SA grocery sector faces competition probe

MickeyD

RIP
Joined
Oct 4, 2010
Messages
139,095
Reaction score
432
Location
Nelson Mandela Bay
Johannesburg – The Competition Commission will probe South Africa’s four large supermarket chains, their effect on small retailers and the impact of their long-term exclusive leases with landlords.

The wide-ranging probe will include informal businesses and look at the dynamics between local and foreign-owned small retailers in townships, according to the terms of reference published in Friday’s Government Gazette.

“The commission is initiating the grocery retail sector inquiry, because it has reason to believe there are features in the sector that may prevent, distort or restrict competition,” it reads.

The movement of large supermarket chains into townships, mainly in shopping malls, had led to a significant decrease in business for nearby informal businesses. According to a study by the Bureau of Market Research in Soshanguve near Pretoria, 75% of informal traders reported a drop in profits within six months of a new mall opening within 1km of their business.

The four large retailers account for more than 90% of the market.

The declining number of small businesses could have an adverse impact on employment, income levels and the spread of ownership in the sector, according to research cited in the terms of reference.

The commission would look at how exclusive clauses in lease agreements retailers signed with landlords affected smaller businesses, as they were prevented from opening shop in the same mall.

“These restrictions tend to mostly affect small and independent retailers who may not be in a position to attract customers if located outside the shopping centre or mall,”

Violence, directed mainly at foreign-owned shop owners, during xenophobic violence earlier this year, was another reason for the probe. Foreign-owned shops were perceived to be more successful, for reasons still not clear.

“This has led to tensions that have sparked into violence in some instances.”

Interested parties had 15 days from Friday to make inputs and comment on the terms of reference.

Thomas Hartleb, News24

Source: http://www.fin24.com/Economy/SA-grocery-sector-faces-competition-probe-20150612
 
Yeah my gardener says the small shops near him is so competitive charging double for bread that checkers does... lets investigate the big grocery stores!
 
Three bread companies are still screwing us so not holding my breath. They should rather look at how stuff go up at the same time. Competition see Moer.
 
There is Def a need to investigate the large retailers and their impact on the pricing of goods... but the terms of this current investigation seem misguided to me. It's not the retailers fault that ppl would rather shop in a mall than at some local shop.
 
And what happens if found guilty?

1. pay fine
2. increase prices
3. new fixing scheme
4. customers wins!
 
The movement of large supermarket chains into townships, mainly in shopping malls, had led to a significant decrease in business for nearby informal businesses. According to a study by the Bureau of Market Research in Soshanguve near Pretoria, 75% of informal traders reported a drop in profits within six months of a new mall opening within 1km of their business.

This does not even require an understanding of economics, it falls under common sense. Is the CC made up entirely of SACP members?

As for foreign-owned township stores being perceived as more successful, it is because they are more successful. Their entrepreneurial skills and work ethic are gained outside South Africa, and therefore are superior to those of township residents.

The shocking fact that foreign-owned versus locally-owned township stores fall within the scope of a government Competition Commission, again illustrates that xenophobia is very much the result of government and SAPS policies. At what level would ethnicity/race/nationality or country of birth be a matter for the government to calculate a competitive environment? Such a probe is discriminatory and racist by its very basis.
 
Last edited:
Important part

Violence, directed mainly at foreign-owned shop owners, during xenophobic violence earlier this year, was another reason for the probe. Foreign-owned shops were perceived to be more successful, for reasons still not clear.
 
So if township shops independently owned by immigrants born in foreign countries are found to be more successful than those owned by people born in SA, then what? That is anti-competitive? Wtf?
 
There is Def a need to investigate the large retailers and their impact on the pricing of goods... but the terms of this current investigation seem misguided to me. It's not the retailers fault that ppl would rather shop in a mall than at some local shop.

Yes, cant have them low prices, better to have them R20 2l cokes than those R15.99 2l Cokes...
 
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X