Rand is overvalued, says IMF.

PeterCH

Honorary Master
Joined
Aug 8, 2005
Messages
18,371
Reaction score
3
Location
Cape Town
Rand overvalued, says IMF.
If that's the case, with it being at 12 to a Dollar, what can we expect?
15? 18? 20? It will go that low I think. So if you have foreign reserve,
keep it, you may need it.

IMF says rand 'overvalued'
Oct 22 2008 16:48
Washington - The International Monetary Fund has said on Wednesday that the rand may be overvalued.

The IMF said South Africa's floating exchange-rate policy was helping shelter it from external shocks but noted there were questions about the value of its currency.

"While acknowledging the considerable uncertainty surrounding estimates of the equilibrium value of the currency, directors took note of the staff's tentative assessment that the currency may be moderately overvalued," the IMF said in a review of SA's prospects.

The IMF's report was completed on August 15 2008.

By 18:10 the rand was bid at R11.2763/$ from a previous close of R10.6550. It was bid at R14.4810/€ from a previous R13.8936 and at R18.2403/£ from R17.7622 before.

South Africa faced intensifying inflation pressures that were making its economy more vulnerable to a downturn, the IMF added.

"In particular, global food and fuel price shocks have boosted inflation and the external current account deficit, while economic growth has slowed in the context of still-high levels of unemployment and inequality," the IMF said.

It also warned that a deteriorating economic outlook has heightened the risk that capital inflows to the country will slow down.

The IMF praised South Africa's government for practising what it described as sound macroeconomic policies and an open policy framework. "South Africa's economic fundamentals remain strong, the external debt is low, and the financial system is resilient," it said.

The IMF said that given the importance of sustaining investor confidence and the limited scope for raising private saving, the government needed to increase public saving "to bring the structural public sector borrowing requirement to zero over the next few years."

It suggested that the way to achieve that goal was to restrain current spending and to increase spending efficiency, including by seeking more public-private partnerships to work on needed infrastructure projects.

The IMF said it supported South African authorities' policy of gradually building up currency reserves.

http://www.fin24.co.za/articles/def...icle.aspx?ArticleId=1518-25_2414185&Type=News
 
Smells to me like another attempt to protect the dollar at the expense of the 3rd world.
 
The IMF can go fsck itself as far as I am concerned. What did they do to prevent the global credit crisis, when all the indicators were so clear that there was a crisis looming. Wait for it.... NOTHING, because those fat politicians were too busy stuffing their mouths.

How about first world countries looking in their own back yard first - the $ is way too overvalued at the moment.
 
The IMF can go fsck itself as far as I am concerned. What did they do to prevent the global credit crisis, when all the indicators were so clear that there was a crisis looming. Wait for it.... NOTHING, because those fat politicians were too busy stuffing their mouths.

How about first world countries looking in their own back yard first - the $ is way too overvalued at the moment.

You think? Who buys the minerals we export? What major manufacturing do
we do? What do we have to offer for investors?

I'm sorry but the Dollar is not undervalued. And while you may not care what the IMF says, potential investors listen to it.

Oh and Pakistan is not saying 'fsck you IMF' - they're saying singing a different tune.
http://www.fin24.co.za/articles/default/display_article.aspx?Nav=ns&ArticleID=1518-1783_2414163
 
Last edited:
<rant>
It's lost another 50 c to the dollar now at 11.87. How do we deal with this. Today I bought ten grand worth of stock, because I know that it will cost fifteen next month. Nothing fancy, basics like cable and connectors. How do we run businesses without knowing what our costs will be tomorrow? I'm ranting, but todays slide (over R1 to the dollar - 10% loss in a day) just scared me. Capex budgets cant keep up, things are being cut back. When are we going to recover?
<end rant>
 
<rant>
It's lost another 50 c to the dollar now at 11.87. How do we deal with this. Today I bought ten grand worth of stock, because I know that it will cost fifteen next month. Nothing fancy, basics like cable and connectors. How do we run businesses without knowing what our costs will be tomorrow? I'm ranting, but todays slide (over R1 to the dollar - 10% loss in a day) just scared me. Capex budgets cant keep up, things are being cut back. When are we going to recover?
<end rant>

We'll start to recover when our politicians start to take their job seriously, responsibly and actually think of the country first ahead of their own foreign bank accounts.

Maybe when we have less public spending and less mismanagement, less AA and BEE and less crime plus no stupid Leftist policies - and someone gags the SACP, maybe then the Rand's decline will slow down and maybe if we're lucky
we'll see it level off and stabilise around 13/14 to the Dollar and stay that way for the next 1-2 years.
 
I heard that a country needs to export more than they import and a weak rand will help our exports and make us competitive, which is good for the whole country.

Anyone care to enlighten me on this?
 
I heard that a country needs to export more than they import and a weak rand will help our exports and make us competitive, which is good for the whole country.

Anyone care to enlighten me on this?

Yes but we need imported oil and gas. We need imported manufactured goods. We can't just build stuff from our own sweat and what we dig up and grow from the soil. We need to import to be able to export. And as we import those things our manufacturing costs rise and we're definately not one of the most productive or cheapest countries out there for manufacturing.
Our minerals are no longer as valuable as before as demand drops, as Chinese and foreign companies reduce production....

I think we're way more st-ffed than the US, hence my remarks about the $ not being as overvalued as everything else. The US has 300 mil people- most of whom are educated and productive, what have we? We're about 10 million with the rest living in shacks and shanty towns and relying on the government for aid.
 
Last edited:
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X