Outsurance

Annie S

New Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2026
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Hi, I am hoping I can get advice on this forum. My headlights were stolen from my VW Tiguan, they did not do a huge amount of damage, some dents in the side panels near the light and a small dent in the bonnet. Outsurance is my insurer. They towed away the car and gave me an assessment, which had some parts quite a bit more expensive than the quote I got from GoldWagen and they included things like coolant etc. I believe it was done to make sure it was just slightly more costly ( R 4000) than the percentage value of the car so they can "write it off" so to speak, although they admit in the assessment that the car is driveable and can be fixed ( It was driven from the place where the the incident happened (Delta Park if you are interested - avoid parking there, this is common there, so I learned). They want to pay me out a sum, and agreed to tow it to my panel beater. they have now said I don't get the car insurance, which is quite incredible as I will be without my car while it is getting fixed and I pay insurance for these services. I am very unhappy and wonder if there is any recourse I have - has anyone got any ideas? I would be happy to use Outsurance panel beaters but they now have no choice and i am so mad, and they are so difficult on the phone as well. I told them to wait for me today as i wanted to think about it overnight but it seems thay have moved forward, so i am even more mad. Any advice?
 
I have thought long and hard about your situation and this is what I recommend.


You have several practical steps to challenge the assessment and settlement terms, starting with a formal dispute through OUTsurance and escalation to the National Financial Ombud if needed. [1, 2, 3]

Why This Happens
    • Write-off calculation: Insurers determine a write-off when repair costs exceed the vehicle's insured value less its salvage value—not simply because a car is driveable. Consumables like coolant and minor dents are routinely included in repair assessments. [1]
    • Car hire rules: Under OUTsurance policies, car hire is typically an optional add-on rather than automatic comprehensive cover, and courtesy/rental cover generally applies to repairs rather than total-loss payouts. Check your policy schedule to confirm whether car hire is active. [1, 2, 3, 4]

Steps You Can Take
    • Put everything in writing: Stop relying solely on phone calls. Email the claims handler to state clearly that you did not agree to finalise the settlement and put the claim on hold pending a dispute.
    • Challenge the assessment figures: Submit your written Goldwagen quote and ask for an itemized breakdown of the insurer's parts pricing, labour, and consumables. Note any unjustified or inflated line items that pushed the figure over the threshold.
    • Request an internal complaint escalation: Ask OUTsurance's formal complaints or disputes team to review the assessment and the decision to move ahead without your sign-off. [1]
    • Escalate to the NFO: If OUTsurance does not resolve the dispute satisfactorily, lodge a free complaint with the National Financial Ombud (which absorbed the Ombudsman for Short-Term Insurance) along with your policy schedule, assessment report, Goldwagen quote, and call/email records. [1, 2]
    • Consider repair vs. settlement: If the vehicle is written off, note that OUTsurance takes salvage ownership and generally discourages or restricts private repairs, so weigh the net payout (after excess and any finance settlement) against replacing the Tiguan. [1, 2]

To help narrow down your best next move, share:
  • Whether car hire is listed on your policy schedule
  • Whether the Tiguan is financed or paid off
  • The insured value vs. the assessed repair cost
I can help you draft a formal dispute email or outline how to structure an NFO complaint.
 
Sincerely, please, paragraphs. It's Friday :(
Hi, I am hoping I can get advice on this forum. My headlights were stolen from my VW Tiguan, they did not do a huge amount of damage, some dents in the side panels near the light and a small dent in the bonnet.

Outsurance is my insurer. They towed away the car and gave me an assessment, which had some parts quite a bit more expensive than the quote I got from GoldWagen and they included things like coolant etc.

I believe it was done to make sure it was just slightly more costly ( R 4000) than the percentage value of the car so they can "write it off" so to speak, although they admit in the assessment that the car is driveable and can be fixed ( It was driven from the place where the the incident happened (Delta Park if you are interested - avoid parking there, this is common there, so I learned).

