Squid vs IPCOP vs ???

AstroTurf

AstroTurf

Lucky Shot
Joined
May 13, 2010
Messages
32,113
Reaction score
6,119
Hi,

Never used the above for very long periods of time.

We have been using Wingate but due to needing log parsing that it does not supply I am considering a change.

What I need from the proxy:

Authentication of users (Currently using NTLM but do not mind if I have to create a separate Internet user database on the proxy).
All the usual protocols (http SSL, FTP, SOCKS etc).
The ability to parse log files and to log user activity. (I would like to print/save reports on user activity).
Proxy Server.
Ability to block ports, open ports, (during certain hours would help).
open certain sites for certain users while blocking for the rest of the users.
Ability to block sites by time (I open the net for our users during tea,lunch and after hours).
Secure, I do not want to open holes for outside attacks.
Easy set up and little maintenance.

What would you suggest?
 
gonna make a vm quick and see if it does what I want, Thanks for the suggestion :)
 
I have used Smoothwall Express and Untangle for my clients and they are both great products ...... and free. :)

I particularly like the feature in Untangle of emailed reports on a daily, weekly and monthly basis.
Great feature when clients don't have the time to manage their network and internet usage.
I get the reports mailed to me and any anomalies I advise them. Builds great customer relationships.
 
Zeroshell is a Linux distribution for servers and embedded devices aimed at providing the main network services a LAN requires. It is available in the form of Live CD or Compact Flash image and you can configure and administer it using your web browser. The main features of this Linux distribution for Network Appliances are:

  • Load Balancing and Failover of multiple Internet connections;
  • UMTS/HSDPA connections by using 3G modems;
  • RADIUS server for providing secure authentication and automatic management of the encryption keys to the Wireless 802.11b, 802.11g and 802.11a networks supporting the 802.1x protocol in the EAP-TLS, EAP-TTLS and PEAP form or the less secure authentication of the client MAC Address; WPA with TKIP and WPA2 with CCMP (802.11i complaint) are supported too; the RADIUS server may also, depending on the username, group or MAC Address of the supplicant, allow the access on a preset 802.1Q VLAN;
  • Captive Portal to support the web login on wireless and wired networks. Zeroshell acts as gateway for the networks on which the Captive Portal is active and on which the IP addresses (usually belonging to private subnets) are dynamically assigned by the DHCP. A client that accesses this private network must authenticate itself through a web browser using Kerberos 5 username and password before the Zeroshell's firewall allows it to access the public LAN. The Captive Portal gateways are often used to provide authenticated Internet access in the HotSpots in alternative to the 802.1X authentication protocol too complicated to configure for the users. Zeroshell implements the functionality of Captive Portal in native way, without using other specific software as NoCat or Chillispot;
  • QoS (Quality of Service) management and traffic shaping to control traffic over a congested network. You will be able to guarantee the minimum bandwidth, limit the max bandwidth and assign a priority to a traffic class (useful in latency-sensitive network applications like VoIP). The previous tuning can be applied on Ethernet Interfaces, VPNs, bridges and VPN bondings. It is possible to classify the traffic by using the Layer 7 filters that allow the Deep Packet Inspection (DPI) which can be useful to shape VoIP and P2P applications;
  • HTTP Proxy server which is able to block the web pages containing virus. This feature is implemented using the ClamAV antivirus and HAVP proxy server. The proxy server works in transparent proxy mode, in which, you don't need to configure the web browsers of the users to use it, but the http requests will be automatically redirected to the proxy;
  • Wireless Access Point mode with Multiple SSID and VLAN support by using WiFi network cards based on the Atheros chipsets. In other words, a Zeroshell box with one of such WiFi cards could become a IEEE 802.11a/b/g Access Point providing reliable authentication and dynamic keys exchange by 802.1X and WPA protocols. Of course, the authentication takes place using EAP-TLS and PEAP over the integrated RADIUS server;
  • Host-to-lan VPN with L2TP/IPsec in which L2TP (Layer 2 Tunneling Protocol) authenticated with Kerberos v5 username and password is encapsulated within IPsec authenticated with IKE that uses X.509 certificates;
  • Lan-to-lan VPN with encapsulation of Ethernet datagrams in SSL/TLS tunnel, with support for 802.1Q VLAN and configurable in bonding for load balancing (band increase) or fault tolerance (reliability increase);
  • Router with static and dynamic routes (RIPv2 with MD5 or plain text authentication and Split Horizon and Poisoned Reverse algorithms);
  • 802.1d bridge with Spanning Tree protocol to avoid loops even in the presence of redundant paths;
  • 802.1Q Virtual LAN (tagged VLAN);
  • Firewall Packet Filter and Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) with filters applicable in both routing and bridging on all type of interfaces including VPN and VLAN;
  • It is possible to reject or shape P2P File Sharing traffic by using IPP2P iptables module in the Firewall and QoS Classifier;
  • NAT to use private class LAN addresses hidden on the WAN with public addresses;
  • TCP/UDP port forwarding (PAT) to create Virtual Servers. This means that real server cluster will be seen with only one IP address (the IP of the virtual server) and each request will be distributed with Round Robin algorithm to the real servers;
  • Multizone DNS server with automatic management of the Reverse Resolution in-addr.arpa;
  • Multi subnet DHCP server with the possibility to fix IP depending on client's MAC address;
  • PPPoE client for connection to the WAN via ADSL, DSL and cable lines (requires a suitable MODEM);
  • Dynamic DNS client used to easily reach the host on WAN even when the IP is dynamic;
  • NTP (Network Time Protocol) client and server for keeping host clocks synchronized;
  • Syslog server for receiving and cataloging the system logs produced by the remote hosts including Unix systems, routers, switches, WI-FI access points, network printers and others compatible with the syslog protocol;
  • Kerberos 5 authentication using an integrated KDC and cross-authentication between realms;
  • LDAP, NIS and RADIUS authorization;
  • X509 certification authority for issuing and managing electronic certificates;
  • Unix and Windows Active Directory interoperability using LDAP and Kerberos 5 cross realm authentication.
 
ITCynic said:
I have used Smoothwall Express and Untangle for my clients and they are both great products ...... and free. :)

I particularly like the feature in Untangle of emailed reports on a daily, weekly and monthly basis.
Great feature when clients don't have the time to manage their network and internet usage.
I get the reports mailed to me and any anomalies I advise them. Builds great customer relationships.
Click to expand...

Also doesnt have squid. Proxies are pretty important.
 
Smoothwall isn't that great IMO

IPCOP is great & awesome, but lacks a lot of things as well.

Endian is suppose to be the best of Smoothwall and IPCOP combined, but from recent experience with it, I wouldn't really recommend it. ( and it doesn't have PPTP out of the box )

ClearOS has a lot of features, but I don't really like it's interface because in my experience it was slow, on a not-that-bad box. After a while I had to restart it every now and then. But it's features wasn't that bad. Very good with PPTP / OpenVPN etc
 
deepdiver said:
IPCOP is pretty cool
I would really recommend PFsense
it has everything that smooth wall has and an awesome interface.
New version is out now with added cool features
2.0_New_Features_and_Changes
Click to expand...

I tried PFSense last week on Hyper-V. I could never shutdown or reboot the VM machine, status just kept saying "stopping". Also had problems with the interfaces just freezing, and because I couldn't reboot PFSense, I had to reboot the whole Windows machine.

Back to running IPCop. Easy to setup and easy to maintain. Plus everything works perfectly. :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top
Sign up to the MyBroadband newsletter
X