Regulator slams Mail & Guardian report

ToxicBunny

Oi! Leave me out of this...
Joined
Apr 8, 2006
Messages
142,852
Reaction score
101,305
Location
Crimetown
Johannesburg - National Nuclear Regulator (NNR) chief executive Bismark Tyobeka on Friday described as irresponsible and reckless a newspaper report claiming a job was created for his wife at Necsa.

"We all have a democratic right to choose where we want to work, and that cannot be simply taken away because of some imaginary conflict of interest, merely aimed at selling more newspapers," Tyobeka said in a statement, referring to a Mail & Guardian report.

He confirmed in a statement on Friday that his wife, Ngeniswa Tyobeka, had been appointed as a junior HR business partner at the Nuclear Energy Corporation of SA (Necsa).

"The... position is a support function, which does not in any way contribute to issues of nuclear regulation and safety, so, immediately, conflict of interest does not arise," he said.

A whistle-blower reportedly told the newspaper that Necsa hired her for a position that "did not exist on the approved Necsa organisational structure".

The whistle-blower claimed the position was "unbudgeted and unfunded, which translates into [an] irregular appointment and unauthorised expenditure".

The NNR is responsible for national regulatory framework to protect people, property and the environment against nuclear damage.

The Mail & Guardian reported that the appointment could cloud his judgement when he made decisions regarding Necsa, which paid his wife a R490 000 annual salary.

Ngeniswa was appointed to Necsa last year, her husband had been the head of the NNR since 2013.

"The NNR... is not a one man show, as the M&G would like the public to believe. There are adequate checks and balances to ensure that the decisions taken are transparent and based on sound technical basis," Bismark Tyobeka said.

NNR inspectors were empowered by the NNR Act to enforce compliance without consulting the CEO, he said.

"The role of the CEO only comes into the picture when such a decision is being appealed by the operator.... So to portray the CEO of the NNR as having unfettered unilateral powers to shut down an operator is simply fallacious."

He said his brother had worked at management in Necsa since 1992.

"Does this mean I should not have accepted the position of CEO of NNR because my brother works there?" he asked.

‘Growing salary bill’

The whistle-blower reportedly told the newspaper that Necsa had a shortfall of R82m this month, partly due to a "growing salary bill" caused by "unbudgeted and unfunded created [job] vacancies".

Necsa criticised the disclosure of the company's private information.

"We deplore the unethical disclosure [of] Necsa's private information apparently by some staff members and others who have access to it, mainly for the purposes of slander," it said.

Necsa said Ngeniswa was appointed "in a process of aligning the organisational structure with the strategy approved by the board".

Necsa's corporate services divisional executive Xolisa Mabhongo was described in the report as being "very close friends" with the Tyobekas.

Mabhongo apparently met the couple in Vienna, Austria, during his tenure as South African ambassador to the country between 2010 and 2014.

Bismark Tyobeka said his wife had worked at the South African embassy, under Mabhongo.

Ngeniswa Tyobeka currently worked in the corporate services department, where Mabhongo was an executive.

"Mrs Tyobeka applied for positions at Necsa long before the arrival of Mr Mabhongo," Necsa said in a statement.

"By the time Mr Mabhongo joined Necsa, Mrs Tyobeka's appointment was already at a very advanced stage with interviews and panel discussions concluded."

She was interviewed twice at Necsa in November 2013 for a different post. She was interviewed again in February 2014 for the position she was currently in.

She joined Necsa on 6 June 2014, the company said.

http://www.news24.com/SouthAfrica/News/Regulator-slams-Mail-Guardian-report-20150306

I would like to know what kind of "Junior HR Business partner" earns R490k per year in an real company. Fscking muppets... really.
 
"Johannesburg - National Nuclear Regulator (NNR) chief executive Bismark Tyobeka on Friday described as irresponsible and reckless a newspaper report claiming a job was created for his wife at Necsa.

"We all have a democratic right to choose where we want to work, and that cannot be simply taken away because of some imaginary conflict of interest, merely aimed at selling more newspapers," Tyobeka said in a statement, referring to a Mail & Guardian report."

I do not think this idiot knows what the word Nepotism means .

Just in case he reads this here is the wiki "Nepotism is favoritism granted in politics or business to relatives. The term originated with the assignment of nephews to cardinal positions by Catholic popes and bishops. Nepotism is found in various fields including: politics, entertainment, business, and religion."

This idiot should be fired .
 
Last edited:
PRESS OMBUD RULES IN FAVOUR OF M&G

The Press Ombudsman on Monday ruled in favour of the Mail & Guardian following a complaint laid by National Nuclear Regulator CEO Bismark Tyobeka.

Tyobeka claimed an article written by the weekly's reporter, Lionel Faull, falsely reported that an HR position had been created at the Nuclear Energy Corporation of SA (Necsa) for his wife, Ngeniswa. Necsa is an entity regulated by NNR.

Tyobeka complained that the paper suggested he had used his influence and an alleged friendship with Necsa's corporate services divisional executive, Xolisa Mabhongo, to secure her appointment.

Delivering his ruling, press ombudsman Johan Retief said the Mail & Guardian story did not state as a fact that a position was created for Ngeniswa Tyobeka, but it quoted a source to this effect.

None of the evidence provided by Necsa proved that they had refuted the claims and Necsa had indeed stated that it had created new positions including in support functions.

"I concluded that Faull was justified in publishing his source's opinion as an opinion. It would have been a different matter if he had stated it as a fact," Retief said in his judgment.

Commenting on the Tyobeka's relationship with Mabhongo, Retief said it was not relevant.

"Of crucial importance is the fact that Faull did not state the alleged friendship as a fact- he merely reported this allegation by the whistle-blower as an allegation," he said.

Tyobeka had complained that Faull made no serious effort to verify his facts and that he relied on information given by a whistleblower.

Retief disagreed and said Faull did not omit any matter of substantial importance gained from responses he received from all the parties involved.

Source : Sapa /nsm/ks
Date : 23 Mar 2015 22:23
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X