They want to pay me out a sum, and agreed to tow it to my panel beater. they have now said I don't get the car insurance, which is quite incredible as I will be without my car while it is getting fixed and I pay insurance for these services.

I am very unhappy and wonder if there is any recourse I have - has anyone got any ideas? I would be happy to use Outsurance panel beaters but they now have no choice and i am so mad, and they are so difficult on the phone as well.

I told them to wait for me today as i wanted to think about it overnight but it seems thay have moved forward, so i am even more mad. Any advice?
 
My headlights were stolen from my VW Tiguan, they did not do a huge amount of damage, some dents in the side panels near the light and a small dent in the bonnet. Outsurance is my insurer. They towed away the car and gave me an assessment, which had some parts quite a bit more expensive than the quote I got from GoldWagen and they included things like coolant etc. I believe it was done to make sure it was just slightly more costly ( R 4000) than the percentage value of the car so they can "write it off" so to speak, although they admit in the assessment that the car is driveable and can be fixed ( It was driven from the place where the the incident happened (Delta Park if you are interested - avoid parking there, this is common there, so I learned). They want to pay me out a sum, and agreed to tow it to my panel beater. they have now said I don't get the car insurance, which is quite incredible as I will be without my car while it is getting fixed and I pay insurance for these services. I am very unhappy and wonder if there is any recourse I have - has anyone got any ideas? I would be happy to use Outsurance panel beaters but they now have no choice and i am so mad, and they are so difficult on the phone as well. I told them to wait for me today as i wanted to think about it overnight but it seems thay have moved forward, so i am even more mad.
Year of manufacture?
Insured value?
Basis of settlement for car? Comprehensive I assume?
Quote price from Gold Wagon? What is the quote price to fix your car per OS / assessor / panel beater?
Why coolants? Was there other damage?
What do you mean by "I don't get the car insurance"?
 
See what we put up with every day?

And then people wonder why brokers and insurers are the way they are.
 
Hi, I am hoping I can get advice on this forum. My headlights were stolen from my VW Tiguan, they did not do a huge amount of damage, some dents in the side panels near the light and a small dent in the bonnet. Outsurance is my insurer. They towed away the car and gave me an assessment, which had some parts quite a bit more expensive than the quote I got from GoldWagen and they included things like coolant etc. I believe it was done to make sure it was just slightly more costly ( R 4000) than the percentage value of the car so they can "write it off" so to speak, although they admit in the assessment that the car is driveable and can be fixed ( It was driven from the place where the the incident happened (Delta Park if you are interested - avoid parking there, this is common there, so I learned). They want to pay me out a sum, and agreed to tow it to my panel beater. they have now said I don't get the car insurance, which is quite incredible as I will be without my car while it is getting fixed and I pay insurance for these services. I am very unhappy and wonder if there is any recourse I have - has anyone got any ideas? I would be happy to use Outsurance panel beaters but they now have no choice and i am so mad, and they are so difficult on the phone as well. I told them to wait for me today as i wanted to think about it overnight but it seems thay have moved forward, so i am even more mad. Any advice?
Sorry, that's a rotten way to lose a car. I built a tool that reads insurance policies, and I've read OUTsurance's personal policy wording (V23.02.26), so a few pointers. Check them against your own schedule. The write-off: the wording says "We have the choice to settle your claim in any of the following ways" (cash, repair or replacement), and "if it is written-off we will pay the OUTsured value". So paying out is allowed, but the numbers behind it can be questioned. Ask in writing for the assessment, the repair total and the threshold they used, and send them your dealer quote. The hire car: it's optional cover, so check your schedule first. If you have it, it covers a car damaged and being repaired, and "The hired car is available for a maximum period of 30 days or until your claim is finalised if it is within the 30 day period." Ask them to explain in writing why it doesn't apply. If you disagree, you have "90 days from the day you are first informed of the outcome to notify us about your objection". Happy to look at your schedule if you'd like.
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X