business which relies on refrigeration?

An observation. Checkers in Cresta dont power their fridges during load balancing. I assume the fridges draw too much power from the generators and its probably a calculated risk on their part. But I do wonder about the warming up and cooling down of meats repeatedly and if that is any good.
 
An observation. Checkers in Cresta dont power their fridges during load balancing. I assume the fridges draw too much power from the generators and its probably a calculated risk on their part. But I do wonder about the warming up and cooling down of meats repeatedly and if that is any good.

It probably depends on how much they warm up. So Checkers may need to keep them "super cooled" if possible when there is no load shedding. That way the 2-3 or more degree rise during the blackout is not going to put the meat in a temperature zone where bacteria start to become metabolically active again.

Organisations which need to keep products always within a certain range need to run on generators and UPSes. Some products such as some medicines must be kept within a narrow range. In that case such businesses must have generators to take care of any unforeseen power cuts anyway. There are usually temp monitors which log all temp changes and even report live when these approach out of range values.
 
Iqbal bs baffles a lot of brains. Not all of us are baffled.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X